How to report cheaters?

Here is enough space for all players to ask questions about the game.

Moderator: moderators

Guest

Post by Guest »

Halee-Burton wrote:I keep running across these threads about "cheating" and trying to understand what the rules are exactly. I am in the US, so I haven't been able to find the answers in the FAQ or game rules of my version.

The thing that bothers me a little, is the lack of clarity in the actual rules, I would like to hear more than... we have ways of knowing if you're 'cheating', and if you're 'cheating' we will ban you from the game. It would be nice to know, what exactly IS 'cheating' first!

This is a market simulation game, it is supposed to represent the actual market place (I assume), and people buy and sell goods at all kinds of high and low prices, for all kinds of reasons, in the real market. Part of 'capitalism' is being in the right place at the right time, and making smart and informed business decisions. If I have researched a product and know its value on the market, and I see an ad for the product at less than what I know it's worth, why should I be branded a 'cheater' for taking advantage of a capitalist opportunity? Doesn't my knowledge and understanding of the market and value of the product count for something? Doesn't my diligence in watching the market account for something? How is this 'cheating'? I understand some people might be jealous that I got such a good deal because I clicked faster than they did, but that is not cause to label me as a 'cheater' or report me for breaking some rule that I don't even know about.

I saw an example given yesterday, about a company selling steel for .01, and everyone was upset about it, but hey... If I had seen steel on the market for .01, you don't think I would have bought it too? You wouldn't? I don't see how this is 'cheating' in any way, it's free enterprise at its best! Someone said, he was obviously trying to "ruin the market" but that didn't ruin the steel market, it only lasted until his steel supply was exhausted, and that was it. Now, someone else in turn made a huge profit, but so what? This happens in the real world every day! The early bird gets the worm????

I understand there is a way people can cheat. I also understand there is a way to track IP's and discover those who cheat. I don't understand how legitimate business transactions, regardless of price/profit, can be deemed "cheating" unless there is a specific written rule, which I have not seen as of yet. I would like to know an answer to this from the KapiGod's, if it's not too much to ask.

I think that what has been said is that some one who offers vast amounts of one type of material at below market prices when from their company profile cant possibly have "made or brought" the stock is cheating if goods are offered at EG steel for .01c then either that company wont last more than a day or and i think this would be the answer they made a mistake on pricing cheaters for me are people who make a vast amount of money from goods that they can not have produced or purchased. everyone needs to watch and report any company that is trading way above their available assets/cash.
Guest

Post by Guest »

It is the third time this evening that I found more than 6000 steel sold at 0.01 on the market...
Tycoon
Moderator off duty
Posts: 1911
Joined: 21.01.2007, 11:04

Post by Tycoon »

It won*t help if you post such a sentence here:
the second post in this thread says: write a pm to one of the mods...

If you do so: copy the market offers and send them to us. You can be sure that we will pass such messages on to the programmers immediately.

But just a sentence: I saw... offers for... are not sufficient...
Guest

Post by Guest »

how are the contracts controlled?
Guest

Post by Guest »

Going back to a small note,
Tycoon wrote:Or if e.g. there are 2 (or more) companys with the same ip, they are not allowed to do trade with each others. So they use the market and not a direct contract.
My roommate and I just discovered Kapiland last week and have gone nuts (gone nuts= maybe about 6 resets each? Buying buildings is dangerously fun :wink: ).

Anyway, we were planning (until I read this post) to do contracts with each other (I've got a well and power station, basically) at a basic price (ie. only slightly higher than producing cost). Is this always cheating? I could offer power at 0.02 to anyone, technically.

If it, couldn't the mods separate cheaters at the same ip address by whether the contract makes sense (we are helping each other, not moving large cash amounts for 1 power/water between the accounts).[/quote]
Tycoon
Moderator off duty
Posts: 1911
Joined: 21.01.2007, 11:04

Post by Tycoon »

The problem is, that this checking of the single contracts between the same ips just takes too much time....

I think there are so many other partners you can trade with...
Guest

Post by Guest »

If I may, I think it's unfortunate but necessary. RL people (roomates, couples, siblings, etc) would naturally want to be trading with each other. But it looks too much like 1 person with 2 accounts - which is too close to 1 person with a double-size company.

That would clearly be cheating not only because the game gives such a generous head-start, but because it gets around things like the limit on building slots as well.
Guest

Post by Guest »

1,000 Gas danubio 4 15.00 15,000.00 buy
1,000 Gas danubio 4 15.00 15,000.00 buy
1,000 Gas danubio 4 15.00 15,000.00 buy
1,000 Gas danubio 4 15.00 15,000.00 buy
1,000 Gas danubio 4 15.00 15,000.00 buy
1,000 Gas danubio 3 14.50 14,500.00 buy
1,000 Gas danubio 3 14.50 14,500.00 buy
1,000 Gas danubio 3 14.50 14,500.00 buy
800 Gas danubio 3 14.50 11,600.00 buy
100 Textiles danubio 0 162.50 16,250.00 buy
100 Textiles danubio 0 162.50 16,250.00 buy
100 Textiles danubio 0 162.50 16,250.00 buy
100 Textiles danubio 0 162.50 16,250.00 buy
100 Textiles danubio 0 162.50 16,250.00 buy

