Master of Research Certificate

Here is enough space for all you players to ask questions about the game

Moderator: moderators

Guest

Post by Guest »

btw, how did the q1 stone (marble) make it past the quality control checkers?? I'm assuming it was not the intention of the programmers to give out a cert for something that can't be researched!

btw, wrdoff, what size be your research facilities? (I'm finally getting mine to a 1,000 sqm :? )
Guest

Post by Guest »

The original quality for Stone was Quality 0, taken by the System.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Therian wrote:The original quality for Stone was Quality 0, taken by the System.
But the marble is considered q1, which is sold by the system and which cannot be researched. So in essence you're giving a cert to Odessa (name appears on the listings, I figure I don't need to bleep it out) who (I assume) thought they'd check to see just what kind of loopholes there might be in the coding. But since we cannot research marble it makes it impossible for anyone else to compete for that certificate. I just don't think a cert should have been given to anybody for something like that...
Guest

Post by Guest »

From what I can gather it was actually a bug when the system was implemented then. In some ways it could be considered bug-abuse, but then it shouldn't have occurred originally.

With the release of Marble (Q1 Stone) the System should have automatically been 'given' Q1 Stone on those listings, but instead as it wasn't updated it was given Q0 instead, thus opening that loophole for someone to submit Quality 1 Stone.

On the German Servers Q1 Stone was taken by the System at the time of the feature been implemented.

I'll leave a note about it, but I can't say what will happen - though chances are the name may just be changed to 'System'.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I have to agree with wrdoff,.. the research certificates put a good amount of emphasis on playing it smart.

And, it is always a good idea to research at least one product to be at the top. Though, you have to understand that not everyone gets to be at the top. The number of players is much much greater than the number of products.

Besides, there are other, much faster and surer ways of getting reputation points (spl building quests).

So, quit whining ppl,.. this is the middle ages, its not supposed to be a democracy. think abt it, Wars keep the population honest, but since the wars ended b4 you all start a city here, there is going to be a lot of scheming, politics, dishonesty, corruption and opportunism.

What we really need here is BATTLES to solve issues.. probably a scenario where cities/guilds pit strength of arms against each other backed by their economies, and a system generated super quest decides the winners. Then you take ur spoils....

I'd just loooooooove that!
Guest

Post by Guest »

JohnWick wrote:The more I think about it, the less I like this. The way it works out, the top quality people got a huge point windfall when this started by repeatedly bumping up the quality certificates. It's pretty much impossible for a new player, or even a successful several-month old player like me, to catch the likes of Wyrdoff or St-Germain on quality, but the effect of this is that even if by some miracle of dealing/playing I *did* manage to catch them I can never, ever, ever, get anything like the points they got because of the exponential increase in quality improvement costs. There were probably as many quality score points handed out in the last week as there will be in the next 2 years.

Worse, the scoring is in many cases fairly arbitrary because it's who had the highest quality *this* week, and in many cases what mattered is who logged on first and snatched the certificate. If you were a high-Q player on a long cycle who didn't log on until Tuesday, tough cookies, you've lost out, pretty much for all time. This is particularly true for products where the quality didn't have any in-game use and so players had medium Qs by accident or for yucks.

I suppose you can say this is sour grapes from a late-starter, but it is frustrating to see 2 of the few roads for a late-starter to make the leaderboards (reputation and high Q in obscure products) closed down by this massive and fairly arbitrary point handout which isn't even particularly fair amongst the players who get to participate.
Agreed.

The number of reputation points gained by the "winners" on day 1 from windfall through the Royal Quality Institute was 2x-10x the total amount of points that they had earned in the entire game up to that time.

I do not fault these people for identifying and quickly taking advantage of the situation...I would have done the same thing had I logged on at the right time instead of 20 hours later. However, I question the thinking of game management as this does not seem healthy for the game. How much will people value a gold medal when they know people got 5x that many points by being the lucky person to bump beer Q from 9 to 23 on the first day? In general, this windfall event has greatly depreciated the value of any other point-generating activity.

To be clear, my specific concern is around the day 1 windfall. On an on-going basis, if people choose to research obscure products in order to grab more certificates, then more power to them.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I fully agree with JohnWick and Cash is Kingdom on this topic.

I think, It should be a case maybe that you get x points and a certificate for having the best Q in a product, if someone gets better that you, then you loose the points and the certificate, which goes to the player that now has the highest Q for that product.


It totaly degrades the contests and the reputation poins I have worked hard to aquire.

I for one will not be going for gold, silver or bronze in the next contest. as there is now not much point in it.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Cash is Kingdom:

To be clear, my specific concern is around the day 1 windfall. On an on-going basis, if people choose to research obscure products in order to grab more certificates, then more power to them.
That is a sad sad thing that happened.. I guess the initial "system" qualities needed to be a bit higher than they were to avoid the initial amassing of certificates. Also, though I think that the certificates have the right reputation points (100), the number of first day certificates is the problem. And this is definitely going to affect the next contest. However, a medal is still a medal and is quite priceless.

It takes me about a week + some creative trading to get the next quality of my goods out to get a research certificate. And that costs a fair bit as well. Compare this to the fact that you can get 25-30 reputation points by sending in around 25-30 million thalers worth of products. So, 100 points for researches that take a ~week each + costly raw material imports + cost of those researches ~1.5-2 million each is quite right. Because in the same time, you can fulfil 4-5 quests at a special building.

