Stalls have a diminishing return because if you only expand market stalls and don't expand production, the only way to profit from increased demand is to increase price, but because price is cubed in the formula, your ability to increase price is much more limited than your ability to increase quantity.
Imagine having a fixed number of brewers and only increasing the size of your tavern. Each increase in the size of your tavern yields less and less profit, because all you are doing is pushing up your price along an increasingly steep demand curve.
Optimally, you increase production and market stalls in tandem. But the ratio of stalls to production depends on the price you want to sell for.
Selling prices in stalls.
Moderator: moderators
-
Guest
Just now found the thread. Several comments
First off, Knoll’s threads are legendary. His analysis of market pricing is great, and the math works exactly the same in Kapi Regnum as it does in Kapilands. He has several other threads on the Kaplilands forums that cover other topics, and they are great as well. I have been using the formulas he shows since I first started in Kapilands. These formulas will provide the profit-maximizing price. Of course, this assumes that you can change your ratio of breweries to taverns as needed…which is easier said than done. It also assumes you have a good transfer price on beer going from breweries to taverns, which can get rather complex to calculate.
However, your real question seems to be how to quality-adjust the sales price based on Q…and whether there are rules of thumb that are simpler than running Knoll’s formula over and over. Yes there are, but the answer changes from product to product.
For beer, the quality adjustment is 5 per Q. In your example, stats are 319.24 ¢τ with an average quality of 17.85. If you sold Q20 beer at 329.99, the system would see that as being “at average stats”. The math is 319.24 + (20-17.85)*5. For Q10 beer, the “average” price would be 279.99.
How do I know that the quality adjustment is 5 for beer?? Well, a combination of experience and a real easy test.
Step 1: Put some beer near average Q in a tavern at around the stats average price.
Step 2: Check out how long it will take until it all sells.
Step 3: Now put the same amount of beer in your tavern at 1 Q higher.
Step 4: Adjust the pricing on this beer until the “time till it all sells” is the same as the first batch.
Step 5: Check out the difference in pricing between batch 2 and batch 1. That difference is the quality adjustment.
Here is the results of a test I just ran. I don’t have any Q18 beer, so this is the closest I could get.
Sample #1: 10000 beer, Q25, pricing 380. Time to sell out showed as 9 hrs 16 min 5 sec
Sample #2: 10000 beer, Q26, pricing 385.20. Time to sell out showed as 9 hrs 16 min 3 sec
Difference between the two was 5.20.
So, where should I actually price my beer??
If you run Knoll’s formula a bunch of times, it mostly ends up that the optimal sales price is a bit north of the average stats price. This is definitely not true of all products and all times, but seems to be at least 2/3 of the time.
Also, if you run Knoll’s formula a bunch you will find that the “lost profit” for not selling exactly on optimal price is not particularly large until you move 20-25% away from “optimal”.
So, a simple rule of thumb is to sell products on a quality-adjusted basis at 15% above average stats price. That way you will usually be close to optimum profit, and you will not be dragging down the average stats.
Now, if you have a fixed amount of brewery and tavern space, then I agree with the other posters that the answer is simple....price the beer in taverns so that you don't run out
First off, Knoll’s threads are legendary. His analysis of market pricing is great, and the math works exactly the same in Kapi Regnum as it does in Kapilands. He has several other threads on the Kaplilands forums that cover other topics, and they are great as well. I have been using the formulas he shows since I first started in Kapilands. These formulas will provide the profit-maximizing price. Of course, this assumes that you can change your ratio of breweries to taverns as needed…which is easier said than done. It also assumes you have a good transfer price on beer going from breweries to taverns, which can get rather complex to calculate.
However, your real question seems to be how to quality-adjust the sales price based on Q…and whether there are rules of thumb that are simpler than running Knoll’s formula over and over. Yes there are, but the answer changes from product to product.
For beer, the quality adjustment is 5 per Q. In your example, stats are 319.24 ¢τ with an average quality of 17.85. If you sold Q20 beer at 329.99, the system would see that as being “at average stats”. The math is 319.24 + (20-17.85)*5. For Q10 beer, the “average” price would be 279.99.
How do I know that the quality adjustment is 5 for beer?? Well, a combination of experience and a real easy test.
Step 1: Put some beer near average Q in a tavern at around the stats average price.
Step 2: Check out how long it will take until it all sells.
Step 3: Now put the same amount of beer in your tavern at 1 Q higher.
Step 4: Adjust the pricing on this beer until the “time till it all sells” is the same as the first batch.
Step 5: Check out the difference in pricing between batch 2 and batch 1. That difference is the quality adjustment.
Here is the results of a test I just ran. I don’t have any Q18 beer, so this is the closest I could get.
Sample #1: 10000 beer, Q25, pricing 380. Time to sell out showed as 9 hrs 16 min 5 sec
Sample #2: 10000 beer, Q26, pricing 385.20. Time to sell out showed as 9 hrs 16 min 3 sec
Difference between the two was 5.20.
So, where should I actually price my beer??
If you run Knoll’s formula a bunch of times, it mostly ends up that the optimal sales price is a bit north of the average stats price. This is definitely not true of all products and all times, but seems to be at least 2/3 of the time.
Also, if you run Knoll’s formula a bunch you will find that the “lost profit” for not selling exactly on optimal price is not particularly large until you move 20-25% away from “optimal”.
So, a simple rule of thumb is to sell products on a quality-adjusted basis at 15% above average stats price. That way you will usually be close to optimum profit, and you will not be dragging down the average stats.
Now, if you have a fixed amount of brewery and tavern space, then I agree with the other posters that the answer is simple....price the beer in taverns so that you don't run out
