Why Make Wine?
Moderator: moderators
-
Guest
Why Make Wine?
just doing some math, for the 20 grapes is takes to make 1 bottle of wine, i make alot more if i just sell the grapes themselfs.
i sell my grapes for 24.00 each that is 480.00 for 20 of them. If i use those 20 grapes to make one wine i can only sell that for 200-205 a bottle.
Am i wrong or is it a waste to make wine?
i sell my grapes for 24.00 each that is 480.00 for 20 of them. If i use those 20 grapes to make one wine i can only sell that for 200-205 a bottle.
Am i wrong or is it a waste to make wine?
-
Guest
I finished my "nifty" Access database for this game to calculate the cost of everything. With yesterday's stat prices, I figure that it costs just over 290¢τ. The cheapest wine on the open market is 150¢τ. Current Average Price is just over 208¢τ.
You figured correct - -at least until quality levels raise the average price up a bit (and people pay more attention to what they sell stuff in their taverns for)
You figured correct - -at least until quality levels raise the average price up a bit (and people pay more attention to what they sell stuff in their taverns for)
-
Guest
-
Guest
But you don't want to use the stat price for that. Use some cost of production. The stat price is retail price. You wouldn't use that for cost accounting.WeGotGame wrote:I finished my "nifty" Access database for this game to calculate the cost of everything. With yesterday's stat prices, I figure that it costs just over 290¢τ. The cheapest wine on the open market is 150¢τ. Current Average Price is just over 208¢τ.
You figured correct - -at least until quality levels raise the average price up a bit (and people pay more attention to what they sell stuff in their taverns for)
-
Guest
I like Knolls' "Pay Your Building" theory so that's the way I do my figuring. That way, components' costs are based on what you can get for them on the open market (which may still be under-figuring as this price is usually even lower than the stat cost).Duncan wrote: But you don't want to use the stat price for that. Use some cost of production. The stat price is retail price. You wouldn't use that for cost accounting.
If I spent half as much time on my work databases as I did on this game database, I'd be getting a promotion.
-
Guest
No, you would not necessarily use the stats price for cost accounting, but definitely not the production cost. Usually you have to use the market price. I don´t like the word cost of a product in this case, because the production costs tell you nothing. That is why I usually speak of the value of a product.Duncan wrote:But you don't want to use the stat price for that. Use some cost of production. The stat price is retail price. You wouldn't use that for cost accounting.
But if you usually sell your grapes for 30 in the fruit market, you can use this price to calculate the value. And I usually sell for stats price, so for some products I can use the stats price for these calculations.
But I think WeGotGame named the stats price of wine to show that you will not be able to sell wine for what it´s worth, not even in shops, because the stats price is so low.
Elwood
-
Guest
Ack! This post can be deleted. I don't know what happened.
I thought I put a post here yesterday.
If you use the price you would sell your inputs at the market stall to figure the cost of producing your finished product the price that you charge for your finished product will be too high. Use the cost of production instead.
I thought I put a post here yesterday.
If you use the price you would sell your inputs at the market stall to figure the cost of producing your finished product the price that you charge for your finished product will be too high. Use the cost of production instead.
Last edited by Guest on Mon Dec 10, 2007 9:35 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
Guest
But a market stall is another building. That one has to be paid also.WeGotGame wrote:I like Knolls' "Pay Your Building" theory so that's the way I do my figuring. That way, components' costs are based on what you can get for them on the open market (which may still be under-figuring as this price is usually even lower than the stat cost).Duncan wrote: But you don't want to use the stat price for that. Use some cost of production. The stat price is retail price. You wouldn't use that for cost accounting.
If I spent half as much time on my work databases as I did on this game database, I'd be getting a promotion.
-
Guest
I don't know if you mean the market price as in price to another player or price you make at your market stall.elwood74 wrote:Usually you have to use the market price.Duncan wrote:But you don't want to use the stat price for that. Use some cost of production. The stat price is retail price. You wouldn't use that for cost accounting.
I thought what was being said is that to use the stat price for grapes to figure the cost of making wine.
-
Guest
-
Guest
Let me see if I can remember Econ 100 correctly.
The actual cost of a good sold is its production cost, plus any associated transportation or marketing costs. I think. Maybe you don't put the transport and market costs in there.
The opportunity cost is what you gave up or what you could have gotten had you done something different.
