Profitable business

What's going on in Kapi Regnum? This section is for everything concerning the game itself

Moderator: moderators

Post Reply
Guest

Profitable business

Post by Guest »

:D What I started producing and why
At Freeman level I was adviced in forums to produce wood, which I did...contracting most of the production to other cities, but keeping some to upgrade my luberjacks. By this I reached Bourgeois level fairly quickly, so I continued producing wood. Producing wood did not require me to spend money on knowledge, and selling wood on contract did not require me to spend money on market stalls, meaning all sale profits went into further expanding the lumberjack operations (compound interests if you will).

:) What I want to produce
But now as I see the level of Huckster within my grasp, I begin to wonder if there is more to life than wood. The rich cities seem to have gotten wealthy on beer, but I would be much happier to calculate if beer is really the way to go, or if there is perhaps some other way to gain riches, perhaps even faster. So, as so many before me, I started an Excel sheet.

8) My calculations
I entered each and every product into the Excel sheet as follows (assuming Q0 for all):

<Product Name: Honey>
<Ingredient: 5 Herbs @ 30 cT = 190 cT> (cost for lowest quality ingredients at market, preferably Q0)
<Production cost: 0,4 cT>
<Total Production cost: 150,4 cT>
<Market Price: 160 cT>
<Profit per unit: 160 cT - 150,4 cT = 9,6 cT per unit>
<Manufacturing per hour: 17,82 units per hour>
<Total profit per hour: 9,6 cT * 17,82 = 171,07 cT>

:roll: Calculations presumption - Purchasing vs. producing
Some will probably criticise my calculations presuming ingredient purchase from market instead of producing, as these people will state that producing ingredients yourself (instead of buying them from market) will increase you profits, but this subject has been discussed here in the forums before (and in the real world), and the truth is that either the ingredients are not as profitable as your main production (and hence you should buy them instead of producing), or the ingredients are more profitable than your main productions (and hence you should abandon your main production and turn to producing the ingredients).

:o Calculations results - Top 10 list
The calculations above tell me that if I buy all the needed ingredients at the market, produce the product, and sell it again at the market (not the stalls), I should make 171 cT per hour in profits for that particular product. And this kind of calculations I did for all the products available at Freeman level, showing me which products could be worth while. Comparing all the products this way gave me the following top ten list, ordered by profitability: Venison, Pearls, Fish, Casks, Beer, Wood, Herbs, Beets, Grain, Milk

:!: Calculation simplifications - Low quality
I am aware of the assumption in my calculations, assuming Q0 (or the lowest quality available on market), and this I do both for simplifying and for the fact that I consider money spent on research better spent on increasing the production (at least at Bourgeois level). Same applies to market stalls. It seems to me that most large industries produce to contracts anyway, at prices similar to (just below) the market value.

:? Observations - Statistics
According to my calculations, Venison was to be one of the most profitable businesses, yet very few seemed to be in that business. I took a look at the "Supply & Demand" in "Statistics" section of Kapi-Regnum, and tried to spot some relation on why Venison might be profitable, but none was to be found. Beer was in most demand, so it should be the most profitable? Or was it perhaps the ratio between demand and supply, meaning Eierdowns would be the most profitable business?

:?: How others do their calculations?
As I have gained more experience in Kapi-Regnum, I have begun to wonder how other players calculate their way to the most profitable business? Do they apply the formula for at which price you can sell at market stalls, comparing your product quality to the average price and quality at NPC market? Do they take into consideration the cost of the buildings needed for production, sale and knowledge? Do they use the "Market Writer" to follow trends? Are some players only in the NPC market business (pure market stalls, not producing anything by themselves)? I would love to get some input on what others consider good business, why, and what calculations are behind that statement.

:idea: I would love to hear from you.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I use market prices of components to calculate profits.

