[2009-01-18 | 2359] 200,000 X Horses q1 [CLOSED]

Completed Auctions are archived here for later reference.
Locked
Guest

[2009-01-18 | 2359] 200,000 X Horses q1 [CLOSED]

Post by Guest »

For auction are 200,000 fine q1 horses. Prices in cT/Horse.

Starting bid: 9,000
Bid Increase: 500
Buy it Now: 12,000

Thanks for bidding.
Guest

Post by Guest »

extra horses available to the winner if required at the same price :)
Guest

Post by Guest »

Auction cancelled

or BIN from me/someone. Whichever way it pleases punters.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Since when was it possible to cancel an auction?
Guest

Post by Guest »

There is no rule about this at all.

So, I in all fairness only punish punters who seek to cause me financial grief by not bidding at all until the last minute. I never set up exorbitantly priced auctions (one exception).

Also, there were no bids at all. If there had been bids then I would not cancel the auction. I don't offer my products for irresponsible prices, so even the starting bid clears cost. Be assured that I won't dishonour a contract. EVER.
Guest

Post by Guest »

1. Changes can only be done by moderators.
Seems like a rule about it to me... This is nothing personal against you Pk, but I think its annoying to see auctions being changed without regard for the rules all the time, it makes it impossible to plan as a bidder.

What can happen if anyone can cancel their own auction is that suddenly private bids doesnt have to be written down, and that is against another rule again.

The whole point of an auction, at least for me, is that it is unchangable and binding. And if people think that they shouldnt be, then remove the rules that say that they are, so that we know what we are dealing with.

I understand your issue with the last minute bidders, even though I have been one myself some times. But if you dont want to sell for the starting bid price, then put out a higher price. You deside.

What I would like to see though, an idea I have been thinking about for a while now is an auction without a deadline.
Example:

10k farm/draper whatever

Starting bid: 500 mill
Min bid increase: 50 mill

Auction ends when there has been no new bids for 12 hours straight.

That way, there is no point in waiting for the last minute, everyone thats interested will just try and have the latest bid, no reason to wait. And if you like, you can just make your own auction like this in the building forum, where there are no annoying auction rules to abide by, and then you can cancel or do anything you want.

These are just my thoughts about the matter, and of course I will leave it up to the moderators to decide how things really are.
Guest

Post by Guest »

There are no rules regarding this, and there were no bids prior to this so the BIN is still active. There could have been other ways to lie his way out, but at least he was honest.

There might be a need for amendments regarding this, for now I'd say there's no breech of auction rules
Guest

My 2 cents.

Post by Guest »

I like his Idea too. i.e., that there should be an allowance for a condition to be added that if no one bids for xx.xx hrs then the auctioneer can declare the auction void.

On the other hand, I also believe that if there are no bids AT ALL, then the auctioneer should be able to cancel it anyway. without any made up reasons.

Reason for this is simple. I do not have anything against people who bid at the last minute. I do that a few times too. But where there is not a single bid until the end, there the winner is almost certainly decided by the luck of those online at the last minute only. Besides, if ppl forget to bid at that time then the owner is stuck with stock/items/buildings that he/she has to sell all over again.

Just like any other person's rights, a seller should be able to protect their rights as long as they set the auction up responsibly enough.

I'm a firm believer in calling a spade a spade. i.e., if a rule has to be made, then it should address the each specific problem clearly rather than a complicated rule that is meant to cover multiple things but may be misused if applied creatively.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I still think that the rule I quoted covers this, since canceling the auction is very much changing it. But since the moderators have said this is ok, then I officially withdraw my complaint:) But I do think that it should be specified in the rules, so that the ones bidding will be able to plan ahead.

And I agree with Tlite, it was an honest way of doing it. It would have been easy to fix under the table.
Guest

Post by Guest »

There is a simple solution for those not wanting to conform to the auction principles...

THE BUILDING MARKET

Please don't change the auction - auctions are so cool...

They are risky... we at least have the right to set a minimum price...

As for when people bid... Sheesh...

Auctions have the oportunity to sway in the direction of the seller or the buyer...
Guest

Post by Guest »

I think the auction rules could be revised regarding withdrawal when there are no bids. Everyone will have their own take on how the auction rules should be like, however it would really help if we updated the rules to set things in stone. It makes it easier to deal with situations where rules are not yet made for.

I've asked Therian about this matter, and we'll see what he thinks about amending the auction rules.

Cheers!
Guest

Post by Guest »

Firstly, I've added your Moderator title, Tlite - I had forgotten all about it until just now when reading this post. Shows how little time I've actually had! ;)

I'm not actually at home at the moment - am just "sneaking" on while on my course, which I don't intend to go into details about having already explained to a few people just how boring this place actually is .. but thats a story for another time!

Anyway:- The Auction Rules at present are more or less a direct translation from the German Forums when Kapi-Regnum was first released. I've often thought about rewriting them, and it would seem this may well be the right time to do so.

I wrote up a set of forum rules for Molehill Empire when that server first came online, and have since adapted it for RumbleRace. I administrate both these forums as well and given that Molehill Empire's forum style is virtually identical it should be that difficult to amend the rules there for here at Kapi-Regnum. I'll take a look when I get home anyway, should be leaving here in about half an hour from this post, so I'll be online in maybe 2 hours or so, give or take a few minutes here for there.

Why can't I just take a horse and carriage home and say sod to the buses? It'd certainly be much quicker!


Edit: Okay, back at home now (6:30pm server time) heading off for dinner shortly but when I get back I'll take a look into the rules.
They won't be put into place straight away however, as I'll be looking into getting opinions on how they will work and if any addendum's can be made.
Locked