1,000 Wood company full 4 51.00 51,000.00 buy
1,000 Wood company full 4 51.00 51,000.00 buy
1,000 Wood company full 4 51.00 51,000.00 buy
1,000 Wood company full 4 51.00 51,000.00 buy
1,000 Wood company full 4 51.00 51,000.00 buy
1,000 Wood company full 4 51.00 51,000.00 buy
1,000 Wood company full 4 51.00 51,000.00 buy
1,000 Wood company full 6 58.00 58,000.00 buy

350,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 35,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy
500,000 Power company sony 0 0.10 50,000.00 buy

company: company sony
cash: 6,822,577.10
fixed assets: 8,587,500.00
score: 40.00
last login: 22.07.07

company: company full
cash: 776,964.91
fixed assets: 7,642,500.00
score: 40.00
last login: 22.07.07

company: danubio
cash: 3,550,589.88
fixed assets: 10,449,500.00
score: 23.00
last login: 22.07.07

--------------

An obvious cheater,
company full, company sony
often in multi players are not creative enough to think up new names so just use variations on the same name, which I'm sure you will know.

plus posting all the goods, the exact same time, the exact say way, ironically in multiples, round numbers, within minutes of each other.

all have around the same money and score,
I don't even play for score yet, many do not.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Tycoon wrote:The problem is, that this checking of the single contracts between the same ips just takes too much time....

I think there are so many other partners you can trade with...
no, you could set it up so if a player has the same IP, it simply won't sell.
of course some people can hide their IP but you could make it a rule that you have to have an IP# to play.
But then again, some players, I think get a different IP# ever time they log on. I think I have that since I have DSL, not sure.
Plus some players can use a proxy to get a different IP#.

But it is like keeping somebody from breaking into your house,
if they really want to get in they will,
but make it very difficult to lessen the amount and frequency and make it such a big pain in the ass they rather go somewhere else easier.
to reduce the averages or in this case, incidences.
Guest

Post by Guest »

more

1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00

Also, I'd like to add, in addition to listing all his stuff the exact same way under different company names, they all seem to be over priced as well.
Guest

Post by Guest »

dbsuma wrote:
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
OK, I'll be stupid -- how does this suggest cheating? I understand it's annoying, well, it annoys ME, anyway, but what's the difference if it's put it on the market as one lot of 11000 units of cotton, or 11 lots of 1000 units?

I hope I'm not being TOO stupid here, but I've learned there are almost no limits to my stupidity ;)
Guest

Post by Guest »

Merhouse wrote:
dbsuma wrote:
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
1,000 Cotton RosetYurd Sdn Bhd 0 45.00 45,000.00
OK, I'll be stupid -- how does this suggest cheating? I understand it's annoying, well, it annoys ME, anyway, but what's the difference if it's put it on the market as one lot of 11000 units of cotton, or 11 lots of 1000 units?

I hope I'm not being TOO stupid here, but I've learned there are almost no limits to my stupidity ;)
Well, if you know anything about multi-cheaters, which I do, then you'd know this person is cheating.

somebody who is a multi typically creates new account after new account, to funnel the goods that came with the account to his main account.
they rarely ever keep the account past the first day but it seems in this came they have.

They really give themselves away, getting too tired to thinking up new names to name their company that is only a shill for the main account, the soon start creating more obvious names.
As a fictitious example,

Fred_Co
Fred_co2
Fred_co3
Fred_co4
Fred_co5
Fred_co6
Fred_co7
Fred_co8
Freds_store
Freds_goods
Freds_company
Freds_stuff
Freda
Fredb
Fredc
Fredd
frede
Fredy
Fredz
Fredfred
fredfredfred
fred
freed
freeed
freeeed
freeeeed
freeeeeed
afred
bfredd
dfred
cfred
efred

etc, etc, etc,

This is just an fake example as I had previously searched the stats/score pages for such multi accounts and most of the more obvious have been removed that I had posted about but the mods of this game said that they don't want multi hunters on this site, so I stopped looking.

but I'll page back really far again, just to find a few real examples for you.

farel
fborel
forel
ferel
fcorel
fnorel

goka
gokb
gokc
godd
goke

zu
zui
zuio

ryba
ryba1
ryba2
ryba3
ryba4
ryba5

and it goes on and one the further back you look,
it becomes especially obvious on those sites that have members lists that are listed by the day joined.
it is astronomically improbable that such similarly named companies all joined on the same day, if not within hours or minutes of each other, so it is an indicator that they are multi cheaters.

As it is here on Kapilands, all those players with a score of 0 are all listed together, if you get a score you are taken out of sequential order, which I take it must be account number, thereby being the order joined, so again becomes even more obvious when these accounts joined in such close chronological order.

as in the example of
Rank: 4598 - Company name: 1
Rank: 4599 - Company name: 2
Rank: 4600 - Company name: 3
Rank: 5601 - Company name: 4
Rank: 5602 - Company name: 5
Rank: 5273 - Company name: 6
Rank: 5274 - Company name: 7
Rank: 5275 - Company name: 8
Rank: 5276 - Company name: 9
Rank: 5277 - Company name: 10

And keeps going that way up to 31.
Then yes, this person is obviously a multi cheater.

