Beer is overpriced.

What's going on in Kapi Regnum? This section is for everything concerning the game itself

Moderator: moderators

Post Reply
Guest

Beer is overpriced.

Post by Guest »

What is going on here. Everyone has lost their mind thinking that their beer is that valuable. I don't know if they think they are getting that much profit out of their own taverns but I have 2 200sqm taverns with no beer in them. My bartenders can live the life of Riley for all I care. I don't need the income from them and I'm not going to make money for someone else.

Also, there is 6 million thaler worth of beer offered at the market. I hope you guys like to pay commision for nothing.
Guest

Post by Guest »

What are you talking about? I don't understand what the problem is...

Market beer or Tavern beer is overprice?
Guest

Post by Guest »

I think that Duncan is saying that people are asking too much for beer on the open market. The beer market is kind of matching the overexuberance seen in markets in the past, such as Tulipomania or all farmers jumping into hog farming when pork bellies go up on the commodities market.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Honestly, I know that beer is not that profitable until you get to q7 maybe. But then that's the way it should be. And then around that quality you can slowly make more. That's the way it's going to be if you build your own taverns. And btw, I've liquidated all of my taverns. I think it was worth it.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Did you ever try to put Pamphlets on your taverns? 200 sqm is worthy to do so. You will propabably get a totally different vision to Beer.

The major reason "caused people to sell their Beer to other city with lower price" is that, they could adjust the price a little higher in the stall. Says I sold 20,000 Beer as 170¢ in my taverns daily. If I deliver 2,000 Beer as 100¢ to other city, is that possible to sell the rest 18,000 Beer as 178¢ or even higher? If not, someone lost money via such trading.

It is not overrated, people will choose the best solution for themselves.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Ya say i produce phamlets if u need them :) But i find its plenty profitable, i have 15 satlls with arouned 300 in ea at 150 no phalets there 40 sq2 il reduce the amount i have latter and just upgrade them but, i make arouned 1 mill daily so my expansion of city is huge at this point, there plenty profit to be seen. i do have a bit of oversupply tho :(
Guest

Post by Guest »

miauwally wrote:Did you ever try to put Pamphlets on your taverns? 200 sqm is worthy to do so. You will propabably get a totally different vision to Beer.
Yes.
The major reason "caused people to sell their Beer to other city with lower price" is that, they could adjust the price a little higher in the stall. Says I sold 20,000 Beer as 170¢ in my taverns daily. If I deliver 2,000 Beer as 100¢ to other city, is that possible to sell the rest 18,000 Beer as 178¢ or even higher? If not, someone lost money via such trading.

It is not overrated, people will choose the best solution for themselves.
I'm not sure exactly what you mean, but if you sell your beer to other players for 100ct you should figure that that is the cost of the beer that you sell in your tavern also.
Guest

Post by Guest »

[quote="Duncan"][quote="miauwally"]The major reason "caused people to sell their Beer to other city with lower price" is that, they could adjust the price a little higher in the stall. Says I sold 20,000 Beer as 170¢ in my taverns daily. If I deliver 2,000 Beer as 100¢ to other city, is that possible to sell the rest 18,000 Beer as 178¢ or even higher? If not, someone lost money via such trading.

It is not overrated, people will choose the best solution for themselves.[/quote]

I'm not sure exactly what you mean, but if you sell your beer to other players for 100ct you should figure that that is the cost of the beer that you sell in your tavern also.[/quote]

Let's make a simple example.

One city produces 10,000 Beer every day. It takes 24 hours to sell 10,000 Beer as 170¢ at his own taverns. No matter what cost for brewing Beer, he will got 1.7 million after 24 hours.

Now, there is a trade between cities. He sold 1,000 Beer to another city and there are 9,000 Beer left.

Because of there are only 9,000 left, he can adjust the price for tavern selling. I assume it takes 24 hours to sell 9,000 Beer as 175¢.

9000x175 = 1575000¢, it is the income from taverns.

This city must get more profit from trading with other cities unless he should sell all Beer by himself. What is the minimum price for Beer trading?

(1,700,000-1,575,000)/1,000 = 125¢

All numeric are made up for explanation but may not fit actual situation.

Beer industry is profitable indeed.
Guest

Post by Guest »

miauwally wrote:
Duncan wrote:
miauwally wrote:The major reason "caused people to sell their Beer to other city with lower price" is that, they could adjust the price a little higher in the stall. Says I sold 20,000 Beer as 170¢ in my taverns daily. If I deliver 2,000 Beer as 100¢ to other city, is that possible to sell the rest 18,000 Beer as 178¢ or even higher? If not, someone lost money via such trading.

It is not overrated, people will choose the best solution for themselves.
I'm not sure exactly what you mean, but if you sell your beer to other players for 100ct you should figure that that is the cost of the beer that you sell in your tavern also.
Let's make a simple example.

One city produces 10,000 Beer every day. It takes 24 hours to sell 10,000 Beer as 170¢ at his own taverns. No matter what cost for brewing Beer, he will got 1.7 million after 24 hours.

Now, there is a trade between cities. He sold 1,000 Beer to another city and there are 9,000 Beer left.

Because of there are only 9,000 left, he can adjust the price for tavern selling. I assume it takes 24 hours to sell 9,000 Beer as 175¢.

9000x175 = 1575000¢, it is the income from taverns.

This city must get more profit from trading with other cities unless he should sell all Beer by himself. What is the minimum price for Beer trading?

(1,700,000-1,575,000)/1,000 = 125¢

All numeric are made up for explanation but may not fit actual situation.