However, another consideration which I haven't figured in is the time component. I produce my own beets for my own wool for rainments. I sell rainments by contract and in my own stalls. That's quite a few steps for my initial production of beets to show a profit. Even though I charge more for my rainments in my market stalls it is a slow process to get my money. When I send the same amount via contract it is almost instantly paid for.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I use a similar approach. I haven't tried out a fishery yet and now I'm regretting it because I'm far enough along in the businesses I tried that I don't really want to start it. You should look at stones and furniture though.

One thing to be aware of is market stability and liquidity. Some of the caravan products come out very profitable but the market is strange - there can be no sales for days while products just sit on the market and the offering price drops and drops until it's actually unprofitable. Then somebody comes along and, fwoop, it's all gone and the offering price is high again. I know you don't have caravan products yet but seeing how on top of things you are you will soon ;-) IMO they should be profitable because they are SUCH a pain to run!

Pearls are made for deliveries, not stall sale, so I expect the market will be even more illiquid than the caravan products.

Venison and all the butchery products I've always been suspicious of because the profitability depends on the fact that livestock producers sell their products at a loss. I don't understand it but it's the same way in Kapilands. But even if deer were at a fair price venison would still be profitable, so maybe I was overcautious.

These things change, BTW. When I started a month ago beets, for example, were pretty mediocre. All the farm products were far inferior to wood. They've come up a lot in the past few weeks and now are getting close. In Kapilands the profitability of all manufactured goods climbs over time because the more promoted players are the less they can manufacture relative to what they can sell. Since wood is capped by the royal warehouse price, at some point - possibly soon - farm products will pass wood in profitability. I built a lot of lumberjacks at the start but I'm converting most to furniture now partly because of that and partly because it's now more profitable for me anyway since I can afford advertised stall and am facing slowing manufacturing rates from promotions.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I started in the meat-business because I like meat, and I produce all the required ingredients because I want to be completely selfreliant... Its not the fastest way to get rich, but its fun:) its also very comfortable not to work to get it all, be reliant to the shifting market prices and all that...
Guest

advice

Post by Guest »

if you want to go big real fast, you need to go high with the lumberjacks, stone pit, and 3 or menufacturies.
plus to that, add a self using metrial. such as fish or beer, or joeinery + printing press. this will allow you to have a few prodaction lines that you can upgrade them with ur own matrail and you alwyas have money that works for you.
if you go let's say, beer and fish, so you stock up high, and upgrade all of your prodaction line , that mean, if you have farms to supply grain so you upgrade you farms, you breweries and the taveren, but in the same time you have your fish and vic markets doing for you money and the contracts of matiral that you contract out.
i had a late start and spent a lot of cash on the contest but after 3 days i'm back in the top 80 and counting, just beacuse of this system
Guest

Re: Profitable business

Post by Guest »

Ragnarsson wrote: Do they take into consideration the cost of the buildings needed for production, sale and knowledge?
Yes!! Ranking profitability is a great start, but there are big differences in how much different buildings cost to build/expand.

The thread below is a "guide of guides" that contains a bunch of very useful threads. Recommend paying particular attention to the ROI threads. Since the game mechanics in Kapilands are extremely similar to Kapi Regnum, most of the information is applicable.

http://www.forum.kapilands.com/viewtopic.php?t=4434

One last comment that relates to your listing of pearls on the "top" list. There may be people listing pearls at very high prices, but that does not mean they are selling...
Guest

Post by Guest »

I am in the herb business right now. I just started playing on the 12th. City is Trivandrum.

I ran up a few numbers, and these were based on how much it would cost me if I produced the items on my own.

I made an assumption first on the cost of my production unit (farm, well, etc), by dividing 50 by the amount of goods produced per hour on a 20 MSQ unit.

So for water, it would be 50/1069.3 which is approx 0.05

All other input costs are derived from production costs of raw materials. I assumed I was self-sufficient.

A few numbers I realized (all level 0)....

