Stocks

Here is enough space for all players to ask questions about the game.

Moderator: moderators

Guest

Damn

Post by Guest »

DragoonZ50 wrote:To add towards the idea, you start off with 49% stock in your warehouse (maybe only from lvl manager or entrepreneur), which you can sell according to the value of your fixed assets. 1% stock will sell for about 1% of your fixed assets. The higher your fixed assets, the more you can sell it for. Each stock is tracked back to your fixed assets and gives the person who has the stock (whether it's you or someone else) a daily salary-like ammount of caps to his inventory (something small, maybe like 0,0001)

This means that when a company with 100 mio fixed assets decides to sell its stock, most of it will be sold for 1 mio per stock, giving him a total sale of about 49 mio. Now the person who sold the stock doesn't have to do anything, just use the new-earned money. The stock holders receive 10k daily for each stock they have (remember it cost them 1 mill each). If the company who sold the stocks expands to, lets say, 120 mio each, the stock holders will make more money and not have to pay anything extra, they already have the stocks.

Now, if the companies starts selling their buildings, the stock holders will make less money. It has its risks, like the real market.

Just an idea to point out.
What you are suggesting is great but it guess you must know how to program this bit and hook it up on the net for a game with so many users.

And as far stocks goes, it must for a browser based capitalistic game.
And Stocks and capitalists have avery strong and old bonding
Guest

Post by Guest »

I always like hearing these ideas. Unfortunately, they always run into the same problems.
DragoonZ50 wrote:Each stock is tracked back to your fixed assets and gives the person who has the stock (whether it's you or someone else) a daily salary-like ammount of caps to his inventory (something small, maybe like 0,0001)

The stock holders receive 10k daily for each stock they have (remember it cost them 1 mill each). If the company who sold the stocks expands to, lets say, 120 mio each, the stock holders will make more money and not have to pay anything extra, they already have the stocks.

Now, if the companies starts selling their buildings, the stock holders will make less money. It has its risks, like the real market.
Where does this money come from, the selling company? Can they ever force a buyback? What happens if they don't have the cash on hand? Do you put them into negative cash, and thereby screw them out of being able to send contracts, or sell on the market, or load stores, or start production?

Those sound like a preferred stock, which is something, but still not quite what comes to mind for a stock market. Common stock doesn't have a guaranteed dividend, and it's certainly not fixed to assets.

More than that, here are the problems you get with every player-issued stock suggestion:

1. Player A buys company B stock. Player B then stops playing / gets locked for cheating / takes a nosedive. Player A is screwed, with nothing they can do. (Except complain. They can always complain. Loudly. To me.)

2. Player A buys company B stock. Player A then resets. Where'd the stock go?

You also end up with a catch-22. If you allow players to set their own price on stock trades, you open up even more cheating shenanigans. If you don't allow players to set their own trades, then it's not like a stock market at all - you may want to bid more on Majestic stock because you like the management, but you can't.

Also, 0,0001 is a lousy return. Anyone who actually cares about profit is going to decide that this is a lousy payment that isn't worth it.

It seems like a lot of work and a bunch of new problems just to put in a new system that also won't get used.

I share your desire for a more interactive stock market. But it would need to be done right.
Guest

Post by Guest »

By the way, have you read this thread?

http://www.forum.kapilands.com/viewtopic.php?t=11371

Same goal, similar methods. Same old same old grumpy negativity from me. :evil: But I think I was a little more thorough in the answer there.
Guest

Post by Guest »

that sounds like it is working then. what level can you get stocks?
Guest

Post by Guest »

manager
Guest

Post by Guest »

good az
Post Reply