Contest suggestions

Ideas on how the game could be improved and suggestions for subsequent versions of the game

Moderator: moderators

Guest

Contest suggestions

Post by Guest »

I have been enjoying the first contest a lot, although I couldn't help being disappointed with my final ranking (106th). Here a few suggestions which, in my opinion, could help making the next contests even better:

:arrow: End of the contest: Everyone knew the contest would end on Friday at 23.59. It made no difference at all whether you gave all your flax at the beginning of the contest or at the very last second, in one large bunch or in several small ones all over the duration of the contest. That made it very important to be online in the last few minutes, to be able to make a last minute submission, depending on the standings just before the end. In my case, I had to leave around 18.00 and knew I couldn't come back before the end, so at this time I sent everything I had and stopped producing flax, hoping it would be enough - but everyone else knew how much I had and how much they needed to get ahead of me in the rankings (although they didn't know whether I would send more or not).

If we had only known that the contest would end "at some point on Friday" or even "at some point between Wednesday 0.00 and Friday 23.59" (randomly decided), this period of time would have been even more exciting, with everyone sending flax as soon as they could, to avoid being surprised by the end of the contest with a lot of unsubmitted flax. Also, it would have removed the bias towards people who could be online at 23.59 - what if the end had been at 3.18 or 11.23 or 19.47? I'm aware it could be in favor of people who can be online a lot, compared to those who log on only once a day - but even then, the first 10 days or so of the contest have more weight than the final 2 days anyway.

:arrow: Prizes: While giving 100 prizes is nice, it may be a bit too much compared to the number of the participants (only 156). About two thirds of them had a prize. My suggestion would be to reduce the number of prizes to, say, 50, but add some prizes per rank: for instance, 5 prizes for the best 5 Bourgeois, best 5 Hucksters, and so on. As it is now, low-level players can only take advantage of the contest to make money, which is a good thing already. However, they could also have a chance to win an extra contest certificate or two by being among the best submitters in their rank, which I am sure would be interesting to some players (and the other ones, of course, would still sell their products without caring about their contest ranking).

:arrow: Quality: Wouldn't it be easier for the players to allow sending flax of q0 or better (always for the same price, of course)? Of course it is possible to lower the quality down to 0 by cancelling a production made with that flax, assuming you have a relevant building, but sending the high-quality flax directly would make things easier. And also, that would work when the contest products are not q0, if it ever happens. Alternatively - and that would also be useful outside the contest, a way to lower the quality of an item would be great (but I can understand how this would slightly reduce the need for a larger storehouse and thus for a premium account).

Anyway, these suggestions are not more than that - suggestions. As I said, I enjoyed the contest, even though I tried getting a prize and did not get any, and will certainly take part to the next one, even if none of my suggestions have been implemented. Thanks!

Wlam, Elberia
Guest

Post by Guest »

I agree, great suggestions!
Guest

Post by Guest »

In regards to the random timing for the 'End of the Contest' - It has always been 23:59 even since Kapilands .. We cannot set it otherwise unless the server coding itself is adapted to accommodate this, but as I understand there have never been any problems previously.

One problem that could arise from a random unknown time is people might be trying to save up their flax for a last minute big boost, or waiting for a contract only to find when they try to submit it the contest is already over so in a sense they are "left holding the bag".
23:59 is only a minute before the statistics update so means a solid time limit, and the statistics calculation sorts out the winners so I can send the contracts with prizes straight afterwards, or the next morning.

For the Prizes, again it's been the same ever since Kapilands, and is the same on the German Kapi-Regnum; As the server grows and more people actively participate there could be a few hundred entrants - Some people in the first contest chose to sell the Flax rather then submit it to earn a huge profit.

In terms of Quality the set quality won't always be Q0, and making the product at a higher quality would be a waste considering the increasing price that comes with higher quality products. I suppose it could be changed from "and quality equals X" to "and quality is greater then X", but as you've said yourself, it could reduce the need for a premium account.

But then who would want to pay a higher price to get a higher quality unnecessarily? And for most people the only products they would likely store in a very high quantity (few hundred thousand) would be the basic products (Wood, Water, etc.) which are always Q0, and a contest on them would be far too easy with the NPCs around, Although granted other products such as Wheat or Beats may be included depending on what someone is producing as an end-product these would also generally come with a higher quality and go out just as fast as they are produced.