It would be different if it was;
Rank: 452 - Company name: Smith co
Rank:9812 - Company name: Smith co2
where it is obvious they are so far apart in time they were created by different people.
That is just a fictitious listing as well, since I still can't find my company name on the score board, which is how all this began, here anyways.

There currently is 75,131 accounts on Kapilands, if you wanna take the time to page threw them all I'm sure you could find more examples.

Like;
Rank: 74934 - Company name: DomCop
Rank: 74935 - Company name: Domsoft
Rank: 74948 - Company name: biklar inc
Rank: 74949 - Company name: niklar inc

Probably both created last night.

So when you see a company named "Company full" and "Company Sony",
both of which, if I remember correctly where on my previous list of multi cheaters. When you see them together like this, posting the exact same way, in multiples, in all round numbers, with all slightly overpriced items, at the exact same time, which in minutes of each other, then yes, it is a pretty good bet that they are multi accounts, from the explanation above.

so the the first indicator would be the company came being so close.
Of course in this case this multi has simply escaped being listed sequentially by just getting a score on the scoreboard, taking him out of the level 0 listing, but that is irrelevant in this case.

other than this multi cheater was both lucky enough and stupid enough to get the exact same score for both accounts.

Rank: 582
Score: 40
Company name: company full
last login: 24.07.07

Rank: 586
Score: 40
Company name: company sony
last login: 24.07.07

The second indicator would be the method of posting.
All round numbers of quantity,
All round numbers in price,
All slightly overpriced,
All in multiples,
All at the same time,

Then two other additional accounts also share these same characteristics,
"danubio", and "RosetYurd", that just happened to be online at the exact same time, posting the exact same way, in
All round numbers of quantity,
All round numbers in price,
All slightly overpriced,
All in multiples,
All at the same time,

Then it becomes obvious that these too are more of this persons multi accounts that he was cleaver enough to think of different names for.
Or so I would assume, perhaps these other two accounts are just from different days of multi account creating and you might also find a
danubio2
danubio3
danubio4
danubio5
danubia
danubib
danubic somewhere.

I only posted it cause it was outrageously obvious, which it usually is.
But unlike most internet game multi accounts really do little unless you are play for score then might get pissed off about them.
But if anything, here in Kapiland they add more goods to the market, however slightly overpriced they are.

But yes, in my opinion from previous experience as a multi hunter, these accounts where all made by the same person.

Some sites allow more than one account and not sure why this one doesn't other than people will use them to escape the building max.
With multi accounts here they ultimately become the same corporation under different names, they just have to pay service charges by trading with each other.

But then the problems become, if allowing multi accounts, people intentionally creating accounts just to feed their main accounts with the start up items, then never logging in to them again.
Or use their multi accounts as farms to raise money for their main account that is playing for score.
Not really fair.
But if the rule is not multi players, then these accounts should be removed.

And again, I have posted about this before but was that the mods of this game was not interested in these kinds of posts being made, so I stopped bothering with it, since it does little to impact by business.

But to answer your question,
That is why that is cheating.
Any questions?
Guest

Post by Guest »

Many WISP's and almost every internet cafe uses a single public IP NAT'ed via a router and then give all their clients private IP's. This No-trade rules between single IP will , sooner or later, cause problems to those playing from NAT'ed IP address.
I would suggest that a price floor be created for each product, and then sound the 'audit check' alarm whenever there is a contract issued below these price floors.
Guest

Post by Guest »

basically, the rules are written to be a guideline for players, most the people who have items like power on market for 50 caps each are either new to the game and did not take the tutorial, or are transferring money to a larger account, if you see something on the market for a very high price, or a very low price, you might just message them and alert them, because more then a few times i put a dot in the wrong place and put cattle on the market for 1000.0 each instead of 100.00, a person wrote me a IGM and told me it will never sell for that price, i bought it back from market and corrected the problem, this was when my fixed assets were only 1 million caps lol.
Guest

Post by Guest »

netnot wrote:Many WISP's and almost every internet cafe uses a single public IP NAT'ed via a router and then give all their clients private IP's. This No-trade rules between single IP will , sooner or later, cause problems to those playing from NAT'ed IP address.
I would suggest that a price floor be created for each product, and then sound the 'audit check' alarm whenever there is a contract issued below these price floors.
this rule also should be bent a little bit, because many times when you check an IP assigned internet pass the numbers will match due to running off of a router, on an RPG game my friend had a brother that played also but their were 2 separate computers in the house that ran off of a wireless network.

they were suspended for about a week but when they told the game mods what the situation was it was cleared and they went back to normal play.

and like he said their are internet cafe's and such, i dunno what the odds are that 2 people play kapi in the same coffee shop but their should be an investigation instead of an immediate locking of the account.
Locked