Selling iron and coal through contracts

Here is enough space for all players to ask questions about the game.

Moderator: moderators

Guest

Selling iron and coal through contracts

Post by Guest »

Hi :)

I'm at my first attempt on kapilands and after having read through forums and analysed spreadsheets I have decided to produce power and iron ore in the short term to finance the supply chain of steel production (I will add coal, minerals and chemicals later).

I know that steel can be controversial or even a poor choice but from what I have read it seems a quite open way to aim at a good medium term return without being locked to a specific industry for the rest of the game.

Anyway, my questions are:
- Would I be able to sell q0 iron ore, q0 coal and power through contracts in small amounts?
- If so, what would be a reasonable price range?

Thanks ;)
Guest

Re: Selling iron and coal through contracts

Post by Guest »

bamse wrote: Anyway, my questions are:
- Would I be able to sell q0 iron ore, q0 coal and power through contracts in small amounts?
- If so, what would be a reasonable price range?
That depends on which realm you are playing. If you are playing realm 1, you can sell power small contracts but finding a buyer for iron and coal would be very hard. If you are playing realm 2, you can easily find buyers for small power and it would be still rather hard to find a buyer for Q0 iron and coal.
Guest

Re: Selling iron and coal through contracts

Post by Guest »

bamse wrote:Hi :)

I'm at my first attempt on kapilands and after having read through forums and analysed spreadsheets I have decided to produce power and iron ore in the short term to finance the supply chain of steel production (I will add coal, minerals and chemicals later).

I know that steel can be controversial or even a poor choice but from what I have read it seems a quite open way to aim at a good medium term return without being locked to a specific industry for the rest of the game.

Anyway, my questions are:
- Would I be able to sell q0 iron ore, q0 coal and power through contracts in small amounts?
- If so, what would be a reasonable price range?

Thanks ;)
Well, for me I am looking for iron ore Q21+, coal Q21+, chemicals Q30+ and steel q24+, for lower qualities only steel Q0 for expansions and prices lower than 135,00 each
Guest

Post by Guest »

R2.

I think I will just build up the infrastructure by producing and selling stone which should be very easy to sell even in small amounts. This should allow me to build up enough mines before having the size and infrastructure needed to build steel. I will only use iron ore and coal for my internal supply chain.

Thanks for the answers :)
Guest

Post by Guest »

Good choice on the stones there you have done your research :)

And good idea for the moving onto steel. Not that it's a great product, but that you are willing to have fun with the game and make it more challenging :) I used to make Q0 steel and I liked it, so good luck to you and hope to see you later on in the game :)
Guest

Post by Guest »

bamse wrote:R2.

I think I will just build up the infrastructure by producing and selling stone which should be very easy to sell even in small amounts. This should allow me to build up enough mines before having the size and infrastructure needed to build steel. I will only use iron ore and coal for my internal supply chain.

Thanks for the answers :)
Indeed, start producing stones.

And after reading your posts i still advise you to stay out of steel production.


Stones is definatly a great business without research and you could get the sci to produce high quality steel while making a profit producing stones.
But when you write you want to do steel cuz you could change later on i must warn you that it actually isn't easy to change from steel to anything else.

For steel you need several things.
1: Iron Ore (can only be used for steel production)
2: Coal (can only be used for steel production)
3: Chemicals
4: Power
5: Factory


1 and 2 obviously can only be used for steel production, there just isn't anything else you can do with them.

3 can be used for other things, but people who claim to have done the math say it isn't good business.
It however can be used to produce things in chemical plants, but from R1 i know that isn't great business either.

4 is always needed.

5 is needed for steel, but can also produce other products.
People however say gas is a better business.


So how about building mines for stone production and factories to produce gas.
Then when you find out how everything works you can always change to steel if you really want to.
But at the start with the current resource value on the market producing steel Q0 just is a waste of time.


