Upgrade water and farm products?

Here is enough space for all you players to ask questions about the game

Moderator: moderators

Guest

Post by Guest »

I don't know if wells are all that bad. In early game they definitely saved my ass as I was always short on cash. And now I find my wells convinient too. When I'm short on cash I can always produce water for next to nothing, and when I have plenty of cash I buy water and upgrade my wells to increase allod.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I have two criticisms of this argument. First is that it essentially argues that one should only produce the highest priced goods. As such one should produce beer, and the notion of producing grain (or beets or herbs) for market is just as "poisonous". Beer costs something like four times as much to make as grain, but sells for three times as much, making the rate of return something over three times higher.

Second, grain is not a water-intensive crop. Beets uses nearly three times as much, and wood is the real consumer of water.

If you propose that the only non-poisonous way to play the game is to build beer (and maybe dried meat) then fine, make an argument for maximizing profit.

However, you start with a well. So the question is, given the conditions at the start of the game, what do you do with it? My answer is to keep it. Keep it until you need the building space. I don't think its the best thing to buy more wells, or to necessarily even expand your well (unless the resources of expansion would otherwise sit idle), but I certainly do think you should keep the well you started with.

I gave conditions under which I think wells make sense
  • you have the slots available
I also have mentioned the conditions under which I think well expansion makes sense
  • the materials would otherwise sit idle
You may find these conditions never apply to you.

But the decision to maintain a well for some period of time, or even to upgrade a well is hardly the only sub-optimal choice one can make. One can produce grain, beets, or herbs; fruit; furniture; any textiles, particularly other than drapery; you can build or expand lodges of research; pursue non-monetary goals, like reputation.

Consider for example the heavy investment in technology for a sub-optimal product, such as raiments? Where is the return on investment there? Certainly less than a third of the value of a grain farm.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Just do digress a bit...For your info, railments turn in a very high profit. Same goes for other textiles products such as clothes, shoes, drapery, nets and even carpets. I have been into every one of these businesses at one time, so i know.

The good thing about it is that you don't even have to have a high level of research to acquire decent profits.


Also you mentioned about other 'sub-optimal' products such as beets, herbs, furniture... clearly you haven't gotten far enough to realise the prospects they hold.


Now back to what you'd say about returns... you never calculate them based on how many folds return you get based on the amount you put in. Rather, calculate them based on the raw profits they bring you.

Using my research levels as an example
Beer for example, costs about 90cT to produce, and i sell them at 230cT (Q20) to other players. Hence making a profit of 140cT each.

Iron costs 180cT to make, sells at 420cT; profit = 240cT each

Grain costs 1.8cT, (sells to myself at 65cT); profit = 63.2cT each

The production speed of these 3 items are the same,
Profit:cost ratios -
Beer ~ 1.56
Iron ~ 1.33
Grain ~ 35.1

High profit to cost ratio doesn't mean a thing.

Water profits: 0.24-0.02 = 0.22cT each

Now to bring water production into comparison... we need to fix production duration and equal number of employees, lets take 1 hour in a 4000sqm building (with my rank)

Beer profit per hour : 140 * 1264.16 = 177000cT
Iron profit per hour : 240 * 1264.16 = 303400cT
Grain profit per hour : 63.2 * 1264.16 = 79900cT
Water profit per hour : 0.22 * 50526.32 = 11100cT

Sure it may cost nothing to produce, but it also brings in nothing.

One would argue that beginners wouldn't have as high a research and bring down the profits to Q0 products

Q0 beer sells for 120cT, Q0 iron sells for 145cT, Q0 grain sells for 45cT
Water? Always Q0...

To produce lower Q products, cost is reduced somewhat

Beer profit per hour : 55 * 1264.16 = 69500cT
Iron profit per hour : 45 * 1264.16 = 56900cT
Grain profit per hour : 43.2 * 1264.16 = 56400cT
Water profit per hour : 0.22 * 50526.32 = 11100cT

Still at least a 4:1 profit ratio of any of the products above compared to water.



Now... lets talk about heavy investments into research buildings. True, most beginners wouldn't have the capital to invest into them... but sometime later when they have like 5-10million cash lying around from the huge profits they're making earlier on, it acts in 2 ways.

First off, a research lodge is a real estate investment, it appreciates as size increases and as time goes on.

Next, it increases the value of products you produce. Quite obviously, the higher the quality of your goods are, the more people will pay for it. Some people even have a linear equation for goods pricing and if you can find a good buyer you'll make more over time as your quality increases. The same goes for selling your products in market stalls, you earn more for higher quality stuffs, period.

The reason I'm posting this is to help beginners learn how to make a bigger profit and to clear doubts about the uselessness of a well, it is indeed the worst way you can dump money away. ANY single product can bring in more profit IF you use the right strategy, fruits, weaponry and jewellery included.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Well I did have 3 wells when I started playing because I felt it was hard to get money to buy the water I needed for my goods in the beginning. But later on, my wells simply couldnt keep up with my water requirements. Also I needed those 3 slots for more profitable buildings.

