Demand is increasing faster than supply, what about prices?
Moderator: moderators
-
Guest
Demand is increasing faster than supply, what about prices?
What does the demand for a product mean? In this game anyway.
I see that the demand has been increasing much faster than the supply of all the goods that I have looked at, even chairs. However, I if you look in your market stalls it says that the demand has been met for these goods for a certain percent. If the demand stats were actually true the percent of demand met would approach zero, however the percent supplied is at over 30% in some markets and increases regularly.
I don't know how much any of these statistics matter. It would be nice if they did. Why publish statistics that don't mean anything. Anyone?
I see that the demand has been increasing much faster than the supply of all the goods that I have looked at, even chairs. However, I if you look in your market stalls it says that the demand has been met for these goods for a certain percent. If the demand stats were actually true the percent of demand met would approach zero, however the percent supplied is at over 30% in some markets and increases regularly.
I don't know how much any of these statistics matter. It would be nice if they did. Why publish statistics that don't mean anything. Anyone?
-
Guest
-
Guest
The higher the percentage is that has been met of the product, the slower the sale speed gets, this is only noticable above 50% or something, and if the demand is met 100% you cant realy sell anything anymore.
The demand is comes from the inhabitants, at least thats how it is in kapilands, would need to watch the stats for a few days for the details.
Also the percantage of the demand met that is displayed in your stores, equals to the numbers in the stats.
The demand is comes from the inhabitants, at least thats how it is in kapilands, would need to watch the stats for a few days for the details.
Also the percantage of the demand met that is displayed in your stores, equals to the numbers in the stats.
-
Guest
I know that's how it's suppose to be, but if demand is increasing much faster than supply that doesn't make sense. The percent of demand supplied will keep decreasing and will be very small for every product.Strolling wrote:The higher the percentage is that has been met of the product, the slower the sale speed gets, this is only noticable above 50% or something, and if the demand is met 100% you cant realy sell anything anymore.
The demand is comes from the inhabitants, at least thats how it is in kapilands, would need to watch the stats for a few days for the details.
Also the percantage of the demand met that is displayed in your stores, equals to the numbers in the stats.
-
Guest
As new players join the game, the base population increases. This creates more demand, more population means more demand. New players find it is easier to sell bulk to existing players who advertise, in-game and/or forum. They get the money needed for expansion faster selling to players. New players are slower to build markets; the cash return might be greater, but it requires more time to sell off all the goods to get that cash. So, the demand increases, but supply doesn't.
-
Guest
-
Guest
I can't quantify this, and I'll be the first to admit that there could be other factors in operation, but it seems like it has been easier to maintain a good selling price with those products that do not have as much market saturation. I sell weaver's products in four equal-sized draperies. I find it much harder to maintain the price for raiment, for which the market is about six percent saturated, than it is for carpets, which is less than one percent saturated. Same with goats (almost 6 percent saturated) vs. bread (less than 1 percent).
This is, of course, highly subjective, and there are so many other factors, such as quality and market share, in operation, that I cannot say definititively that demand is the controlling factor. It just seems easier to sell in a market in which demand is not being met as much.
But just as I cannot say with 100 percent assurance that supply/demand have an effect, I still do not understand how it has been demonstrated that it does not. Chessguy's explanation of why demand increases faster than supply seems reasonable, and there may be other factors masking the effect of demand (if there is, indeed, one). For example, average quality is also increasing, which makes it harder to sell low Q products even with higher demand. And an increasing number of new players selling lower Q products will pull the stat price down.
In summary, I think there is just too much going on to say for certain how supply and demand affect selling price. We certainly can't quantify it at this point. We can, however, keep an eye on chairs, which is rapidly approaching the 50 percent mark, to see what happens.
This is, of course, highly subjective, and there are so many other factors, such as quality and market share, in operation, that I cannot say definititively that demand is the controlling factor. It just seems easier to sell in a market in which demand is not being met as much.