For anything else I've missed in the above they'll have to be answered by someone else if they've seen such suggested before or from someone from UpJer's themselves in regards to other coding changes.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I was surprised about the suggestion to reduce the prices to 50, while you didn´t even make it to the pot 100. I don´t think there are too many prices. I didn´t really want to compete in the contest, but I thought: Well, send 1000 or 2000 to get the cert. I also left on Friday at 18:00 and came back after 23:59. But then I saw that you needed at least 14,290 to get the certificate. I think this is quite a lot of flax for rank 100.

So I think we should stick to 100 prices.

As for the other suggestions: I like the contest as it is. They changed something in the contest on the German server, with the effect that only very few people take part in the contest and contest products sell for not much more than normal price. The last contest was beer q2, and in the end I bought the beer for 150, while I usually sell high q beer for 220 and more in my taverns.

Let´s just leave the contest like it is and see after a few more weeks if we need to change anything.

Elwood
Guest

Post by Guest »

The discusion about the end time is very interesting one in my opinion.
I would not chnage it randomly but an hour or two every contest.
The English server is very International so some time zones have a good time for the end of the contest and some an awful one, if the end time always stays at midnight CET.
When the end time rotates 1 or 2 hrs every contest, good and bad times also change. This makes players of all time zones equal!

regards, Volki
Guest

Post by Guest »

elwood74 wrote:But then I saw that you needed at least 14,290 to get the certificate. I think this is quite a lot of flax for rank 100.
Well, 5 coins will get you 10 points, and they're worth about 200k each now. So 10 points, as in 1 contest certificate, translates to 1 million ¢τ.

If flax was trading around 35, that would be 28,571 flax for a contest cert as the break even. So I would say 100th place was a bargain.

(On top of which, many would say a contest reward is worth more than your standard point value, since it's more limited. This explains why the two top guys submitted over 500 million ¢τ worth of flax to chase 300 points (150 million ¢τ worth)).

That's likely to be my cutoff, unless I get it into my head that I must chase down a particular place.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Thanks everyone for your answers and comments.
Therian wrote:One problem that could arise from a random unknown time is people might be trying to save up their flax for a last minute big boost, or waiting for a contract only to find when they try to submit it the contest is already over so in a sense they are "left holding the bag".
The time wouldn't be completely random - just random within a given day or range of days. So the players would still have something like 10 full days to make their contracts and trades, but everything in the last day or so would be more uncertain.
Therian wrote:For the Prizes, again it's been the same ever since Kapilands, and is the same on the German Kapi-Regnum
I don't know exactly what is coded by whom and what kind of changes can be implemented locally to this server. I don't play on Kapilands or the other servers, so it would be a bit strange for me to post suggestions there, and that's why I post them here. I suppose that even ideas posted here have a chance to be read at some point by someone who can actually implement changes.
Therian wrote:In terms of Quality the set quality won't always be Q0, and making the product at a higher quality would be a waste considering the increasing price that comes with higher quality products. I suppose it could be changed from "and quality equals X" to "and quality is greater then X", but as you've said yourself, it could reduce the need for a premium account.
Actually, most of the flax I submitted and sold to other players during this contest has been produced as q2, since I keep my farms on maximum quality, to avoid getting stuck with a large bunch of q2 beets if ever I make an unnoticed mistake while setting the production. It would have been marginally easier for me to send it directly as is, instead of having to run it through a cancelled production in my weaving mill.
elwood74 wrote:I was surprised about the suggestion to reduce the prices to 50, while you didn´t even make it to the pot 100.
Well, I don't think that all the suggestions should necessarily be about making the game easier, should they? And actually, if there had been only 50 prizes, maybe I would have given up competing myself and I would have made even more money by selling flax to other players.
Also, remember that my idea was to reduce the number of general prizes to 50, but also add some prizes by rank - meaning I could have competed against comparable economies to be ranked in the top 3 or top 5 among players at the Sir level.

Anyway, I understand that these suggestions (and most of the other ideas I have about the game) require some coding, but as I said, I was not fully aware about which autonomy this server has, as far as coding is concerned.