At that point, I sold them off, and simply buy water now.

So I kinda agree with both sides of the discussion here. It is not a big issue if you build wells when you have slots free, but oftentimes it is hard to meet your water requirements from your own wells unless they are really huge or you have a lot of them.
Guest

Post by Guest »

1) Raiments. Drapery, clothes, and raiments produce the same revenue per unit time of production at the same level of customer satisfaction. However raiments require expensive silk and produce no additional income in the Draper stall. Sold seperatly they yield more than they do together.

The player market rewards raiments more favorable than the stalls, but because it also does so with silk, its still more profitable to sell them seperatly.

2) Ratios. Once again you have misused figures in an attempt to deceive. I proposed that a more expensive item, beer, has a better return on its costs than grain. When both price and return are both increasing, you have a better product. Showing that objects with a lower price and a high rate of return are not a better product is an entirely different set of conditions. To pretend that one stands in for the other is trickery. I am not deceived.

3) Reasearch lodges. The point I made, which you failed to address is that the return on investment is extremely poor. Far worse than water. Water pays for itself in two weeks (roughly 14 days). The amount of time it takes for increases in lodges to pay themselves back in terms of increased demand or increases in price is significantly longer. Especially within the window I mentioned (before you've used 60 spaces). Wells get more allod too.

4) The purpose of the well is not to bring profit. One does not sell water. The purpose of a well is to avoid the costs of buying water. Early in the game when players are cash poor, say the first several weeks in the game, producing water is very sensible. Telling new players that water is never desirable is simply false. It is highly desirable during the early part of the game. I suggest as late as having any slots open, but precisely when to discard wells is not the question at hand, it is the error that wells are never desirable.
Guest

Post by Guest »

kgauck, i don't understand what you're trying to get at, nor am i going to try. I will leave things at that, read again what I have to say before passing any judgement.

Cheers!

And good luck to all you newcomers! Have a fun time!
Guest

Post by Guest »

A few observations:

Beginning money strategy: A beginners survival is dependant on how fast they make cash to bring them into contention of being competitive in some category. Wells are a terrible idea that way. Even Lumberjacks will make a lot more! And selling wood/grain/beets gets you good trading partners who may be able to advise you/tie your economy to theirs and take you for a piggyback ride... almost.

LODGES: If you think that lodges are poor investment... well... :lo:... they are priceless.. a little undervalued on the market right now, but with each promotion, you can only keep expanding your city at the same number of max sqms per hour. The way to increase ur returns is to have an ever increasing level of research... I have reassigned previously workshop stalls to extra lodges to keep my research growing.. If I were to let my research slide, then with the decreasing productivity of my workshops with each level, I would have to keep raising the price of goods and decrease my sales/hour. That is a terrible way to go. You definitely can't grow production so fast. Lodges are priceless. start building straight after ur initial cash raising.

Building suggestions for BEGINNERS: Lumberjacks, Farms, Cattle Farms (if u can stay away from cattle farms, its good, b'coz u can pick up cheap big ranches in a bit when u have the cash.... much faster than building them)

Try building a brewery and a few taverns as soon as you see clear cash apart from working capital... if u choose beer, that is :) Some make wool, milk, honey, fish etc..
Guest

Post by Guest »

Personally I think lodeges are great too, but I am optimizer, not a maximizer.

A maximizer seeks the greatest rate of growth now, and while early growth can be impressive, the shape of the curve is somewhat more linear.

An optimizer seeks the best utilization of resources now, and much early growth is not so apparent because much investment is made in things that only pay off much later, like research.

I was responding to the presented argument against wells, which is an extreme version of the maximizer argument (wells never), while my own position is that wells are good in the early game and become less advantageous later on. However, for the same reason that wells are bad - there are better choices for growth - applies to lodges for quite some time.

As a team approach, having maximizers work with optimizers is very nice. The maximizers tend to have more resources in the early game, and the optimizers more in the late game.

Its a mistake to think either approach is wrong, let alone "poison".
Guest

Post by Guest »

the difference between lodges and wells is that while lodges are slow growth in the beginning but really show their value later,..

Wells are money losers right in the beginning and continue to get worse.

Lodges are like a great red.. Its a bit terrible right now, but it is gonna get really really good with age.

Wells in my opinion are like bad beer.. its terrible now,.. its gonna get worse.. and it never gets any better :!:

I'm a bigtime optimiser myself.. I've bn building over and over my capacity, zeroing out cash and pumping all the money into bigger buildings.. in fact, I delayed going premium by a few months despite having the coins b'coz I wanted to be able to start premium play with max efficiency, so I got my city to be making a months premium cost in a day b4 I went premium and sustained it for a while that way :) Thing is, a blanket might make u warm at night, but what abt when u have to get up and goto work.. u can't drag the blanket along.. u have to cut it up and sew urself clothes (*$#%#$%) so, wy not start from proper clothes and have some optimised comfort!
Post Reply