I advise you to ignore people who want to get you to produce Q0 steel for them.
Just ask yourself a very simple question, why don't they produce it themself when its such a great business????
When someone is spending 5 coins to post a fax to tell people to produce steel i guess something is fishy :P
Guest

Post by Guest »

Ronintje wrote:
Just ask yourself a very simple question, why don't they produce it themself when its such a great business????
When someone is spending 5 coins to post a fax to tell people to produce steel i guess something is fishy
:lol: :lol: :lol:
Absolutely right! 8)
Guest

Post by Guest »

Fortunately what I read here makes sense to me, which might mean that I start having a clue of how things work (from a very very high level point of view) :)

Yes, stones is way more profitable than steel and I will stick to that for quite a long time at least until I'll have gained enough confidence to move to something else, however my idea was to rather use steel (not q0) as a starting point for (much) more profitable businesses. I can see wardrobe as one of the most popular right now and even if less popular the automotive industry seems to have a highest ROI and an amazing payback period due to the fast production (this would be a long term objective of course).

Please correct me if I see it wrong, but quality steel seems to me a versatile but still profitable way of making money. Probably gas or even sticking to stones might be more profitable, at least in the short medium term, but I think I would find very boring producing only one product.

Anyway, I'm just at the beginning so more than happy to take advice. As I said I will stick to stones for while, so plenty of time to talk about theory :D

Thanks everyone ;)
Guest

Post by Guest »

I do believe that most things can be profitable, though the reason people say it's not, is that you need to make a lot of it yourself, and also, most people think in value rather than production cost, which excludes many things, but keeping above production, and it will make a profit
Guest

Post by Guest »

You can make a profit out of anything in this game. Just the size of the profit and if it would make more money selling the things needed seperatley, deters many people and makes one product better than another

eg: steel

5 coal 50
2 iron 20
0.5 chems 10
200 power 54 (realm 1)

So thats if you sold all the products... Thats 134 plus the cost to make steel... so you couldn't make a profit......................................

Though if you made all the products yourself eg the power

5 coal 50
2 iron 20
0.5 chems 10
200 power 2( if made in green)

So in total thats 82 caps(plus price to make the steel)- bigger profit you may say, so you have made a much bigger profit than if you bought all the products yourself :D

Only problem is you could of sold all of the products for a greater price. That is why steel isn't a great industry
Guest

Post by Guest »

agent00skid wrote:I do believe that most things can be profitable, though the reason people say it's not, is that you need to make a lot of it yourself, and also, most people think in value rather than production cost, which excludes many things, but keeping above production, and it will make a profit

Please don't tell me you are one of those guys who claim they make a profit cuz you produced all resourses yourself and therefor didn't need to pay the market value.....

If so, PLEASE DON'T SPOIL NEW PLAYERS WITH YOUR RETARDED IDEA's!!!!!!!!!
Guest

Post by Guest »

felixbluindustries wrote:You can make a profit out of anything in this game. Just the size of the profit and if it would make more money selling the things needed seperatley, deters many people and makes one product better than another

eg: steel

5 coal 50
2 iron 20
0.5 chems 10
200 power 54 (realm 1)

So thats if you sold all the products... Thats 134 plus the cost to make steel... so you couldn't make a profit......................................

Though if you made all the products yourself eg the power

5 coal 50
2 iron 20
0.5 chems 10
200 power 2( if made in green)

So in total thats 82 caps(plus price to make the steel)- bigger profit you may say, so you have made a much bigger profit than if you bought all the products yourself :D

Only problem is you could of sold all of the products for a greater price. That is why steel isn't a great industry
In R1 usually the price of coal and iron ore tends towards 15 rather then 10.
Tho sometimes you can buy at 10 each making it a cheap batch, still most of the time you couldn't.
I wouldn't be able to run a business shutting down the factory 50% of the year cuz resourses are to expensive.


Other then that, you clearly showed why Q0 steel isn't much good. :)
Guest

Post by Guest »

bamse wrote:Fortunately what I read here makes sense to me, which might mean that I start having a clue of how things work (from a very very high level point of view) :)

Yes, stones is way more profitable than steel and I will stick to that for quite a long time at least until I'll have gained enough confidence to move to something else, however my idea was to rather use steel (not q0) as a starting point for (much) more profitable businesses. I can see wardrobe as one of the most popular right now and even if less popular the automotive industry seems to have a highest ROI and an amazing payback period due to the fast production (this would be a long term objective of course).

