Armory & Indulgences - Are they worth it?
Moderator: moderators
-
Guest
Armory & Indulgences - Are they worth it?
Okay, I put in the goldsmith and armorer, as well as the indulgences stall and armory stall. To date, the weapons and jewelry that I have sold in the market stalls sell at the pace of snails on a cold day. Do others have the same problem trying to sell these expensive to produce items? Has anyone managed to increase sales rate through pamphlets and increasing the sizes of the stalls? Has anyone said to heck with it and just ripped the suckers back out? 
-
Guest
I think that a lot of ppl have just plucked them in the bud.
well, I can say one thing, I have thought of building large market stalls and not worrying about the production of these. Then I can just sell them at a margin to my purchase cost. But I doubt these things will be very profitable even then. The demand for them is way too low.
well, I can say one thing, I have thought of building large market stalls and not worrying about the production of these. Then I can just sell them at a margin to my purchase cost. But I doubt these things will be very profitable even then. The demand for them is way too low.
-
Guest
Have made the same mistake...
I tried to catch it up by upgrading my indulgences, but after all even that is a waste of money (and time)
It might be worth building them only if you wish to send statues to a cathedral or something, but still... All i can do now i using what buildings i have, and try to find big cities willing to buy my statues. I have to admit most do not worry about the price, and if i can sell 500 of them at 500cT each, i still have some profit after all...
But other buildings give lots more cT's in that same time and with the same investments...
These goods aren't the best choice
I tried to catch it up by upgrading my indulgences, but after all even that is a waste of money (and time)
It might be worth building them only if you wish to send statues to a cathedral or something, but still... All i can do now i using what buildings i have, and try to find big cities willing to buy my statues. I have to admit most do not worry about the price, and if i can sell 500 of them at 500cT each, i still have some profit after all...
But other buildings give lots more cT's in that same time and with the same investments...
These goods aren't the best choice
-
Guest
I was selling arquebuses. I could make a profit, but the speed of sale isn't worth the wait, even though the demand was really high.
With average quality and average price, right now you make a 550ct profit on one arquebus. That's only a 35% profit AND its a slow profit -- I'm not sure how many you can sell in a day per sqm.
I sold the armorour and bought another farm for my beets (averaging 80% profit).
With average quality and average price, right now you make a 550ct profit on one arquebus. That's only a 35% profit AND its a slow profit -- I'm not sure how many you can sell in a day per sqm.
I sold the armorour and bought another farm for my beets (averaging 80% profit).
-
Guest
I think the secret to making a profit on those low demand products is to have big markets -- really, really big markets. Quality is important, too, but I think it all turns on being willing to invest a lot up front building the market in which to sell them.
I don't have any experience with goldsmith or armorer products, but I do have some with carpets and eiderdown, and those are, I think, comparable in their complexity and demand. Let's look at eiderdown.
Eiderdown is expensive to make. It takes 20 geese, 2 tools and a drapery. I make the geese and drapery myself, but I buy high Q tools, and an eiderdown costs me between 300 and 400 kapi-thalers to make. At that cost (and I cannot get it any lower and maintain quality) I cannot afford to sell these for 800 or 900 each. The margin isn't good enough; I might as well sell the weaver's shop, roast the geese and buy a brewery.
But in a large drapery, I make good money. In a 260 sq.m. drapery, I can get 2500 kapi-thalers each for an eiderdown, and in a 400 sq.m., it pushes 3000. I only sell between 100 and 200 a day because my production is limited by how many geese I can make, but for each one I sell, I net at least 2000 kapi-thalers. I suspect there are not that many products in the game providing that kind of profit per item.
Same with carpets. When Colchester started producing carpets, the stat price was under 400, and several people told me carpets would never make a profit and were only good for making salt. It costs me about 130 to make a carpet, and selling them for under 400 in a 60 sq.m. stall was not an attractive proposition. But in a 260 sq.m. drapery, I can sell 500 carpets a day for over 900 kapi-thalers each. That's a profit on each one of about 800 kapi-thaler, so the net income for the carpet drapery stall is pushing half a million a day.
Now, I'm not saying that this is true for goldsmith and armorer products, for your mileage may vary. But I am saying that if I were not maxed out on buildings, I would have a goldsmith and an indulgences stall, because I think there is a market there, and I would love to be the one to open it up.
I don't have any experience with goldsmith or armorer products, but I do have some with carpets and eiderdown, and those are, I think, comparable in their complexity and demand. Let's look at eiderdown.
Eiderdown is expensive to make. It takes 20 geese, 2 tools and a drapery. I make the geese and drapery myself, but I buy high Q tools, and an eiderdown costs me between 300 and 400 kapi-thalers to make. At that cost (and I cannot get it any lower and maintain quality) I cannot afford to sell these for 800 or 900 each. The margin isn't good enough; I might as well sell the weaver's shop, roast the geese and buy a brewery.
