Okay, I got a question for a long time, but didn't try to find it out.
Now it truly happend, so need to know.
It's about trading with players.
I've read the rules, and know that:
(2) Presents, credits or trades with an extreme advantage on one side
are not allowed. If one of these things is detected the depending account
will be deleted.
But does it included coins?
I mean, if I want to give someone a gift; Since giving BIG discount
buildings was illegal, may I use coins as my gift?
I happend like this...
PTT, as known as " Pirate of Trading from Taiwan " accauly was just a
name of bulletin board system in Taiwan. We heard kapi from a bord
on there(2007/10/07), and started a new board in PTT just for kapi
(2007/10/28).
We are a group just like TIB, but since our discussing board was
communicated in Chinese, not English. So, we didn't advertising ourself
a lot.
We also help new players. For example, I buy wood from them at 23[ct].
If they were shy to send at that price to me, I buy water from NPC and
sold them in lower price to let the wood price become 23[ct].
Buying that at 23 or 24[ct] was not a big difference to me, I'd rather
spent more money to buy from NPC and keep my cash for a longer time.
(Yes, he/she was right, Cash is Kingdom, cash makes more and more
money.) Doing all that was just trying to let them grow faster and find the
fun in this game. All OLG was the same, more people, more fun.
At about 2007/12/30, one of us started an event to celebrate new year.
He take his coins out to be the reward in this event. I have told him
maybe doing this was not good, according to the rules I had mentioned
above. But he said coins come from real money, it should be okay. And I
didn't think more.
At about 2007/01/08, one of our friend had been baned.
Not knowing was that caused by our new year celebrating event
- 1 cap coin trade.
( Cause I don't have account at 3.0's board, so I posted at here since
here also have coins. )
****
Discounts.
Again, another friend had been ban. He was baned because he use the
network in his lab. His lab use same IP for all computers to connect
outside. One of his friend stop playing this game, so sold his building
IN A FAIR PRICE to him.
He know it's his fault, he should know this and avoid it; Same IP.
Now comes the problem:
So many people baned beside me, I'm confused.
If it's so danger to trade, should I still help the new ones?
Which kind of discount was allowed?
I know, I have some memory like this...
" Although I'm not an admit, but I'll lock my account if I... "
" ... should give 10% discount, not like 80% off discount... "
Could we have this allowed disscount range clearly writed in rules?
Sorry for writing so long, but my English was not good. I tried my best.
- Crow
Trading, Coins, Discounts.
Moderator: moderators
-
Guest
Hi.
I will try to answer your questions as good as I can and as far as my knowledge goes:
1. The rule about not selling with a large disadvantage on one side also applies to coins. Of course you cannot sell coins for 1 cT. Selling coins for one cT looks very much like a multiaccount. If you want to give some people a present, there are presents you can give them:
3. You can still help small cities getting big. I doubt that buying wood for 24 or water for 0.24 is the right way, but that is no problem. I even thought about buying raw materials slightly above npc prices (25, or 0.25) for smaller cities, but since I didn´t have time to think about conditions to avoid people misusing this I have not done it yet. I think the best advice would be, not to produce raw materials, because other wares make more profit.
4.
There will not be a discount range written in the rules. If you would do that, it would surely be misused by cheaters. If you allow a discount of 50%, all cheaters will sell their wares from second account to their main account for 50% off market price and could never be banned for cheating. So it is for the best of all fair playing people, not to state such rules.
I hope this answered all of your questions.
Elwood
I will try to answer your questions as good as I can and as far as my knowledge goes:
1. The rule about not selling with a large disadvantage on one side also applies to coins. Of course you cannot sell coins for 1 cT. Selling coins for one cT looks very much like a multiaccount. If you want to give some people a present, there are presents you can give them:
2. People using the same IP are not allowed to trade with each other. That´s the rule and people should know about that.gifts (not tradeable for kapi thalers!)
small sack of pepper 4 points Buy for 2 coins
signet seal 40 points Buy for 20 coins
guild's ring 30 points Buy for 15 coins
golden disc of the world 250 points Buy for 125 coins
3. You can still help small cities getting big. I doubt that buying wood for 24 or water for 0.24 is the right way, but that is no problem. I even thought about buying raw materials slightly above npc prices (25, or 0.25) for smaller cities, but since I didn´t have time to think about conditions to avoid people misusing this I have not done it yet. I think the best advice would be, not to produce raw materials, because other wares make more profit.