Wlam, Elberia
Guest

Post by Guest »

Knolls, in general I agree with you. And if my city would have been bigger, I would have sent the 20k or maybe more needed to get the cert. But imo I´m too small right now and need my money to buy coins for my premium or I need the money to grow my city. OK, I know the cert sells for 800k but I could not know that before...
Wlam wrote:And actually, if there had been only 50 prizes, maybe I would have given up competing myself and I would have made even more money by selling flax to other players.
But that is exactly the problem. Now imagine that half of the people taking part in the contest (~75) think the same way. The result will be that the demand will go down, while the supply goes up. So the price will fall and you cannot make as much money with the contest product, as you could now.

Elwood
Guest

Post by Guest »

elwood74 wrote:But that is exactly the problem. Now imagine that half of the people taking part in the contest (~75) think the same way. The result will be that the demand will go down, while the supply goes up. So the price will fall and you cannot make as much money with the contest product, as you could now.
What I meant that if there had been only 50 prizes and the price of flax had been the same (about 35 ct), I would not have sent anything and would have tried to sell the few thousands flax I submitted in vain.
However, imagine there had been only 50 prizes and thus fewer players take part. Either the other participants buy more flax and the total quantity stays the same, and then the price doesn't change; or there is less interest for flax and the price goes down, let's say to 20. Now, I am sure that some more players consider it is not worth producing flax to sell it for 20 - and either they stop doing so and mind their own non-flax business, or even they start thinking "Well, with flax being so cheap, I might buy some myself and grab one of these prizes" - and then the demand for flax is increased, the price goes up again and the competition as well.

This contest mechanism is self balancing, which is very nice. Changing the number of prizes (within reasonable limits) wouldn't change it. Of course, if there were only 3 prizes, it would be different.

Also, remember we are not discussing about my original suggestion, but the variant of it which consists in cutting down the number of prizes without adding prizes by rank. If you allow me to quote myself:
Wlam wrote:Also, remember that my idea was to reduce the number of general prizes to 50, but also add some prizes by rank - meaning I could have competed against comparable economies to be ranked in the top 3 or top 5 among players at the Sir level.
Anyway - the contest rules probably won't change whatever we may say, so we are just talking for the fun of it, aren't we? :wink: And as I said earlier, I will keep taking part and having fun in the contests anyway, either by competing or by providing the products - and I might even add some more suggestions next time again if I have further ideas worth posting.

Wlam
Guest

Post by Guest »

One thing tho,.. How do they run a contest between cities of the same rank??

well, consider that b4 the competition ends, you sent a delivery of something to a customer city and were somewhere near the promotion mark.

All thats needed to kick u out of the contest is for your contract to be accepted. Or you accidentally collecting money from a market.

+ it raises the prospect of people buying coins and selling them to buy flax. Then, they stay in a lower rank, but they supply flax like a much bigger city. They can later sell their contest certificates for a really nice profit and buy back coins or whatever... Basically, it will encourage cheating.

I might suggest that next time a contest may have some twist to it, like perhaps a particular quality to be delivered or a combination of goods that might stretch any city's production, so having good partners will win you contests.

I guess all suggestions are really positive as it might make the contest a lot more interesting.
Guest

Post by Guest »

pk wrote:I might suggest that next time a contest may have some twist to it, like perhaps a particular quality to be delivered or a combination of goods that might stretch any city's production, so having good partners will win you contests.

I guess all suggestions are really positive as it might make the contest a lot more interesting.
Well I could set it to something like Q4 Saint Statues ;)

We'll see when the time comes as to what I decide. Flax was a last minute decision on the Thursday before, and of course I had to think up a story to go along with it.

Nevertheless for the moment the main goal is to still encourage growth among the smaller cities by selling the products, and for anyone to participate, as it will likely always be.

I'll think of something for when I host another competition. It'll be announced in the Journal again when one starts.
Guest

my thoughts

Post by Guest »

I know it has been a while since anyone posted to this, but I had been thinking about the contests and wanted to provide my newbie opinion to it.

