If your mines are disgustingly large and you have a problem with a lot of stock, it might be better to sell the materials, but otherwise, steel is the better choice.Dwarf wrote:And you even earn more with the "ingredients" then with steel itself. Steel is the badest branch of all...
How much does it cost to make 1 unit of steel?
Moderator: moderators
-
Guest
-
Guest
yep, at the current market prices of raw materials the process of steel producing is as the edge of value destroying.
At least my plants stoped to produce steel this week and my freed excess production capacity of the mines earn the usual profit of the mine-factory by its own
But with coal/iron below 8 steel production is fine business (payback periods of expansions of 16-18 days). Just during these 2 weeks there are beter alternative utilization of production capacity.
At least my plants stoped to produce steel this week and my freed excess production capacity of the mines earn the usual profit of the mine-factory by its own
But with coal/iron below 8 steel production is fine business (payback periods of expansions of 16-18 days). Just during these 2 weeks there are beter alternative utilization of production capacity.
-
Guest
Actually, his other buildings do earn money if he's selling the steel above what the breakeven point is if he were buying everything.Antalun wrote:But in that case your mines, wells and power plants do not earn anything. How many buildings of yours need to work the same time to produce all to make 1 steel?
- power plant
- more than one mine, I would say that at least 2 or 3 to get all needed coal, iron and minerals
- well
So lets count that it is 4 buildings plus factory, that is 5. So one poor factory has to make profit that you need to share with other 4 buildings, and that wouldn't be so much. So don't try to trick people that on quality 0 steel you earn much.
To look at this with a slightly simpler product that requires only two inputs, let's say I produce coal.
Let's say I produce 10,000 units at 1 kapidollar per unit if i buy off market at 6. Let's say i sell on contract at 8. This is a profit of 7 per unit.
Now, if I make a powerplant in green. I can make power at .01 per unit. This lowers my costs to .50 kapidollars, resulting in a profit of 7.5 per unit.
I could just as easily sell the power with a profit of .05 per unit, or .50 per 10 units, which is needed for coal.
The misconception arises because people look at the other products in the game that are selling for less than what they go for when buying the materials off the market.
-
Guest
-
Guest
You aren't using all the materials though. Seems a little weighted to say you make more from the ingredients when you include the left-overs. More than that, selling the materials takes away the option of making steel; whereas you can make more selling the excess iron ore and chemicals since you'd only be limited by coal,(or, the size of your factory in the case of the numbers you presented) if you produced steel.
And it doesn't factor in the price jump quality steel can make, compared to the materials that go into it.
steel is not really profitable and you earn more money with the ingredients
Maybe not as profitable for you, but it does bring in a pretty penny.
Guess that's just the wording though.
And it doesn't factor in the price jump quality steel can make, compared to the materials that go into it.
steel is not really profitable and you earn more money with the ingredients
Maybe not as profitable for you, but it does bring in a pretty penny.
-
Guest
Steel Profits
Profit in this game has to be judged based on:
1. ROI of the building (Return On Investment)
and
2. Oppurtunity Costs (Indirect Costs and Benefits)
ROI is most simply measured as cost of building / daily profit of building = days to return cost. Obviously, a yellow mine costs more then a red factory. The question is not which makes more profit - it is which makes more profit for the cost.
Oppurtunity Costs are less precise. Some benefits that can be seen for making steel are; you don't have to buy it off the market to expand, you are almost certian to be able to sell it on contract at close to market price, the market price is fairly unlikely to change, and by owning the other buildings that supply your factories you can insulate yourself some from market shifts and save the "costs" of buying goods off the market (where prices will reflect commission).
On the other hand, you only have so many building slots available. Calculating the value of each slot including expansion issues like expansion and location is not easy. I think everyone has to come up with there own system for that - and I'm not even near out of slots so I haven't worried too much.
Just for reference, 1 yellow mine produces almost exactly enough goods to push production from 1 red factory. Some minerals must be converted to chemicals - if this is calculated as part of the factory's function in a day, about 25 steel less is made a day. The whole process uses about 1/2 of a red power plant, and 1/10 of a yellow well. That means that a chain uses about 2.6 buildings.
Here are the daily ins and outs at merchant (yeah, that means the same ratios apply regardless of level, just less output on the chain)
103,940 power (power plant)
21,400 water (well)
400 steel (factory)
200 chemicals
2000 coal (mine)
800 ore
200 minerals
If this chain is evaluated as a unit for ROI purposes, you get a fairly different result then as individual buildings. Lets use CC's costs of 20.92 per unit of steel (I get the same for that matter) and assume you can sell on contract for 130 (todays faxes offer better but I like round numbers).
The daily profit looks like;
(130-20.92) * 400 - (contract fees, lets ignore that) = 43,632 a day
The unit building costs are;
1 Red Factory 120,000
1 Yellow Mine 240,000
1/2 Red Power Plant 71,000
1/10 Yellow Mine 24,000
--------------------------------------
total costs 455,000
455,000 / 43,632 = about 10.43 ROI for the unit at Merchant
The math on the water and power is rounded a little. Employee costs are left out. You can correct that and argue about it if you want. If you want to gauge profit for steel vs. pure mining, go do the ROI's for mines. Keep in mind that steel prices are stable vs. mine products which shift a lot more.