4.
I think I am the one who wrote these lines, if not, I could have been." Although I'm not an admit, but I'll lock my account if I... "
" ... should give 10% discount, not like 80% off discount... "
There will not be a discount range written in the rules. If you would do that, it would surely be misused by cheaters. If you allow a discount of 50%, all cheaters will sell their wares from second account to their main account for 50% off market price and could never be banned for cheating. So it is for the best of all fair playing people, not to state such rules.
I hope this answered all of your questions.
Elwood
-
Guest
I've read the things that I writed before, and found that the words I use
was a little bit rude; I apologize for that... <(_ _)>
enought to let me (want to) start chasing on reputations/scores.
Maybe the page of sending coins to other city/company should have a
warning, also give a link to the page of gifts.
And, add one line into the rules, telling people that coins maybe will be
used by cheaters on doing bad things to the game, so that coins can not
be used as gifts directly.
a chance to undo the trade.
He know they have same IP was after he had been ban. Although he
knows and acept the fault he had made, but us (his friends) was still
sigh for his leaving; Leaving just because of the dam c class address
used by there university.
Spending one more step on these kind of things may save a company
which need four month to build.
If it had been writed into the rules, cheaters will use it.
Thanks for your patient on answering Crow's long long questions. : )
was a little bit rude; I apologize for that... <(_ _)>
Well, I haven't found this before, since my city/company wasn't bigelwood74 wrote: 1. The rule about not selling with a large disadvantage on one side also applies to coins. Of course you cannot sell coins for 1 cT. Selling coins for one cT looks very much like a multiaccount. If you want to give some people a present, there are presents you can give them:gifts (not tradeable for kapi thalers!)
small sack of pepper 4 points Buy for 2 coins
signet seal 40 points Buy for 20 coins
guild's ring 30 points Buy for 15 coins
golden disc of the world 250 points Buy for 125 coins
enought to let me (want to) start chasing on reputations/scores.
Maybe the page of sending coins to other city/company should have a
warning, also give a link to the page of gifts.
And, add one line into the rules, telling people that coins maybe will be
used by cheaters on doing bad things to the game, so that coins can not
be used as gifts directly.
I suggest to gave them a warning at the first time, and let them have2. People using the same IP are not allowed to trade with each other. That´s the rule and people should know about that.
a chance to undo the trade.
He know they have same IP was after he had been ban. Although he
knows and acept the fault he had made, but us (his friends) was still
sigh for his leaving; Leaving just because of the dam c class address
used by there university.
Spending one more step on these kind of things may save a company
which need four month to build.
You're right, I haven't thought this before.3. You can still help small cities getting big. I doubt that buying wood for 24 or water for 0.24 is the right way, but that is no problem. I even thought about buying raw materials slightly above npc prices (25, or 0.25) for smaller cities, but since I didn´t have time to think about conditions to avoid people misusing this I have not done it yet. I think the best advice would be, not to produce raw materials, because other wares make more profit.
4.I think I am the one who wrote these lines, if not, I could have been." Although I'm not an admit, but I'll lock my account if I... "
" ... should give 10% discount, not like 80% off discount... "
There will not be a discount range written in the rules. If you would do that, it would surely be misused by cheaters. If you allow a discount of 50%, all cheaters will sell their wares from second account to their main account for 50% off market price and could never be banned for cheating. So it is for the best of all fair playing people, not to state such rules.
I hope this answered all of your questions.
Elwood
If it had been writed into the rules, cheaters will use it.
Thanks for your patient on answering Crow's long long questions. : )