Water Q0
Cost of production : 0.067 cT
Selling price : 0.23 cT
Price/cost = 3.43

Wood Q0
Cost of production : 4.27 cT
Selling price : 24 cT
Price/cost = 5.62

Beets Q0
Cost of production : 0.517 cT
Selling price : 3.5 cT
Price/cost = 6.76

Honey Q0
Cost of production : 16.87 cT
Selling price : 80 cT
Price/cost = 4.74

Herbs Q0
Cost of production : 2.738 cT
Selling price : 28 cT
Price/cost = 10.22

So I have been producing herbs for the last 6 days. I currently have 2 wells, 9 farms, and 1 lumberjack (all 20 MSQ). I also have a 20 MSQ market stall and a 80 MSQ monastery garden researching herbs all the time.

I am currently on level 7 herbs research, producing Q3 herbs and I am selling them at 29.5 to 32 cT (contracts and stall)
Guest

Time.

Post by Guest »

When i calculate i always include the time factor. This is the most important factor. Take flax and beets:

Flax sells at the market for (about) double the price of beets.

Production prices:

Beets: 0,35

Flax 2,7

Sell prices:

Beets: 6-12(averange 9)
Profit: 8,65

Flax 20-30 (averange 25)
Profit: 23,3

If you look just at this information flax is more profitable per produced unit. However, if we take the time factor into play we get a totally different picture. I usually calculate with profit per hour, lets see the statistics. I have assumed a averange price for profits (9 for beets, and 25 for flax)
Rank Baron, 2000sqm farm.

Beets profit per hour:
4909,09 Hourly production x 8,65 profit per unit = 42463,6 Profit per hour

Flax profit per hour:
1472,73 Hourly production x 23,3 per unit =34314,6 profit per hour.

This is only for a simple production. If you have more complex productions, the calculations are more complex but doable. if you want to compare different SQM sizes or buildings, compare profit per worker.
Lets follow the previous example:

Beets profit per worker:
42463,6 profit per hour (divided by) 200 workers= 212,3 hourly profit per worker

Flax profit per worker per hour:
34314,6 Profit per hour (divided by) 200 workers = 171,6 hourly profit per worker

We can see what is most profitable? 2000sqm lumberjack or 2000 sqm farm?Calculations for baron and 2000sqm buildings

Beets, hourly profits per worker: 212,3

Wood, hourly profits per worker: 149,1

23(sell price)- 6,8 (cost)= 16,2 (profit)
16,2 (profit) x1840,91(production for an hour) = 29822,7
29822,7 (hourly profit) / 200 (employees) = 149,1

Here we can see a suprising result, even though the profit per unit for wood is double the profit per unit for beets. The wood only have 70% profit rate per hour compared to beets(100%)

Then a more complex example:

Shelves profit per worker (1000sqm joinery)
Buy all needed materials
need 0,1xiron(12), 1xtools(12) and 3xwood(69)

Sell price(my market): 800 - Total cost:93
profit per unit: 707

Profit per hour: 707 x 272,73 = 192820,1
time market selling one hour production: Selling units per hour: 212, time spent selling 272units: 272 (dvided by) 212= 1,3 hours (or 76 minutes).

Total time 272 units of shelves
Production 1hour + selling 1,3 hour= 2,3 hours
Profit per hour (total): 192820,1 (divided by) 2,3 =83834,8

Profit per employee per hour (joinery1000SQM +market3500sqm):
profit per hour 83834,8 (divided by) employees 450 = 186,3

There is a complex example. However if you produce materials yourself it will be more complex indeed. And i dont want to sit all day and do calculations (i suck in excel).
I didnt know beets was more profitable then my shelves :P

Edit: Just did profit per worker per hour for water: 28,42

Long post, but hope it helps!
Guest

Post by Guest »

Actually, when you are the beginner, you could collect all of your materials from the market. Some ingrediants were too cheap because...sometimes the city sell this things not for sale, just for clear their store. So you could get the cheaper things from the market.

