The Price of Honey -- A Rhetorical Question
Moderator: moderators
-
Guest
The Price of Honey -- A Rhetorical Question
Greetings from the people of Colchester.
Suppose we have 50,000 pounds of honey. Should we sell them or enter then in the contest? And if we sell them, what price should we ask?
Let's see . . . . Hmmmmn
If we enter them in the contest, with 50,000 pounds we stand a decent chance of finishing in the top 100 and getting a 10-point certificate. This 10-point cert gives its owner the same amount of reputation as does a goldberyl. And since a goldberyl is worth 5 coins, so should that 10-point certificate, and so should those 50,000 pounds of honey.
Given the current prices for coins, that makes those 50,000 pounds of honey worth between 21 and 25 million kapi thalers if they are used to get a 10-point reputation cert, which can then be resold.
How much money would we have to get to equal this if we sold these 50,000 pounds of honey to someone else so they could put them in the contest? That would be 21,000,000 (minimum) divided by 50,000, or 420 kapi thalers each.
And so, if we are not offered at least 420 kapi thalers per pound of honey for out 50,000 pounds of honey, we should keep them and enter them ourselves to get a certificate, which we can then sell.
Any comments about this reasoning? If not, then that is all. Carry on.
Suppose we have 50,000 pounds of honey. Should we sell them or enter then in the contest? And if we sell them, what price should we ask?
Let's see . . . . Hmmmmn
If we enter them in the contest, with 50,000 pounds we stand a decent chance of finishing in the top 100 and getting a 10-point certificate. This 10-point cert gives its owner the same amount of reputation as does a goldberyl. And since a goldberyl is worth 5 coins, so should that 10-point certificate, and so should those 50,000 pounds of honey.
Given the current prices for coins, that makes those 50,000 pounds of honey worth between 21 and 25 million kapi thalers if they are used to get a 10-point reputation cert, which can then be resold.
How much money would we have to get to equal this if we sold these 50,000 pounds of honey to someone else so they could put them in the contest? That would be 21,000,000 (minimum) divided by 50,000, or 420 kapi thalers each.
And so, if we are not offered at least 420 kapi thalers per pound of honey for out 50,000 pounds of honey, we should keep them and enter them ourselves to get a certificate, which we can then sell.
Any comments about this reasoning? If not, then that is all. Carry on.
-
Guest
I know it was a rhetorical question and a nice idea,
but what if you only need 10.000 pounds???
A short calculation not better or worser as your idea:
Honey needs 5 herbs a 62.7ct (stats April 28 ) ~300ct and an extra farm for the production + 62.7ct => ~360ct.
This calculation results in a higher price if you take the stats of grain!!!
People, who produce honey for the contest, want to get more. So, multiply this price by 2, 3, 4 or even 5.
What about this calculation??? We don't know but we'll see!!
but what if you only need 10.000 pounds???
A short calculation not better or worser as your idea:
Honey needs 5 herbs a 62.7ct (stats April 28 ) ~300ct and an extra farm for the production + 62.7ct => ~360ct.
This calculation results in a higher price if you take the stats of grain!!!
People, who produce honey for the contest, want to get more. So, multiply this price by 2, 3, 4 or even 5.
What about this calculation??? We don't know but we'll see!!
-
Guest
The reasoning is sound, but I agree with volki that the amount of honey need to break into the top 100 is critical. In the last contest, though, you could get a contest certificate for far less than the 15 mill or so 5 coins were worth at the time. However, that contest was a fruitpicker production and there aren't too many fruitpickers going; this one is all farm and the are a LOT of farms in Kapiregnum!
The winner of the last contest spent a good deal more than the putative coin value of a 500 point rep boost. However, a gold certificate is a rarity and IMO worth much more than 500 rep points. They are an unusually special item.
The winner of the last contest spent a good deal more than the putative coin value of a 500 point rep boost. However, a gold certificate is a rarity and IMO worth much more than 500 rep points. They are an unusually special item.
