Okay, after all this heated discussion about wells vs lumberjack (or whatever else for that matter), I whipped out my calculator and did the sums. If someone else feels they need to, check my working but:
Profit/hour on a well: 235.2482
Profit/hour on a lumberjack with water produced myself: 1261.82
Profit/hour on a lumberjack with water bought from the NPC: 1026.624
Those figures were based on selling back at the same price as the NPC, which I know wouldn't happen in reality, but it's a fair enough marker (favours water more if anything, since you can probably get a price closer to the NPC with wood). On that note, anyone know how much cash you start the game with so I can get an idea of how much I've lost through the well fiasco and if it's worth restarting?
EDIT: Worked it out from the balance sheet, and it WAS worth restarting. I now have two lumberjacks, a farm and a brewery. This learning curve's a biggie...
Now looking at producing wood, beer and grain (for the beer) and buying in water & casks. seems to work out better than before. Everyone's comments and thoughts are still welcome, see if you can point out where I'm going wrong this time =)
New Player Help?
Moderator: moderators
-
Guest
-
Guest
-
Guest
If you are not too tapped for cash, then use your own wood to upgrade your breweries and taverns while the contest lasts. The contest ends and hey presto, your brewery would be spitting beer like a Ilama... that means profits during the contest (beets) and after (beer and wood). Theres a package for you.
cheers n good luck.
cheers n good luck.
-
Guest
-
Guest
I haven't done too much direct sales, but might a 2:1 Tavern:Brewery ratio end up being a problem down the line when your Taverns are advertised and your Brewery efficiency drops? Or is the short term benefit enough to justify tearing down some of the Taverns when you start expanding your facilities? Even at 1:1 joinery:manufacturer's market I'm starting to buy furniture.
-
Guest
Yes, it is a problem later on. I was one of the early proponents of the 2:1 ratio, and it does work great for a while. However, it eventually becomes a major problem with steady loss in efficiency in breweries. I ended up selling a bunch of taverns a few months ago because could not keep them stocked with beer even at crazy high selling prices.JohnWick wrote:I haven't done too much direct sales, but might a 2:1 Tavern:Brewery ratio end up being a problem down the line when your Taverns are advertised and your Brewery efficiency drops?
If you start with a lower ratio than 2:1, you will have excess beer in the short-term, but that isn't a big problem since pricing for beer on the market or by contract has been quite good lately.
-
Guest
One of the things nice I found about direct sales is that the exact production:market ratio isn't all that critical. Without advertising, about 2:1 is optimal for furniture, but 1:1 reduced profits only by 15%. I assume it's similar for beer although I never researched the beer market (very timeconsuming to do research). It would be different for something like silk or spices where your production costs are high; too few markets there would mean you're selling your product at cost for *zero* profit. But if you're growing your own grain your beer production cost is pretty low so even at a lowish price you make decent profits.