But in a large drapery, I make good money. In a 260 sq.m. drapery, I can get 2500 kapi-thalers each for an eiderdown, and in a 400 sq.m., it pushes 3000. I only sell between 100 and 200 a day because my production is limited by how many geese I can make, but for each one I sell, I net at least 2000 kapi-thalers. I suspect there are not that many products in the game providing that kind of profit per item.
Same with carpets. When Colchester started producing carpets, the stat price was under 400, and several people told me carpets would never make a profit and were only good for making salt. It costs me about 130 to make a carpet, and selling them for under 400 in a 60 sq.m. stall was not an attractive proposition. But in a 260 sq.m. drapery, I can sell 500 carpets a day for over 900 kapi-thalers each. That's a profit on each one of about 800 kapi-thaler, so the net income for the carpet drapery stall is pushing half a million a day.
Now, I'm not saying that this is true for goldsmith and armorer products, for your mileage may vary. But I am saying that if I were not maxed out on buildings, I would have a goldsmith and an indulgences stall, because I think there is a market there, and I would love to be the one to open it up.
-
Guest
gonzo, your point is right!
The market area is an important thing. I produced Arquebuses on the German server and I needed 12 times the production area for my market stalls to get an acceptable price.
This proportion may change with the adaptations in game but in my opinion it worked very well. Halberds on the other hand only needed 4 times the area of the production.
best regards,
Volki
The market area is an important thing. I produced Arquebuses on the German server and I needed 12 times the production area for my market stalls to get an acceptable price.
This proportion may change with the adaptations in game but in my opinion it worked very well. Halberds on the other hand only needed 4 times the area of the production.
best regards,
Volki
-
Guest
-
Guest
Not many times hgher, but granted, half again as much as saint statues. Here are the 15 least demanded items, and I would bet they are all a challenge to market.Desecrates wrote:Well, my experience with eiderdown is that they fly off of the shelves faster than I can pluck the geese!! But I would also argue that the demand for eiderdown is many times higher than that for saint statues and other indulgences.
product demand
war horses 107,257
arquebuses 108,090
silk 110,546
swords 117,593
suits of armour 119,213
silver jewellery 159,414
gold jewellery 163,076
pearl necklaces 170,417
carpets 184,808
mussel necklaces 186,434
halberds 199,531
saint statues 222,303
eiderdowns 334,776
tables 421,590
casks 486,815
I said your mileage may vary. If those eiderdowns are flying off the shelf, then you're not getting enough for them. Colchester provides a third to a half of the realm eiderdown market, selling at 2500 or better. Yesterday, there were about 300 eiderdown sold, and the stat price is only 1538. Somebody is practically giving them away.
-
Guest
I think you guys have a point here..
big market areas are really good for selling extremely expensive to make goods.
Just as an example (not strictly though), I make horses - q5 right now.
I make a lot of beets and import as much as I can lay my hands on reasonably. well,.. thing is each horse requires so much of beets that I end up making only about 400-500 horses each batch. However, the speed of making them is good, considering they deliver a handsome profit per piece sold. If I was to make say.. wool or goats or something out of beets, I would produce a few times more the quantity but the price per unit is extremely low.
So, in addition to the time per unit, I think we have to factor in the time per Thaler. Then you can really figure out if its worth it.
And I consider the establishment costs as sunk costs as they continue to provide value far after they were built. and ad points n all make a huge difference. I have manufactory markets. I'm selling quills. In fact I'm the first maker and seller of quills in Regnum. I pushed the stat price up, but some idiots are dragging it down. And still, I'm able to sell them abt 60 cT higher than stat price in advertised big stores. They rake in abt 100k profit a day for me. would be more when I upgrade the quality further and enlarge the stores. And the production cost is next to nothing.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
So, have:
good profit per unit of time
good quality
large stores
&
full advertisement
and you can do it.
big market areas are really good for selling extremely expensive to make goods.
Just as an example (not strictly though), I make horses - q5 right now.
I make a lot of beets and import as much as I can lay my hands on reasonably. well,.. thing is each horse requires so much of beets that I end up making only about 400-500 horses each batch. However, the speed of making them is good, considering they deliver a handsome profit per piece sold. If I was to make say.. wool or goats or something out of beets, I would produce a few times more the quantity but the price per unit is extremely low.
So, in addition to the time per unit, I think we have to factor in the time per Thaler. Then you can really figure out if its worth it.
And I consider the establishment costs as sunk costs as they continue to provide value far after they were built. and ad points n all make a huge difference. I have manufactory markets. I'm selling quills. In fact I'm the first maker and seller of quills in Regnum. I pushed the stat price up, but some idiots are dragging it down. And still, I'm able to sell them abt 60 cT higher than stat price in advertised big stores. They rake in abt 100k profit a day for me. would be more when I upgrade the quality further and enlarge the stores. And the production cost is next to nothing.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
So, have:
good profit per unit of time
good quality
large stores
&
full advertisement
and you can do it.