-
Guest
Hey, remenber that the total area of farm is 5910418 m^2,
the largest in the regnum, which means that the price of honey
won't be too high since nearly every city can produce it and
sell it to other city who want to get the medal.
And then the city won't have enough money to buy it
Unlike the pears last time, fewer city had built fruit picker and fewer pears were picked, so the price will be a little high.
the largest in the regnum, which means that the price of honey
won't be too high since nearly every city can produce it and
sell it to other city who want to get the medal.
And then the city won't have enough money to buy it
Unlike the pears last time, fewer city had built fruit picker and fewer pears were picked, so the price will be a little high.
-
Guest
I guess the large ammounts of farms will - in contrary to what wrdoff thinks - make the price of the honey rise (just read, I know the general rules of buying/selling creating the price, but a contest is no "general" case).
Why?
* As everyone has farms, more people will try to compete for a spot in the top-100.
=> less available honey for sale
* As a result of that, one will need more honey to get into that top.
=> again less honey available.
* in the end, many smaller towns will see they just need that little bit extra honey to remain in the top-100
=> the market might be completely exhausted, making prices rise
* Many small towns (starters with merely farms) do not even know about the contest, and do not know the value of it (yes, that is possible). Those won't sell the full ammounts of honey they can produce ("growing beets, and then goats is my dreamjob")
=> less honey available
* And if many honey is available, many towns might start producing more beets, grain, ... again, to continu what they were doing (looking for stabile prices). That way price of the honey will stabilise again.
* Just pay attention to the fact that I merely talk about top-100, and not top-10. Traditionaly the top-5 spends as much as the other 95 winners together, but this time (due to the many farms) I think the honey-price will be affected more than otherwise by the top-100!
All this to say in my eyes the price of honey will stay high enough to make quite some profit out of it, as a smaller farmer...
And I predict those medals will cost way more than the coin value of the 500 points again
Why?
* As everyone has farms, more people will try to compete for a spot in the top-100.
=> less available honey for sale
* As a result of that, one will need more honey to get into that top.
=> again less honey available.
* in the end, many smaller towns will see they just need that little bit extra honey to remain in the top-100
=> the market might be completely exhausted, making prices rise
* Many small towns (starters with merely farms) do not even know about the contest, and do not know the value of it (yes, that is possible). Those won't sell the full ammounts of honey they can produce ("growing beets, and then goats is my dreamjob")
=> less honey available
* And if many honey is available, many towns might start producing more beets, grain, ... again, to continu what they were doing (looking for stabile prices). That way price of the honey will stabilise again.
* Just pay attention to the fact that I merely talk about top-100, and not top-10. Traditionaly the top-5 spends as much as the other 95 winners together, but this time (due to the many farms) I think the honey-price will be affected more than otherwise by the top-100!
All this to say in my eyes the price of honey will stay high enough to make quite some profit out of it, as a smaller farmer...
And I predict those medals will cost way more than the coin value of the 500 points again
-
Guest
Well, so far herb/honey production has been less than 1/5 as profitable as pears were last round. I tore down almost all my level 1 buildings to build farms and unless the price goes up I should have just left them alone. The additional profits won't even cover construction costs, never mind after accounting for the time value of money and building expansion time.
-
Guest
For what it's worth --
Cash value of contest prizes based on coin equivalent, with coins at 5 million (where they will be soon).
1st -- 300 points = 150 coins = 750 million kapi thalers
2nd -- 200 points = 100 coins = 500 million kapi thalers
3rd -- 100 points = 50 coins = 250 million kapi thalers
4th -- 50 points = 25 coins = 125 million kapi thalers
5th -- 40 points = 20 coins = 100 million kapi thalers
6th - 10th -- 30 points = 15 coins = 75 million kapi thalers
11th - 20th -- 20 points = 10 coins = 50 million kapi thalers
21st - 100th -- 10 points = 5 coins = 25 million kapi thalers
Pay daily attention to the contest board. If your honey stash will lock you in to at least a 10-point cert, then calculate your price accordingly if you decide to sell. If you can't get on the board, definitely sell it. The great unknown factor here is, of course, how much honey do you need to submit to get 100th place. And this is a moving target. For pears, it was 25,000; for wool, only 10,000; and for flax, 14,290.
