Is this competitive or cooperative game environment?

Here is enough space for all players to ask questions about the game.

Moderator: moderators

Post Reply
martinng

Is this competitive or cooperative game environment?

Post by martinng »

hi all. i am new here. and i am really enjoy the game. it is fun!

i have read the forum and learn how to play well from the experienced players. most of them maximizes their profit by buying from other players and selling to NPC, and advise me not to produce the goods myself in most cases. and also it is not allowed to sell with abnormal price (extremely low/high) or will be accused in cheating.

so, i have some questions to ask:

- why we cant sell extremly low/high price in the game? because it is one of the strategy to force opponents retreat from the market. of coz we must have huge enough capital to do this. i am pretty sure everyone in this world who doing business first they want to make money and second they hope to monopolize the market if they can. (at least bill gates ;) )

- will opponent price affect my sales? like in real world, if your opponents sell big enough amount of same goods with you and same quality, and cheaper than you even 1 caps, you will definately lose all of your market. and you wont have even 1 unit sold until your opponent sold out their goods in the case demand still remain. this make sense because will you buy from the higher if both shops got same product and same quality? but you will if the lower shop sold out and you still need it.

So, conclusion: this game is play in cooperative style more than competitive style. this is just my oppinion, please correct me if i am wrong, thanks in advanced .


regards,
Martin

p/s:
it is more fun to play in fully competitive in open market. player can "attack" other players with pricing or quality or brand. those who weak can form/join alliance to against other alliance ;)
Guest

Post by Guest »

well the low/ high price issue is to stop people having two accounts at once
Guest

Post by Guest »

what thebig companys are telling you is to buy a brodct (lets say gas) and to sell it at a store. (for gas, a gas station) and i am 99% sure that if company A sell gas for 5caps cheaper that it will not affect your market. understand?
Guest

Post by Guest »

I would disagree. You will always sell out your goods, but how long it takes to clear the stock varies on your price and quality. You can drop your price those 5 caps and sell out your stock hours sooner, though of course, at less profit per unit.

The higher your quality and the lower your price, the faster you sell goods and you can move larger volumes. I don't believe this effect is as pronounced as it is in the real world, but it does exist in the game.
As in the real world, the trick is to set your price at the maximum benefit level to sell faster, but at a good price. This is trial and error as far as I have seen.
The best strategy seems to be to increase the size of your store or gas station or whatever so you can sell large amounts. Thus, even if it takes you longer to clear the stock, you have sold much more in that time.
A 20 M2 gas station, stocking 1000 gas will sell out in exactly the same amount of time as a 300 m2 station stocking 15000, all other things being equal.
This is why you will see people doing quality research as fast as they can afford. Quality has a major effect on your sales if you get too far behind the average.
As to competitive or cooperative, as in the real world, if you and your suppliers have no competition in end sales, it's cooperative. If you are, at the end, putting the same goods on the market it is entirely competitive.
martinng

Post by martinng »

I would disagree. You will always sell out your goods, but how long it takes to clear the stock varies on your price and quality. You can drop your price those 5 caps and sell out your stock hours sooner, though of course, at less profit per unit.

The higher your quality and the lower your price, the faster you sell goods and you can move larger volumes. I don't believe this effect is as pronounced as it is in the real world, but it does exist in the game.
As in the real world, the trick is to set your price at the maximum benefit level to sell faster, but at a good price. This is trial and error as far as I have seen.

Recimer
Ricimer, thanks for your detailed explanation. I totally agree what you said,but I think you still miss out something what I actually mean.
In theory, you will always sell out the goods but just the time matters, this is absolutely correct. But what I actually asked is :

If company A and B sell the same product/quality/quantity, if B sell lower price than A, will this affect the A selling time?
What is market type in this game? Monopolistic Competition or Perfect Competition?
Guest

Post by Guest »

company B will affect company comapny A but as demand and supply for most products have not been met then it wont affec tit that mcuh but if for example in realm 1 CMB were to get all 100 of his fully expanded furniture stores and say tehy were all in turkey and he sold 30k wardrobes from each buildign a day but for a high Q and a cheap price eg 2000casp each for Q20

then if you sell for a higher price and a lower Quality yes you will be affected but its rather odd for that to happen as this game tends to be people selling at the same or similar prices :)
Guest

Post by Guest »

Ah...yes. I assumed that answer was implied by what I said. Indeed, if somebody else is selling higher quality at a lower price (or one of those two) it will affect your sell time. I often put goods up at the same price range and see the sellout time is hours longer. Then I will look at the stats page and see the average quality of the good has jumped from, say, 12 to 16 in the region, or the average sell price has dropped.
There is no question that other peoples prices and quality affect other peoples sellout times.

The effect is, I feel, more significant than Felix (above post) thinks it is. I can double my sellout time if i don't keep my quality climbing and my prices moderated and that can cut my income in half for the same amount of time. Of course the income is possibly more important to me as I am building my Empire ;) without benefit of income from coins. I just use those to buy premium status, not get more game money. (this is a fatal flaw in this game they need to remove. If people can spend real money to win, it's not a game at all and people will soon see that and lose interest. what do you really have to brag and feel proud about if all you did was spend 50 euros to put yourself ahead?)