But when you get bigger, your need will be increase. At this time, you find you are always run out of materials. Then you need to find the suppliers to supply enough materials and keep your production line working without problem. And, your suppliers charge you higher price because at this time his intension is selling, not clear their store. He will never sell the things which is as cheap as the market's offer.

You must keep this situation in mind.... market's price can not be your reference. Someone sell their things very expensive just for advertisement (He hope someone clicks his showcase and find his offer), and someone just want to clear their warehouse, or someone just want to raise the commodity price.

Hope this will help you :) And actually, beer is more stable for earning profit. The stable profits is more important than unstable huge sum of the profit.

Cheers

Banana City
Guest

Post by Guest »

Sild, that market is way too large for that joinery. My optimal ratio is about 1:1. At 1:3.5 profit/worker is 23% less.

Who's buying beets at 9 per? At that price all the animals are INSANELY unprofitable. Can't check the prices now but the animal prices in my spreadsheet (from the last time I checked) are all far below cost of production at 9 per.
Guest

Prices

Post by Guest »

I got two more joinerys at 1000SQM, and i like overpricing to push prices UP, i always price my wares in my markets so around 80 think my wares are too expencive... this makes the averange price rise in the long run. If i sell at optimal selling price (when the products sell fastest) i earn less per unit but can sell much larger quantities. However the side effect is that in the long run the price of what i am selling will ever spiral downwards.
So at the cost of short term profits I get long term profits.

In addition with this tactics i can focus more on markets then workshops, witch has much more profit per upgraded SQM.

As to the price of beets, prices was drawn out of a hat since there is a competition on now. But it serves to show calculations.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Well, if you have 3 joineries for the workshop, you should only count 1/3 of the workers from the market for determining profit, because the other 2/3 are normally selling goods from the other joineries. That would be roughly a perfect ratio for profits. I'm not anywhere big enough to affect market prices, and doubt I ever will be, so I don't worry about that.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I calculated how long it took me to sell 1hour production at the given price.
That is the same no matter who is supplying the market? But anyway, yes dont worry about price before you get big (dont know if i do a difference, but when i started selling shelves they where selling for 600 at max)
Guest

Re: advice

Post by Guest »

matikonen wrote:if you want to go big real fast, you need to go high with the lumberjacks, stone pit, and 3 or menufacturies.
plus to that, add a self using metrial. such as fish or beer, or joeinery + printing press. this will allow you to have a few prodaction lines that you can upgrade them with ur own matrail and you alwyas have money that works for you.
if you go let's say, beer and fish, so you stock up high, and upgrade all of your prodaction line , that mean, if you have farms to supply grain so you upgrade you farms, you breweries and the taveren, but in the same time you have your fish and vic markets doing for you money and the contracts of matiral that you contract out.
i had a late start and spent a lot of cash on the contest but after 3 days i'm back in the top 80 and counting, just beacuse of this system
Getting some manufacturing happening is good. Especially since you already own lumberjacks and stone pits are next in order (kind of).

Another approach and product I'd recommend is quills. It is a late entrant into the game and a lot of TOP cities didn't bother adopting the product.

All you need is a farm to make grain, a cattle farm to raise geese (both are inexpensive) Then buy some good quality tools (find a reliable and reasonable supplier) and maybe acquire a printing press. I'm sure there are people wanting to sell some of these all the time.

Quills use 0.1 geese and 0.1 tools each. Considering that make ur own geese and import good tools, your cost per unit is quite low, but they sell for prices quite comparable to beer. Build a manufacturers market and try selling these.

I recommend quills since the production chain is both shorter and simpler than beer. So, it is easy to research your quills (3- grain, geese and quills) in comparison to beer (5- grain, beer, tools, casks, iron)

I didn't enter the raw materials for tools into the quills eqn as it is more economical to just buy good quality tools as compared to good quality iron (which you will have to do for casks-beer)
Post Reply