But just as I cannot say with 100 percent assurance that supply/demand have an effect, I still do not understand how it has been demonstrated that it does not. Chessguy's explanation of why demand increases faster than supply seems reasonable, and there may be other factors masking the effect of demand (if there is, indeed, one). For example, average quality is also increasing, which makes it harder to sell low Q products even with higher demand. And an increasing number of new players selling lower Q products will pull the stat price down.
In summary, I think there is just too much going on to say for certain how supply and demand affect selling price. We certainly can't quantify it at this point. We can, however, keep an eye on chairs, which is rapidly approaching the 50 percent mark, to see what happens.
-
Guest
chairs are funny, even with that saturation, they're selling reasonably well.In summary, I think there is just too much going on to say for certain how supply and demand affect selling price. We certainly can't quantify it at this point. We can, however, keep an eye on chairs, which is rapidly approaching the 50 percent mark, to see what happens.
I think it also ahs something to do with the game's inbuilt-default setting for which products are supposed to sell more. Maybe things like: tables should sell at least 1/4th the rate of chairs, Beer sells faster than bread (the programmer must be bayerisch)
-
Guest
Yet another factor that influences market stall price. I've noticed that, too. Nuts sell for more than grapes, but you cannot sell as many in the same time period.pk wrote:I think it also ahs something to do with the game's inbuilt-default setting for which products are supposed to sell more. Maybe things like: tables should sell at least 1/4th the rate of chairs, Beer sells faster than bread (the programmer must be bayerisch)Though I'm not sure abt this, I think some of it is arbitrarily set from the beginning.
I think that isolating the effect of supply and demand on price empirically is going to be all but impossible. The developers know, but they ain't talking (and rightly so).
Last edited by Guest on Mon Dec 31, 2007 3:25 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
Guest
-
Guest
Re: Demand is increasing faster than supply, what about pric
The stats are right. I'll use your chairs. I just put some for sale: "The demand for chairs has been covered for 36.12 % " That means that the markets have 36% of the demand for chairs.Duncan wrote:What does the demand for a product mean? In this game anyway.
I see that the demand has been increasing much faster than the supply of all the goods that I have looked at, even chairs. However, I if you look in your market stalls it says that the demand has been met for these goods for a certain percent. If the demand stats were actually true the percent of demand met would approach zero, however the percent supplied is at over 30% in some markets and increases regularly.
I don't know how much any of these statistics matter. It would be nice if they did. Why publish statistics that don't mean anything. Anyone?
Looking at the statistics page it says: the demand for chairs is 617,725 and the supply is 223,100 (Supply / demand =.36114.)
The supply is 36% of the demand. As of right now chairs are the least in-demand product, but still can be quickly sold because 64% of the population still wants more.
-
Guest
meaning the more you get closer to 100% saturation the longer it takes to sell. and if theoretically you hit 100% saturation you wont sell anymore. also the saturation will get higher as the main players start hitting 60 buildings and almost fully upgraded. then they can supply alot of the little villages with there product. this is seen with chairs. a lot of people go into it and now they are producing so many chairs that the growth of the server cant keep up with it. soon they will switch to something else and the saturation will go down a little.
hope that helps
hope that helps
-
Guest
I checked the stats a few days and these are the results.
2 Examples Chairs and Beer each on 3 diffrent days.
The demand for Beer is about 17.8~ per inhabitant.
17,95519716
17,89299539
17,78283719
Chairs are around 1 per inhabitant.
1,0770544
1,070930007
1,081428222
There must be some other factor which changes it slightly thought.
So 1 more inhabitant, (Residential buildings), means the demand increases by about 17 for beer and 1 for chairs.
2 Examples Chairs and Beer each on 3 diffrent days.
The demand for Beer is about 17.8~ per inhabitant.
17,95519716
17,89299539
17,78283719
Chairs are around 1 per inhabitant.
1,0770544
1,070930007
1,081428222
There must be some other factor which changes it slightly thought.
So 1 more inhabitant, (Residential buildings), means the demand increases by about 17 for beer and 1 for chairs.