In Colchester, the herbs are a'growin', and the bees are a'buzzin', and the beekeepers are a'harvestin' whilst we wait to see which way the wind will blow.
Cash value of contest prizes based on coin equivalent, with coins at 5 million (where they will be soon).
1st -- 300 points = 150 coins = 750 million kapi thalers
2nd -- 200 points = 100 coins = 500 million kapi thalers
3rd -- 100 points = 50 coins = 250 million kapi thalers
4th -- 50 points = 25 coins = 125 million kapi thalers
5th -- 40 points = 20 coins = 100 million kapi thalers
6th - 10th -- 30 points = 15 coins = 75 million kapi thalers
11th - 20th -- 20 points = 10 coins = 50 million kapi thalers
21st - 100th -- 10 points = 5 coins = 25 million kapi thalers
Pay daily attention to the contest board. If your honey stash will lock you in to at least a 10-point cert, then calculate your price accordingly if you decide to sell. If you can't get on the board, definitely sell it. The great unknown factor here is, of course, how much honey do you need to submit to get 100th place. And this is a moving target. For pears, it was 25,000; for wool, only 10,000; and for flax, 14,290.
In Colchester, the herbs are a'growin', and the bees are a'buzzin', and the beekeepers are a'harvestin' whilst we wait to see which way the wind will blow.
-
Guest
Good thread Colchester.
Per your comparison of Goldberyl, Coin, and Contest Certificates...
Coins have been the "benchmark" against which the other items have been priced. This is the sole item that can be valued against all the others, because they can be exchanged very quickly, and they tend to appreciate along with the wealth of all Kapi-Regnum. So, they have been the most valuable (on an exchange basis).
Also, since there are many standing buyers for Contest Certificates, they have been going up in value every contest, as no one really wants to sell their certificate. These have been somewhat pegged to the value of a coin, and they lag in time when the coin price goes up.
Not many people own or want the items like the Goldberyl, or higher reputation items like that.... So they are the lowest valued item among these.
---
As for medals, no one has even tried to sell theirs, so we don't know the value. I estimate given the rarity, that it will carry a good premium. However, who has the money to buy a Gold Medal (300 points)? It's "lowest value" is $600 mil, using a comparable $20 mil for a 10-point contest certificate.
Maybe in a couple months when all the Top 100 is over 1 bil total value we will see some fireworks.
Per your comparison of Goldberyl, Coin, and Contest Certificates...
Coins have been the "benchmark" against which the other items have been priced. This is the sole item that can be valued against all the others, because they can be exchanged very quickly, and they tend to appreciate along with the wealth of all Kapi-Regnum. So, they have been the most valuable (on an exchange basis).
Also, since there are many standing buyers for Contest Certificates, they have been going up in value every contest, as no one really wants to sell their certificate. These have been somewhat pegged to the value of a coin, and they lag in time when the coin price goes up.
Not many people own or want the items like the Goldberyl, or higher reputation items like that.... So they are the lowest valued item among these.
---
As for medals, no one has even tried to sell theirs, so we don't know the value. I estimate given the rarity, that it will carry a good premium. However, who has the money to buy a Gold Medal (300 points)? It's "lowest value" is $600 mil, using a comparable $20 mil for a 10-point contest certificate.
Maybe in a couple months when all the Top 100 is over 1 bil total value we will see some fireworks.
-
Guest
Well the market value of what the last winner blew was about 2 billion, and I don't think he was displeased with the transaction. Given rapid KapiRegnum inflation, I'd put a floor value of 3 billion. But given that they're Kapi's highest permanent achievement and the sentimental value to the owner from all the work he did to get it, it's hard to see them ever being sold.
I think we see fireworks with the contests already.
I think we see fireworks with the contests already.