I'm not sure what you mean by 'monopolistic' and 'perfect' competition, but I can assure you there are people playing in such a manner as to try to 'corner the market'. The limit on computer demand does make it possible.

One last thing though, unlike the real world, in the game, once you put goods on market at a certain price, your sellout time seems to be fixed and remains the same, despite what other people do during the sell time. Thus if you put up 10000 goods with a sellout time of 12 hours, and somebody else after you puts up 100000 goods of higher quality and cheaper, your 10000 will still sell in 12. When you go to renew your stores stock of goods is when you will feel the effect.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Hello there,

I dont know if this is interesting for you or not...

Look here:

http://kapilands-realm1.blogspot.com/20 ... -best.html

Best regards
Marxer


For me it was important to find the max profit...
martinng

Post by martinng »

Thanks for the replies.

The more I have read from the forum, the more I have found that, the game is not follow the Supply and Demand Law at all.

Look at this for the example:
http://www.forum.kapilands.com/viewtopi ... 7270#67270

Coffee 38 million demand and only 1 supply, the price should rises to roof but only 11 caps. If you ask, what is the upper limit for the price to rise. It should rise until the consumers dont want to wait and switch to other replacement, then the demands should drop dramastically and so is the price. Of course only programmers will know that upper limits.

If I sell Coffee immediately with 11 caps, I should get a very significant decreasing in selling time, but according to that forum link, it was 15 hours!!! Insane...

The game is fun even it didnt follow SnD law. But let me tell you guys something, most players (including you maybe) who join this game at first: want to have a fun in big success in one field/sector. So in the early game, proper production line, calculating maximum profit and contracting with other players.
But once we have grown big. Trust me, we will start thinking to "fight" or "take over" other big guys market. That is the real fun of business simulation game.
Farmboy always said "Marxer" is a biggest car dealer in this game. You know, I even have a plan to take over 30% car market from him, but I know that is impossible because the game not allow me to do that :(
I will lose the fun in late game.
Because no matter how quality/quantity/price i input into the market, Marxer still play his own "maximum profit / mininum selling time" without reflected by me at all. No fun.

Just think like that: If Travian dont allow "War", everyone just build their own farm, trading resouces among others, will it still hit big success like now?

Anyway, after few days playing, I decide to quit kapiland. So there is no point to keep argueing this topic. Perhaps you guys should try to play other games.
Bye, and thanks for your time.


regards
Martin
Guest

Post by Guest »

i feel the game falls into 2 categories.

trade to npc (system) and trade to other players.

with trade to NPC thru stores demand doesn't seem to be an issue until demand is exceeded. examples of this are posts by leather jacket producers who see the price crash when the supply does exceed supply. players affect the price in how the choose to sell their goods, but as long as they are at least matching the aveage price (regardless of quality) those who sell above market ave should be able to push up the price. i see this area falling into a co-operative approach as companies aren't needing to compete with each other for the NPC kapi population to buy their goods.

trade with players however can be highly competitive. supply and demand play a strong role and can greatly affrect the price. some goods have low demand and it can be hard to sell excess stock. quartz on r2 is a good example. it should sell for a similar price to coal, iron and minerals but the prices are (quartz about 2.5 caps, coal about 10 caps, iron about 9.5 caps and minerals about 8.5 caps - at the time of this post). the latter items have a higher demand thus the higher price. changes in supply and demand regulate the price up or down sometimes significantly. and external factors can change this dynamic for short periods of time (such as contests). as you rely on someone buying the goods placed on market if a large supply is entered below your price (for the same quality) then you may need to wait a while for your goods to sell ... but as long as the supply isn't too large (or your price too high) then your goods should sell eventually (especially if it is a extremely high demand item such as power, water, wood, stone or steel).
Guest

Post by Guest »

Hey martinng I love ya post, and i agree with you 100%. If i underprice my goods in the shops everyone should buy off me right? therefore other players have to adjust there price accordingly. From how i understand it this game has a virtual market contolled with supply and demand based on a population of people and the supply required, as the supply fills (showed by a percentage in the shops) the time to sell products increase
(better Q = less time). In hope to clarify what i think you are saying ;what you would like to see in this game is where the supplly and demand is based on a real time situation, with real time players (not Virtual) and supply and demand is calculated as close to instantly as possible. This would make the market of sales truly based on real people and not virtual. I can see a program like this being a major success but would require alot more programing and support. Also on your coin topic, i agree, how can someone have braging rights if they spent real money to buy themself to the top?. I admit i have bought coiis to start my bussiness and have a chance to compete though. Pleanty of things could change this game and make it better, personally for the price I pay for a premium account i Really enjoy this game and know i get what i pay for.


Canistane
realm 1 DPI
realm 2 FUTECH
Post Reply