Beer industry is profitable indeed.
Sure, I understand that, but that's under the assumption that you do not have enough inventory in stock to always sell demanded product and supply your own tavern optimally. If you plan your production an tavern building properly that event will not occur.

This is what I do with dried meat. I always have dried meat in stock for people to buy. Then when my inventory builds up I build more victuals markets. When I calculate the profit from selling my dried meat at the stall I consider the price of the dried meat to be the same as if I sold it to other cities. That way I make the same profit producing my dried meat if I sell it to other cities or sell at my stalls. Now I could just sell at my own victuals market but that's not as fun for me.

edit: Also, selling to cities allows me to build more workshops, which gives me more market share, but for dried meat I make about the same selling it as I do producing it so it doesn't matter that much to me which one I do.
Guest

Post by Guest »

9000x175 = 1575000¢, it is the income from taverns.
Actually this is not the income. This is the sales revenue. You haven't counted any cost at all.

I use a spreadsheet for this. The first thing that you should do is figure out how many is sold at different prices. Then you add the cost to the equations. Add acceptable costs, such as the cost of production (including inputs) or the market price for the goods (what you can sell to other players). Now you will have to make adjustments so that both the profitability of the market stall and the profitability of the workshop is acceptable.

Profit should be calculated as Margin(price-cost)*number/time(minutes)

The profitability of my market stall is a little lower than my workshop because my workshop (plus research) is more I think.

But that's basically how I do it.[/quote]
Guest

Post by Guest »

[quote="Duncan"][quote]9000x175 = 1575000¢, it is the income from taverns.[/quote]

Actually this is not the income. This is the sales revenue. You haven't counted any cost at all.

I use a spreadsheet for this. The first thing that you should do is figure out how many is sold at different prices. Then you add the cost to the equations. Add acceptable costs, such as the cost of production (including inputs) or the market price for the goods (what you can sell to other players). Now you will have to make adjustments so that both the profitability of the market stall and the profitability of the workshop is acceptable.

Profit should be calculated as Margin(price-cost)*number/time(minutes)

The profitability of my market stall is a little lower than my workshop because my workshop (plus research) is more I think.

But that's basically how I do it.[/quote][/quote]

I didn't take the cost into consideration indeed. However, I can't see any difference. I could give one more example which continues with last scenario.

Initially, a city has 1 million cash.

It costs 500,000¢ to buy cask, grain, water and to brew 10,000 Beer. Now, there are only 500,000¢ left. Of course, there are 10,000 Beer in stock. Then...

[1] He takes 24 hours to sell all Beer as 170¢ in his taverns. After 24 hours, there are 170¢x10,000 = 1,700,000¢ sales revenue. Finally, he has 500,000¢ + 1,700,000¢ = 2,200,000¢ cash.

[2] He trades 1,000 Beer for 120¢. He takes 24 hours to sell the rest of Beer (9,000) as 175¢ in his taverns. Finally, he has 500,000¢ + 175¢x9,000 + 120¢x1,000 = 2,195,000¢ cash.

Obviously, the case [2] lost 5,000¢ by trading. Does the aspect of cost definition play any critical role under such illustration? No matter how we manage the profit shareing insides our cities, the most important issue is to finger out what is the exact result.
Guest

Post by Guest »

miauwally wrote:
I didn't take the cost into consideration indeed. However, I can't see any difference. I could give one more example which continues with last scenario.
It most definitely has a cost because since you are selling it in your tavern instead you are not making the revenue from selling it to a player.
Does the aspect of cost definition play any critical role under such illustration? No matter how we manage the profit shareing insides our cities, the most important issue is to finger out what is the exact result.
I don't know about your numbers and you you are coming up with them but I can tell you one thing, that the price you sell at your tavern should be the same no matter how many you sell to other players.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I think the point being missed here is that your OWN Market size is limited.

by having a brewery that always outproduces the tavern's selling rate, you have an excess. Consider it investment at a lower rate of interest. So, you sell it at a slight discount and constantly upgrade both types.

Of course you can produce exactly what you sell, but... whats the fun.

By excess production, I always have enough to sell (I'm lying, I'm usually short but only because I can't make enuf for want of raw material - wood)

But still, as long as my manufacturing is over the req, I sell at a discount to my tavern price. Allows me to expand capacity. and that comes in handy when I'm promoted 'cause I lose efficiency, so expanded buildings make up for it.
Guest

Post by Guest »

miauwally wrote:[1] He takes 24 hours to sell all Beer as 170¢ in his taverns. After 24 hours, there are 170¢x10,000 = 1,700,000¢ sales revenue. Finally, he has 500,000¢ + 1,700,000¢ = 2,200,000¢ cash.

[2] He trades 1,000 Beer for 120¢. He takes 24 hours to sell the rest of Beer (9,000) as 175¢ in his taverns. Finally, he has 500,000¢ + 175¢x9,000 + 120¢x1,000 = 2,195,000¢ cash.

Obviously, the case [2] lost 5,000¢ by trading. Does the aspect of cost definition play any critical role under such illustration? No matter how we manage the profit shareing insides our cities, the most important issue is to finger out what is the exact result.
One important point that I missed is that [2] requires less market space and therefore costs less.

Or it should anyway if you charge the same price in both [1] and [2].
Last edited by Guest on Sat Dec 22, 2007 10:40 am, edited 1 time in total.
Guest

Post by Guest »

pk wrote:I think the point being missed here is that your OWN Market size is limited.
Yes, exactly.
Post Reply