In this case, the actual cost of the wine is what you paid to make it and sell it -- ingredients, production charges, etc.
The opportunity cost is what you would have made if you had sold the grapes as is.
And in this case, the opportunity cost is sufficiently high that there is no compelling reason to make wine.
Excluding, or course, those situations such as when you have a boatload of apples and a half a boatload of grapes and only one victualer stall and an idle brewery and tavern and you just happened to have a few Q6 casks sitting around and you have more apples on the way tomorrow, in which case you might get more profit quicker selling the apples through the victualer's stall and making wine with your half boatload of grapes in the idle brewery and selling it at the idle tavern. Too complex. This is why I never took another semester of economics. It made my brain hurt.
And all of this brings me to some related questions --
Is demand for wine (or for finished products in general) likely to increase as more people build special buildings. Wine can be delivered to either a cathedral or a workhouse. Right now, there are only 2 of the former and 4 of the latter. As we get more of those, will there be a greater demand for wine as people turn to the market to provide goods for their special buildings?
And if so, will this demand drive the price for the finished goods up to where they will be more profitable than just selling their component parts separately?
And if this does happen, can we at the same time expect the price of grapes to fall as more and more people join the game and discover that they are profitable with very little effort and then glut the market with them?
The actual cost of a good sold is its production cost, plus any associated transportation or marketing costs. I think. Maybe you don't put the transport and market costs in there.
The opportunity cost is what you gave up or what you could have gotten had you done something different.
In this case, the actual cost of the wine is what you paid to make it and sell it -- ingredients, production charges, etc.
The opportunity cost is what you would have made if you had sold the grapes as is.
And in this case, the opportunity cost is sufficiently high that there is no compelling reason to make wine.
Excluding, or course, those situations such as when you have a boatload of apples and a half a boatload of grapes and only one victualer stall and an idle brewery and tavern and you just happened to have a few Q6 casks sitting around and you have more apples on the way tomorrow, in which case you might get more profit quicker selling the apples through the victualer's stall and making wine with your half boatload of grapes in the idle brewery and selling it at the idle tavern. Too complex. This is why I never took another semester of economics. It made my brain hurt.
And all of this brings me to some related questions --
Is demand for wine (or for finished products in general) likely to increase as more people build special buildings. Wine can be delivered to either a cathedral or a workhouse. Right now, there are only 2 of the former and 4 of the latter. As we get more of those, will there be a greater demand for wine as people turn to the market to provide goods for their special buildings?
And if so, will this demand drive the price for the finished goods up to where they will be more profitable than just selling their component parts separately?
And if this does happen, can we at the same time expect the price of grapes to fall as more and more people join the game and discover that they are profitable with very little effort and then glut the market with them?
-
Guest
-
Guest
Sometimes you want to use the cost of production when the price to buy the input is less than the cost of production but you can't find enough people selling enough of the product so you have to produce some yourself. I've noticed that situation happening when players with lower rank can produce things cheaper but a market for the good just hasn't developed yet.elwood74 wrote:No, you would not necessarily use the stats price for cost accounting, but definitely not the production cost. Usually you have to use the market price. I don´t like the word cost of a product in this case, because the production costs tell you nothing. That is why I usually speak of the value of a product.Duncan wrote:But you don't want to use the stat price for that. Use some cost of production. The stat price is retail price. You wouldn't use that for cost accounting.
I generally use cost of production when I produce the inputs myself, because I can't buy the input for less than I can produce it. If I could buy it for less I would buy it instead of produce it.
And it's not good to use the price that I could sell the good for because I would have to sell it for less than it's worth to me.
-
Guest
Yes a player-to-player market for quest/special items will eventually develop, and if past history guides correctly then pricing for "quest packages" will provide reasonable profit to the seller that is above component costs. However, this could take quite a while to happen, and this does not mean that selling wine to the NPC will ever be profitable...gonzo914 wrote: And all of this brings me to some related questions --
Is demand for wine (or for finished products in general) likely to increase as more people build special buildings. Wine can be delivered to either a cathedral or a workhouse. Right now, there are only 2 of the former and 4 of the latter. As we get more of those, will there be a greater demand for wine as people turn to the market to provide goods for their special buildings?
And if so, will this demand drive the price for the finished goods up to where they will be more profitable than just selling their component parts separately?
