Why Make Wine?

What's going on in Kapi Regnum? This section is for everything concerning the game itself

Moderator: moderators

Guest

Post by Guest »

Duncan wrote:I generally use cost of production when I produce the inputs myself, because I can't buy the input for less than I can produce it. If I could buy it for less I would buy it instead of produce it.

And it's not good to use the price that I could sell the good for because I would have to sell it for less than it's worth to me.
But this is exactly the problem with wine. Let´s say your production costs for grapes are 2. You need 20 to make wine, so wine cost is 40. Now you sell it for 200. That would mean your grapes have a value of 10 for you.

But since you can sell those grapes for 20 at the market or even higher in fruit market it makes no sense producing wine.

The problem is that a lot of goods can be sold for more than they are worth if you use them to produce something else and not for less!!!

But this problem is not caused by us (the users). The problem is that, at the beginning of the game, the stats price data table had a certain value. These values were balanced in a way, that some products are just not worth to produce. In our wine example: Either the price for grapes was too high, or the price for wine was too low.
But you can never tell what will happen in the future. Maybe the demand really goes up and supply stays down. Then the price might rise because people don´t need the wine to sell in shops, but to get status points. We will see.
But I doubt this. It has not happened on the German server yet.

Elwood
Guest

Post by Guest »

elwood74 wrote:
Duncan wrote:I generally use cost of production when I produce the inputs myself, because I can't buy the input for less than I can produce it. If I could buy it for less I would buy it instead of produce it.

And it's not good to use the price that I could sell the good for because I would have to sell it for less than it's worth to me.
But this is exactly the problem with wine. Let´s say your production costs for grapes are 2. You need 20 to make wine, so wine cost is 40. Now you sell it for 200. That would mean your grapes have a value of 10 for you.
Oh sorry. I didn't mean cost of production as it is defined in this game. I meant the whole amount that it costs you to produce something (not opportunity cost). I meant the cost of inputs, fixed costs (expected return from fixted costs), and what the game calls production costs. This is the amount that should be compared to the price to buy or sell grapes.
But since you can sell those grapes for 20 at the market or even higher in fruit market it makes no sense producing wine.
The fruit market is another building. Buildings cost money. So if you can sell the grapes at the fruit market for only 20 value of the grapes for production of wine is probably not 20. That depend of course if you can buy or sell grapes from players at that price. It costs much less to make grapes to sell to players than it does to make grapes to sell at the fruit market.
The problem is that a lot of goods can be sold for more than they are worth if you use them to produce something else and not for less!!!
But that keeps some goods used for production cheaper. If people could get more for them at the market they would charge players more for them.
But this problem is not caused by us (the users). The problem is that, at the beginning of the game, the stats price data table had a certain value.
What do you mean? The stat price is the average price sold, right?
These values were balanced in a way, that some products are just not worth to produce. In our wine example: Either the price for grapes was too high, or the price for wine was too low.
But you can never tell what will happen in the future. Maybe the demand really goes up and supply stays down.
Well, yes the supply should decrease. That is what is suppose to happen in an economy according to theory. Unfortunately it doesn't always work like that, especially when the producers are not sofisticated. People will probably keep producing wine even though they are making lousy profit and the price will probably stay low.
Then the price might rise because people don´t need the wine to sell in shops, but to get status points. We will see.
But I doubt this. It has not happened on the German server yet.

Elwood
Yeah.

- Duncan
Guest

Post by Guest »

With market stalls, please remember that such buildings should have their cost spread among all sales that you do from such a stall. If you have a fruit vendor, the idea is to keep product selling from that vendor constantly. In this way, the cost of the fruit vendor is spread out over all the products that you sell there. Ideally, such a vendor stall will remain viable and productive long after it has paid for itself.

With this game we have the luck of only having to pay the worker once and don't have to pay for maintenance on the vendor, no insurance, licensing, blah blah. The only extra costs come in expansion and new employees. Now, if you advertise as well, then you will have more costs. In fact, it would be easier to calculate the costs of advertisements than it would be to figure the cost of the vendor against all the product that you sell there.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Desecrates wrote:If you have a fruit vendor, the idea is to keep product selling from that vendor constantly. In this way, the cost of the fruit vendor is spread out over all the products that you sell there. .
Yes, but also you want to make the most profit possible while keeping them busy at all times and not having inventory back up.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I know that this might sound weird, but i am gonna put it anyway.

I have another argument to this, ever considered selling 20 grapes in the market, it will probably take more time then selling 1 wine. I sell both wine and grapes at my market since i had some low quality grapes and a victual market to sell them.

All everybody considered is the cost but time is also an important factor. Probably one of the most important factor. I am too lazy to do all the calculations but if you someone can workout the conditions and see actually how much income you generate per hour by selling equivalent amount of goods in both the markets and you would probably find that either both are same or very near to each other.

It is unlikely that grapes price would reach 100, but it is very likely that wine prices can reach within 400-500 just like vension price which has shot up considerably, almost double, but it would take time. At that time wine would definately turn into a more profitable business then expected.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I can confirm the time is more important fact.

I'm making horses, well, if I make wool or pigs or goats or something, I make more money per unit produced and sold.

BUT... horses (in terms of beets consumed, so, one horse = 300 wool and so on) take less time to make and deal a handsome profit. So, for a guaranteed supply of beets it makes more profit to turn the entire production to horses.

This was production.

Now, back to you Raptor - prove it right in sales.
Post Reply