How to report cheaters?

Here is enough space for all players to ask questions about the game.

Moderator: moderators

Guest

How to report cheaters?

Post by Guest »

I noticed 2 companies that sell cotton for 600.000$ / piece, so where do I report them?
Guest

Post by Guest »

Hi

Send a PM (private Message) to any morderator of this board. You'll find a list of mods here : http://www.forum.kapilands.com/groupcp.php?g=5

do not pick Nasenprinz, he has to do other things - send your PM to one of the members in the list below.

Yours

AMI
Guest

Post by Guest »

what is cheating about selling cotton at that price?
Does anyone actually buy at that price?
Guest

Post by Guest »

they can transfer money this way, but i don't know, why they wouldn't do it with contract
Tycoon
Moderator off duty
Posts: 1911
Joined: 21.01.2007, 11:04

Post by Tycoon »

...a contract would be too obvious, as any trade is being controlled ;-)
Or if e.g. there are 2 (or more) companys with the same ip, they are not allowed to do trade with each others. So they use the market and not a direct contract.
Guest

Post by Guest »

you could check the market time to time and at least send some warning to those, who sell 1 energy for 600,000 and it's not only one case :!:
Guest

Post by Guest »

Drvic enterprises wrote:you could check the market time to time and at least send some warning to those, who sell 1 energy for 600,000 and it's not only one case :!:
Good idea :idea:
Do you really think market transfers aren't controlled? ;-)

Mamphil
Guest

Post by Guest »

Mamphil wrote:Good idea :idea:
Do you really think market transfers aren't controlled? ;-)

Mamphil
i hope that they are, but i think, that you could protect people from making mistakes, for example, you can click on buy by accident and you wasted 600,000 for 1 energy
Guest

Post by Guest »

Drvic enterprises wrote:but i think, that you could protect people from making mistakes, for example, you can click on buy by accident and you wasted 600,000 for 1 energy
But which limits should be set? The NPC's price? Bad idea since the quality of steel and wood can be increased.

Any other limit will be found by cheaters, they will sell their stuff some caps below the limits which does not prevent them from cheating.

Mamphil
Guest

Post by Guest »

its just another one of those things you have to look out for.
Tycoon
Moderator off duty
Posts: 1911
Joined: 21.01.2007, 11:04

Post by Tycoon »

It won't happen if you assort the offers on the market according to price. Or this is at least a try to avoid having power deluxe in your warehouse
Guest

Post by Guest »

Id like to make a few suggestions and comments.

When you are new to the game, and alot of people may not use the tutorial, you dont know the idea, what to do etc. So if u have a new company you may innoncently think 'ill put this product on the market and try to make alot of meony' this is not cheating!!! If someone buys it then thats their fault, it is only cheating if it is organised and the company buying is a 'junk' country that wont be used, and is only being used for the cash.

Putting goods into price order is a great idea. Two fold. Firstly for those that are buying it makes it easier, and seconldy for those players that put large quantites of good on the maket, and they dont sell al at once, at the moment your prodcut is 'pushed' down the list, when infact it is still a good deal. What i would say is put a timer or something next to the goods (make a new column possible) that staes the length of time this product has been on the market. (date it was enter onto the market) so u have it assorted into prioce, and also an indication of when it was placed on the market.

If you are bother about 'cheaters' then you need to impose limitations, at the moment u can put any prioce on anything, so who blames people for trying? What you can do, which will prevent cheating, is place a limit on the AMOUNT of goods that can be purchased. U can make it so the amount (in cash) u can buy is relative to your fixxed assets. Say for eg 0 - 500,000 fixxed assets you can buy 100,000 worth of goods from any 1 company 500,000 - 1,000,000 300,000 worh of goods from any 1 company ect etc (maybe this needs to honed but the idea is there)

This would mean people cudnt use proxy, make a new company then immediatly buy all their goods, as they would have to play with the company, which would deter most people!
Tycoon
Moderator off duty
Posts: 1911
Joined: 21.01.2007, 11:04

Post by Tycoon »

Phoenix Oil wrote:Id like to make a few suggestions and comments.