-
Guest
The Armory & Indulgence is a long-term investment for me. Since so few are making my products, I am hoping, once I expan, the supply will still be extremely low ... and I can take advantage of the prices:
Demand---Product---Number---Price-----Quality
109,238---war horses-----7-------1,706.51-----3.34
I sell Warhorses for 2500, and they are Q5, though I think current; I am losing profits if I sold materials separately.
arms dealer E:5 50sqm 86 war horses (q: 5) 193:22:30
It has 44k ads (full ads)
The reason I have it so long is because the contest and also my traders need more horses.
Still, even at my price, I'll be selling more horses each day then sold in the above example. Am I the only seller? :/ ...
Demand---Product---Number---Price-----Quality
109,238---war horses-----7-------1,706.51-----3.34
I sell Warhorses for 2500, and they are Q5, though I think current; I am losing profits if I sold materials separately.
arms dealer E:5 50sqm 86 war horses (q: 5) 193:22:30
It has 44k ads (full ads)
The reason I have it so long is because the contest and also my traders need more horses.
Still, even at my price, I'll be selling more horses each day then sold in the above example. Am I the only seller? :/ ...
-
Guest
hey breth..
my costs per horse vary by whether I imported the beets or made them myself, but I'm supplying at 1550 per horse (50cT disc b'coz the customer is extremely steady) and I manage to sell abt 600-800 horses a day. As a rough guess, I'm making more than 600k per day, but with a great scope for improvement as my cattle farms remain idle for periods between logins as I never have enough beets to set a whole days production. But then it also helps my beer production, as it covers the cost of importing grain for beer production. I make better quality beer if I import beer (abt 3-4 q better) and it sells way better too, so it is profits in more than one way.
I think, that at this rate selling horses rather than armoured horses is a good option until your store size is REALLY large enough and the quality is super good. Thats all I can gauge from what you have told us.
well,.. good luck monopolising the armoured horse market, I don't think you are gonna face much competition anytime soon.
my costs per horse vary by whether I imported the beets or made them myself, but I'm supplying at 1550 per horse (50cT disc b'coz the customer is extremely steady) and I manage to sell abt 600-800 horses a day. As a rough guess, I'm making more than 600k per day, but with a great scope for improvement as my cattle farms remain idle for periods between logins as I never have enough beets to set a whole days production. But then it also helps my beer production, as it covers the cost of importing grain for beer production. I make better quality beer if I import beer (abt 3-4 q better) and it sells way better too, so it is profits in more than one way.
I think, that at this rate selling horses rather than armoured horses is a good option until your store size is REALLY large enough and the quality is super good. Thats all I can gauge from what you have told us.
well,.. good luck monopolising the armoured horse market, I don't think you are gonna face much competition anytime soon.
-
Guest
True, I know I am running at a loss in profits, but still making them.
I grow my own beats, buying from other increase the price by much, I make armored horses for about 847cT
Well, I hope you continue to sell your horses and such, I must admit though I am seesawing alot from trade and armour horses, I may take a break and focus more on trade
I grow my own beats, buying from other increase the price by much, I make armored horses for about 847cT
Well, I hope you continue to sell your horses and such, I must admit though I am seesawing alot from trade and armour horses, I may take a break and focus more on trade
-
Guest
-
Guest
Hoom-hah. I've been fiddling with armaments for the last three weeks, and I've finally got something of a handle on it.
And so, it is with great pride that Colchester Arms announces the production of its first lot of war horses -- 200 of them, Q8, which sold in the arms dealer earlier today for 3200 kapi thalers each. That's almost double yesterday's stat price, which subsequently increased by 500 and is now second only to arquebuses.
We know we are not going to get rich on war horses, but they do net about half a million kapi thalers a day, so we're happy with them. And if we all make sure we get at least stat price every day, even if it means leaving them in the market longer, we'll all make more money.
And for those who may be curious -- it takes a 1000 sq.m. market to get that price in a 24-hour sales cycle.
And so, it is with great pride that Colchester Arms announces the production of its first lot of war horses -- 200 of them, Q8, which sold in the arms dealer earlier today for 3200 kapi thalers each. That's almost double yesterday's stat price, which subsequently increased by 500 and is now second only to arquebuses.
We know we are not going to get rich on war horses, but they do net about half a million kapi thalers a day, so we're happy with them. And if we all make sure we get at least stat price every day, even if it means leaving them in the market longer, we'll all make more money.
And for those who may be curious -- it takes a 1000 sq.m. market to get that price in a 24-hour sales cycle.
Last edited by Guest on Wed Mar 19, 2008 2:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.
