And maybe I'm being too picky here
Building costs duplicated on finance page
Moderator: moderators
-
Guest
Building costs duplicated on finance page
I'm too new in the game to know if this is a bug, but after I spent $640k on a well, a factory, and a gas station, my finance sheet shows expenses of $1.28m for "New build." Worse, the amount carries down to the profit and loss section.
And maybe I'm being too picky here
, but strictly speaking, the purchase of capital assets is not even an expense! 
And maybe I'm being too picky here
-
Guest
-
Guest
-
Guest
Re: Building costs duplicated on finance page
It's always an expense, I think you mixed up expenses and costs, purchase of building is not a cost since it's an euh...active? (we call it activa in Belgium...). But it is always an expense because you have to pay money for it, the table shows your cash flow not your actual profitBobbyBall wrote:
And maybe I'm being too picky here, but strictly speaking, the purchase of capital assets is not even an expense!
-
Guest
Probably just a terminology difference orval. I won't blame you since you guys make good waffles. 
By American accounting standards the classification is Expense vs Investment. An expense, like salaries, is money that's gone and adds no lingering value to the business. An investment, like a building or some machinery, makes the company more valuable. (Although over time it depreciates, contributing an expense deduction each year.)
In Kapilands, they do correctly add to the Fixed Assets each time you purchase or expand. And they do break out "new build" or "extension" from other expenses. The only real difference is the way it's summed, and a player could easily adjust for that I think.
By American accounting standards the classification is Expense vs Investment. An expense, like salaries, is money that's gone and adds no lingering value to the business. An investment, like a building or some machinery, makes the company more valuable. (Although over time it depreciates, contributing an expense deduction each year.)
In Kapilands, they do correctly add to the Fixed Assets each time you purchase or expand. And they do break out "new build" or "extension" from other expenses. The only real difference is the way it's summed, and a player could easily adjust for that I think.
-
Guest
I c, intresting, I thought there was a difference between expenses and costs, if you take a dictionary, look it up and translate into Dutch (uitgaven) you assume that expenses are flows of money outside the company, so it would only affect cash flow while costs are not, we use costs (kosten) for amortizations and salaries etc.
But I think that buildings never represent any costs in kapilands since they do not go down in value, so no amortizations... which means no costs... or no expenses?
But I think that buildings never represent any costs in kapilands since they do not go down in value, so no amortizations... which means no costs... or no expenses?
-
Guest
Thanks for the responses, folks! 
I still don't see why building purchases are counted at 2x their value on the finance page. 2x?
Knolls -- Yes, I guess I'll have to use Excel, which I already do in other games [of this type] that I play. I often wonder why game developers don't capitalize on the need for better management tools, and offer them for sale. Because they don't, game players wind up creating their own and even distributing them to other players.
edit: Sorry, guys, I don't really play that many other games of this type. To clarify, I play some war games in which I use spreadsheets. I play one other game where you buy and sell things on a Lagoon, but it's not as serious as this game.
orval -- I'm not by profession an accountant, but I doubt accounting is fundamentally different between Europe and the US. It's probably just a language and terminology issue.
Here we have Assets - Liabilities = Equity. Assets are the things we own, like cash in the bank and buildings. Liabilities are our debts, and Equity is the value of the business. Separately, we have Revenue - Expenses = Income. You must have the same equations but obviously use different words.
When we buy a building, we are moving value from one asset account to another, so it does not count as an expense. Salaries, however, are expenses, as would be any consumable item that we purchased (paper, stamps, printer ink, etc).
When you say "cost," I think of Cost of Goods, which consists of the things we buy or pay for to build and sell our goods: raw materials, production salaries, advertising, etc. but not taxes and interest we pay on debt. So, all costs are expenses but not all expenses are costs.
I still don't see why building purchases are counted at 2x their value on the finance page. 2x?
Knolls -- Yes, I guess I'll have to use Excel, which I already do in other games [of this type] that I play. I often wonder why game developers don't capitalize on the need for better management tools, and offer them for sale. Because they don't, game players wind up creating their own and even distributing them to other players.
edit: Sorry, guys, I don't really play that many other games of this type. To clarify, I play some war games in which I use spreadsheets. I play one other game where you buy and sell things on a Lagoon, but it's not as serious as this game.
orval -- I'm not by profession an accountant, but I doubt accounting is fundamentally different between Europe and the US. It's probably just a language and terminology issue.
Here we have Assets - Liabilities = Equity. Assets are the things we own, like cash in the bank and buildings. Liabilities are our debts, and Equity is the value of the business. Separately, we have Revenue - Expenses = Income. You must have the same equations but obviously use different words.
When we buy a building, we are moving value from one asset account to another, so it does not count as an expense. Salaries, however, are expenses, as would be any consumable item that we purchased (paper, stamps, printer ink, etc).
When you say "cost," I think of Cost of Goods, which consists of the things we buy or pay for to build and sell our goods: raw materials, production salaries, advertising, etc. but not taxes and interest we pay on debt. So, all costs are expenses but not all expenses are costs.
Last edited by Guest on 19.05.2007, 18:35, edited 1 time in total.
-
Guest
yup I understand it now, same thing in Europe, I was just confused by the terms srryWhen you say "cost," I think of Cost of Goods, which consists of the things we buy or pay for to build and sell our goods: raw materials, production salaries, advertising, etc. but not taxes and interest we pay on debt. So, all costs are expenses but not all expenses are costs.