When you are new to the game, and alot of people may not use the tutorial, you dont know the idea, what to do etc. So if u have a new company you may innoncently think 'ill put this product on the market and try to make alot of meony' this is not cheating!!! If someone buys it then thats their fault, it is only cheating if it is organised and the company buying is a 'junk' country that wont be used, and is only being used for the cash.
There are two things on that: 1st is, that of course this may happen and it is not a cheater standing behind that. But I think that someone who is really interested in such a game will sort out average prices for his goods before putting them onto the market, especially as he has to pay 10% comission. So if somebody doesn't know the price for say apples, how will he come to an amount of 680,000, which is exactly the start capital of another company. And the 2nd thing is that I'm quite sure that the "finding-cheaters-system" has several ways to sort out real cheaters from poeple making just a mistake. But, on the other hand, there are rules in this game, and they have to be sticked to... Otherwise one player could destroy the fun of many others by his activities...
Putting goods into price order is a great idea. Two fold. Firstly for those that are buying it makes it easier, and seconldy for those players that put large quantites of good on the maket, and they dont sell al at once, at the moment your prodcut is 'pushed' down the list, when infact it is still a good deal.
If it is a good deal it won't move to the bottom of the list, I think... Most of the people first look for their required quality, then for the price.. and after that for the number of units offered.
What i would say is put a timer or something next to the goods (make a new column possible) that staes the length of time this product has been on the market. (date it was enter onto the market) so u have it assorted into prioce, and also an indication of when it was placed on the market.
I am really sorry, but for me it does not matter how long an item is on the market, if it meets my demand then I will buy it...
If you are bother about 'cheaters' then you need to impose limitations, at the moment u can put any prioce on anything, so who blames people for trying? What you can do, which will prevent cheating, is place a limit on the AMOUNT of goods that can be purchased. U can make it so the amount (in cash) u can buy is relative to your fixxed assets. Say for eg 0 - 500,000 fixxed assets you can buy 100,000 worth of goods from any 1 company 500,000 - 1,000,000 300,000 worh of goods from any 1 company ect etc (maybe this needs to honed but the idea is there)

This would mean people cudnt use proxy, make a new company then immediatly buy all their goods, as they would have to play with the company, which would deter most people!
There are even people here just trading with others. They do not have shops... or lots of buildings, so their fixed assets are quite low. But nevertheless they have enough cash to buy goods and then trade with them.

My personal experience up to now is that there is a quite good system for finding multis. When I began playing this game I was astonished that cheaters even exist *gg* yes, I know... this is quite...
Guest

Post by Guest »

Ok thanks for your response :)
Guest

Post by Guest »

I keep running across these threads about "cheating" and trying to understand what the rules are exactly. I am in the US, so I haven't been able to find the answers in the FAQ or game rules of my version.

The thing that bothers me a little, is the lack of clarity in the actual rules, I would like to hear more than... we have ways of knowing if you're 'cheating', and if you're 'cheating' we will ban you from the game. It would be nice to know, what exactly IS 'cheating' first!

This is a market simulation game, it is supposed to represent the actual market place (I assume), and people buy and sell goods at all kinds of high and low prices, for all kinds of reasons, in the real market. Part of 'capitalism' is being in the right place at the right time, and making smart and informed business decisions. If I have researched a product and know its value on the market, and I see an ad for the product at less than what I know it's worth, why should I be branded a 'cheater' for taking advantage of a capitalist opportunity? Doesn't my knowledge and understanding of the market and value of the product count for something? Doesn't my diligence in watching the market account for something? How is this 'cheating'? I understand some people might be jealous that I got such a good deal because I clicked faster than they did, but that is not cause to label me as a 'cheater' or report me for breaking some rule that I don't even know about.

I saw an example given yesterday, about a company selling steel for .01, and everyone was upset about it, but hey... If I had seen steel on the market for .01, you don't think I would have bought it too? You wouldn't? I don't see how this is 'cheating' in any way, it's free enterprise at its best! Someone said, he was obviously trying to "ruin the market" but that didn't ruin the steel market, it only lasted until his steel supply was exhausted, and that was it. Now, someone else in turn made a huge profit, but so what? This happens in the real world every day! The early bird gets the worm????

I understand there is a way people can cheat. I also understand there is a way to track IP's and discover those who cheat. I don't understand how legitimate business transactions, regardless of price/profit, can be deemed "cheating" unless there is a specific written rule, which I have not seen as of yet. I would like to know an answer to this from the KapiGod's, if it's not too much to ask.
Locked