Please correct me if I see it wrong, but quality steel seems to me a versatile but still profitable way of making money. Probably gas or even sticking to stones might be more profitable, at least in the short medium term, but I think I would find very boring producing only one product.

Anyway, I'm just at the beginning so more than happy to take advice. As I said I will stick to stones for while, so plenty of time to talk about theory :D

Thanks everyone ;)
Ofcourse high Q steel is something that enables you to make a decent profit.
But you would need a real high quality, say Q20.
Then you would need a buyer to send contracts, otherwise you would lose a lot of cash, or you would need them yourself.

From your initial post i got the point you intended to start producing steel and then quit at some point later on.
Tho you intended to get high quality, you must understand you can't start with high quality and therefor start with Q0.

At Q0 its almost impossible to make a profit at all, regarding the usual recent resourse valur, which makes it somewhat impossible to get to the point of making a profit at all.
Also i didn't get the point you wanted to start producing steel to later start using it yourself.
That still makes it difficult due to the not/hardly making any profit at the point you need the profit real bad....that is the start...

Regarding that info i consider steel to be a wrong business to start producing.
First get some decent production, like you already wrote it could be done with stone production for which you also need the mines that can be used for coal/ironore production later on.
That makes it a great option.


Then when you got the cash you just build some RC and start researching the items you need.
Once you researched a level that enables a profit you shift production to steel production.


I guess that is the only way to reach a healthy steel production business.


And please, please, please, PLEASE.....ignore the people that tell you to not use the market value when you want to check if you can make a profit on a certain product.!!!!
I really want to ask you to PLEASE ignore those guys who want to make you believe BS like that.
When you produce your own water in your own well to produce Q0 seeds tyou can easily produce them seeds below 0,10 each, but had you not produced the seeds you could have sold the water needed to produce the seeds at exactly the same price as you would sell the seeds......

I know people love to write they can make a profit using their production cost rather then the market value of a product.......
IGNORE THEM!!!!!!!!!!

^^
That is the best advise i can give anybody, tho it very often is impossible to make people understand such basic knowledge and people always try showing their stupidity in this forum by telling new guys to use production cost instead of market value!!!!!
Guest

Post by Guest »

omg have you been drinking? that sure was an angry post 8)
Guest

Post by Guest »

Well... I am almost scared to say it now..... you are right about the marketvalue being the base of calculating your profit, ...
BUT: lately I have been reading a couple of posts and I have been thinking about it, and felix is also right when he states (in short) that yes marketvalue is important, but you CAN make a profit as long as your price is more then the productioncost, (although it can be considerably less profit) depending how much above the productioncost you price your product.

Second thing about marketvalue is ofcourse that some people think in terms of: "if you had to buy (the power for example) from the market you had to pay whatever the price on the market is", so that would be the value of your power,
and other people (like me) say: "you can sell it on the market for (blablabla..whatever marketprice)", so that is the value of your power.
There is a difference between the two:first case is simple, you would have to buy it for marketprice (0,15 for power), so thats the value of your power.

in the last case (you could have sold it for..) you don't actually get the marketprice for your product, you get 10% less, (marketfee) so the marketprice minus 10% will be the real value of your product, not the marketprice itself.
That can make a huge difference: powervalue would not be 0,15, but 0,13.
Still I prefer the last case since it is more realistic: you actually wont buy the power from the market because you just produced it yourself, but you CAN SELL it on the market.
So second reasoning makes more sense to me.

Another thing, when you calculate profit with marketprice being the basic variable in your calculations, you exclude a lot of products that according to marketprice suddenly are not profitable anymore, while in fact they are, only not compared to marketprice.

My point is, yes, it is sensible to look at the marketprice and keep that as a value for your products, but if you stick to it very rigidly and you are not a little flexible about it sometimes, then you cheat yourself out of a lot of products and basically all you got left are the boring wardrobes gas and leather jackets.
Ok ,maybe I am wrong, don't bite my head off :shock: but thats how I feel lately.
Hope you understand my explanation in English. :roll:
Soooo....what do you guys (and girls) think..comments please.
(but be gentle ..) :shock: :shock: :shock: :shock: :wink:
Post Reply