Also, think about how much players are charging for the 'time' component of buildings when they sell them.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Well, frankly, the special buildings are a big problem too. Constant point cost (actually decreasing due to more points/sq. mt. with larger buildings) in a game with exponential growth is a big no-no. They're worthless at the start and overwhelming at the end. But, that is at least known - anybody who's studied the game or even watched Kapilands realm 1 knows the endgame is about maxed-out deliveries. In any case, it's no reason to put *another* overwhelming source of points in; one which kicks in much earlier, or to put it in in a way that hands out the points pretty arbitrarily and in a way that nobody could have planned for.

Contest medals will still be reasonably valuable, since people were paying far more than their point worth. Maybe the *concentration* of points counted for something to and that will be reduced as well. But contest *certificates* are highly degraded. Now, to advance from the basic 480 points to the point leaderboard takes about 50 contest certificates, or placing every time for 4 years straight! Hard to get excited about that.
Guest

Post by Guest »

only thing that I gotta say abt this is ur going to feel a little different abt this once yo ustart sinking money into spl buildings to raise your allod. Then it becomes more of a convenience to do quests.

Btw, a great discussion is underway at the BoF forum to find a better solution to the Research certificate problem. We'll be posting something up here sometime soon :D
Guest

Post by Guest »

Then it becomes more of a convenience to do quests.

You sure you don't mean INconvenience? :lol: Delivering large matched quantities of single-quality lots of 8 to 16 different products, often unprofitable and lightly traded (bought any books lately?), from multiple lines of business is cost-effective, alright. But I think better descriptions are challenging, frustrating (like when you fill out a lot with the wrong quality :x ), or downright tedious, depending. I sure wouldn't call it convenient! :P

The cost-effectiveness of multiple special building quests does devalue the contests somewhat. But the solution is to reduce the cost-effectiveness of multiple quests, not to introduce a *new* way to pick up thousands of points in a fairly cheesy way.

BTW, the point distribution for quality certificates has exactly the opposite problem from deliveries. Deliveries are worthless until late in the game and then suddenly become far and away the best way to get points. Quality certificates (as currently done) are a really cheap way to get points early, and become harder and harder as the game progresses and the exponential cost of quality sets in. New quality certificates *should* be really hard to get by now; we're just seeing some strange effects as a mid/late game introduction handed out months of the early points in a short period (most in a few hours). IMO any major source of in-game points should be relatively constant over the life of the game, like the way contests work out. I'd also like to see them tuned so that medals are at least a major source of points. The net result of quality certificates + deliveries with current rules is that contests are swamped as point sources throughout the game and that's not right. :?
Guest

Post by Guest »

Depends how you look at it. I just concentrate on one building and try to max out my low quality stock of all 8 products... Of course, its hard to get all 4 in good levels to just do it. I am always short of books and benches. But the rest works just fine.

See, with the contests, the one thing that really does irritate me is how players are able to just sell coins for cash and raise extreme amounts to win medals. As a case in point, I had been stockpiling CASH for months - more than half a million + industry in full swing providing 50 million + a day + buildings selling at the right time. And still, I didn't have a chance with the medals because basically cash rich (read coin/euro rich) dudes just jumped me. Where is the equity of that???

Now, if people are getting points for investing in quality over looooooooooong periods of time, it is then really unfair for ppl to be upset abt it. Wait, I did say that the first day was an extremely disgraceful show, I got a few as well but the vast majority of my certs are well gotten. So, plz don't *rant* abt the inequity of research certs without acknowledging what shams the contests have become.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I don't think anybody has trouble with the idea that high quality merits reputation. A lot of us do think that the total points for leading a product in quality (over 1,000 for some products) is far too high in comparison to points for donations and competition. We all seem to agree that the way it started wasn't right.

Real money can buy almost anything in this game. You can buy high Q research and lodges as well. IMO that's not really a problem; it's the donators who keep the game going after all. You can do pretty well for nothing more than the cost of a premium account, which is pretty minimal. There are overall strategies you can take (single industry concentration, producing somewhat in excess of optimum for monetary growth) which can let you compete in the contests without extra money. You should have known that 500 million wasn't enough to compete for a medal, though.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I was only saying that quality certs are not the worst thing compared to what happens... I did buy a few coins when my city was young, just to support the game, then when the game grew bigger I decided to buy them off other players to 'help' support the game. And No one can disagree that the amt of reputation got in the first day was obscene...

Just brings to mind a thot that I had when the game had started off... I used to think that reputation points were for how well you do things in your city.. your level of research, building sizes.. making rare goods etc. Things that would actually make your town famous in real life.

But then I found out that they were nothing more than stupid status symbols. Well, the quality certs do bring some reality to the game (imbalance you may call it). Implementation can be a lot better, but I support the idea.

btw, I didn't try to win a medal with 500 million... I spent much more than 1 billion... I had meticulously prepared reserves of everything to last the entire contest, so my markets were selling beer even though I wasn't making any at that time. All farms to honey. All herbs bought. A lot of cash raising... Only thing that I did NOT do was sell coins. I just don't see that being in the spirit of fairplay, thats all.. my two cents on it.

What I like with quality certs is,
a) None is going to sell you the top researches if they can themselves get certs. That makes the best research really expensive.

b) Apart from cash, it takes a loooot of time to make good research and products, careful management of upgrades and building of really good trade ties with other cities. That helps in contests too, but the contest is too much of a free for all for my liking.
Post Reply