1. I don't think you should raise the quality requirement. I think it should remain at Q0 and not be Q0 or higher, and this is why:

(going to use beer as an example since that is the current contest product and so many players produce beer in the game)

It is a contest. And with a contest comes risks. Let's say that you are able to actually produce Q20 beer in your city... well, in case you do not end up using that beer for the contest. Then you are not really losing anything because you can now sell that beer in your Market stalls. So there is not loss to you and not risk involved in the contest. Whereas, if you end up producing a lot more beer than what you needed for the contest at Q0, you will not be making as much money for it in your Market Stall (tavern).

Also, if you keep the product at Q0 only, you are helping the new players to the game a lot! They will be able to better participate since many new cities are only able to produce low (or zero) quality of goods. By setting a higher quality for contests or even allowing a higher quality, you will be decreasing the benefit for new cities.

2. In my opinion, the contest time should be varied, as stated in the original post. Just because "it has always been this way" does not mean that it's the best way. It's always been that way on the German game, well that's great... for everyone who lives in German speaking countries (mostly in the same time zone).
But another point to be made on that, besides the many, many time zones represented in the English version....
"it would take some recoding" is paraphrasing I think what another reason was... well recode it then. If it is going to make the game better, that's all part of the reason for having a space for Suggestions, isn't it? To see what improvements may be made for the game.

Having a random deadline (ie. The King has decided that he has had his fill of beer and does not want anymore at this time) can again put that risk factor into the contest. Right now, as it is, everyone knows the exact time of the end of the contest. If the end were possible within a couple days range... it could really shake things up a bit I think. It seems rather plain right now for a contest, as everyone does the same thing... wait until that last minute before selling your beer. Where's the excitement in that. I'm sure those who like to play that stealthy game will be upset with me posting this, as they enjoy their strategy... but again, where is the risk factor. The risk of perhaps being stuck with a ton of Q0 beer. :)

Those are just a couple of my thoughts regarding the contests. Shake things up a bit! :)
Guest

Post by Guest »

:twisted: Different qualitys is good ... the smaller Citys can still profit .. with other goods or just the ingrediants for contestproducts.
I know from the German Sever they went up to Q4 on that .. which is still not bad for small Citys to atain.Also overthere was a contest last week Iron Q1 ... sounds easy enough .... i finished 81 with just over 300k sent..... cutoff was around 280k (I am only a patritian).
So as the Game progresses the numbers will increase to and make it a lot mor difficult for small Citys to compete.... but they will always be able to supply the big Guys...... :wink:

I dont think we should change the ending time .... again on the German one ... the Numbers change drasticly in the last 15Minutes even dough it ends at midnight.On said contest last week i was at 61st spot 1 hour befor the end 30min later i dropped to 96 and i had to submit another 125k just to get 81st.(it was worth it to: 1 Cert ~ 110mio cT)

Also we always got a week to recouperate over their the next contest starts 1 1/2 later.So you dont have much time to get back to your regular production.

So i think with the increasing number of players ... its going to be hard enough the way its set right now. :)
________________

City of Freimettigen
Guest

Quality of items required in Contests

Post by Guest »

I think that we should stop having Q0 products for the contests for a few reasons:

I think that even if the contest required Q1 products, it would make a big difference for helping out the smaller towns.

It is not too difficult to obtain Q1 production for an item.

It would possibly open up another market for those who wish to sell knowledge during a contest

It would make it much harder for a player to hoard an item in hopes of it later being a contest item. Right now, it seems to be more than likely that players buy cheap Q0 items and hold onto them in hopes of it later being a contest item - thus giving them a head start. If the exact item quality required of contest items were varied, this would make it much more of a challenge for someone to know if they are collecting the correct item/quality or not, thus cutting back the chances of players gaining a head start over other players for a contest.

It would eliminate those larger towns that have hoards of certain types of products held in their storehouses from gaining an upper hand at the start of each contest. - It is so much easier for larger towns to turn these Q2 + items into Q0 by simply putting them into production into their large workshops, and then canceling production = voila, instant Q0 product. If the contest required Q1 or higher products, this loophole of an instant Q0 production gain would be eliminated.
Guest

Post by Guest »

That is good reason and a good suggestion too :)

It would cut hoarding down to collecting raw materials only, which would mean that our smaller cities benefit throughout, not only during the contests!
Post Reply