I will tell you, just as a clue in case you can't do math, that few things have better ROI's or more stability then steel units.
Honestly, if someone knows anything much more profitable let me know - I am bored with steel.
1. ROI of the building (Return On Investment)
and
2. Oppurtunity Costs (Indirect Costs and Benefits)
ROI is most simply measured as cost of building / daily profit of building = days to return cost. Obviously, a yellow mine costs more then a red factory. The question is not which makes more profit - it is which makes more profit for the cost.
Oppurtunity Costs are less precise. Some benefits that can be seen for making steel are; you don't have to buy it off the market to expand, you are almost certian to be able to sell it on contract at close to market price, the market price is fairly unlikely to change, and by owning the other buildings that supply your factories you can insulate yourself some from market shifts and save the "costs" of buying goods off the market (where prices will reflect commission).
On the other hand, you only have so many building slots available. Calculating the value of each slot including expansion issues like expansion and location is not easy. I think everyone has to come up with there own system for that - and I'm not even near out of slots so I haven't worried too much.
Just for reference, 1 yellow mine produces almost exactly enough goods to push production from 1 red factory. Some minerals must be converted to chemicals - if this is calculated as part of the factory's function in a day, about 25 steel less is made a day. The whole process uses about 1/2 of a red power plant, and 1/10 of a yellow well. That means that a chain uses about 2.6 buildings.
Here are the daily ins and outs at merchant (yeah, that means the same ratios apply regardless of level, just less output on the chain)
103,940 power (power plant)
21,400 water (well)
400 steel (factory)
200 chemicals
2000 coal (mine)
800 ore
200 minerals
If this chain is evaluated as a unit for ROI purposes, you get a fairly different result then as individual buildings. Lets use CC's costs of 20.92 per unit of steel (I get the same for that matter) and assume you can sell on contract for 130 (todays faxes offer better but I like round numbers).
The daily profit looks like;
(130-20.92) * 400 - (contract fees, lets ignore that) = 43,632 a day
The unit building costs are;
1 Red Factory 120,000
1 Yellow Mine 240,000
1/2 Red Power Plant 71,000
1/10 Yellow Mine 24,000
--------------------------------------
total costs 455,000
455,000 / 43,632 = about 10.43 ROI for the unit at Merchant
The math on the water and power is rounded a little. Employee costs are left out. You can correct that and argue about it if you want. If you want to gauge profit for steel vs. pure mining, go do the ROI's for mines. Keep in mind that steel prices are stable vs. mine products which shift a lot more.
I will tell you, just as a clue in case you can't do math, that few things have better ROI's or more stability then steel units.
Honestly, if someone knows anything much more profitable let me know - I am bored with steel.
-
Guest
I like your work Capitalis. Very well approached and laid out.
Just a thought to nag at you because it changes things a little bit
:
Consider the value of steel and what the relative ROIs are of different products after you've expanded every building to 100 m2.
Especially as your level moves up and it starts to cost 75 steel / foot to expand (Uppermarket Businessman). In other words:
When doing initial building a yellow mine costs 240,000
Just a thought to nag at you because it changes things a little bit
Consider the value of steel and what the relative ROIs are of different products after you've expanded every building to 100 m2.
Especially as your level moves up and it starts to cost 75 steel / foot to expand (Uppermarket Businessman). In other words:
When doing initial building a yellow mine costs 240,000
-
Guest
Your calculation of ROI ignores the cost of raw materials needed for construction of the buildings and the cost of employing the second employees in your plants. But it will change the whole picture only a bit. The truth is that the power-mine-steel complex is one of the most profitable businesses in terms of ROI and given the stable price of steel and no need to invest in reasearch an almost risk-free one.
But where the actual value in this production chain is created depends on the market price of the raw materials. So if you examine it at the current prices of iron and coal you will find that almost all value is craeted at the mine level and almost none at the factory level. So the optimal utlization (in tems of ROI) of the production capacity in the 2 weeks of chem contest was selling the raw materials on the market or in contracts (e.g. I supplied stones on contarcts) and producing chemicals only (which were very profitable of course, but also required less raw materials)
And finally: If you ask me about something more profitable in terms of ROI than your steel production line (in normal conditions) - I know only better: this is steel production line line with steel factories in green, supporting chemical facories in red and power plants in green.
. Green is better in the case of steel factory even if you calculate the ROI on expansions capex)
But where the actual value in this production chain is created depends on the market price of the raw materials. So if you examine it at the current prices of iron and coal you will find that almost all value is craeted at the mine level and almost none at the factory level. So the optimal utlization (in tems of ROI) of the production capacity in the 2 weeks of chem contest was selling the raw materials on the market or in contracts (e.g. I supplied stones on contarcts) and producing chemicals only (which were very profitable of course, but also required less raw materials)
And finally: If you ask me about something more profitable in terms of ROI than your steel production line (in normal conditions) - I know only better: this is steel production line line with steel factories in green, supporting chemical facories in red and power plants in green.
-
Guest
@Knolls - Thanks. I think thats math I can save for when I get there, but I do see your point. There are real differences between early growth and longterm - still, this forum says its for beginner questions. Oddly, lots of experienced players seem to post the most discussing issues from a late game prespective. Maybe there should be a forum catagory for that, but it seem late game players seem to horde that knowledge and only let it out when they respond to other players responses to newbie questions 
@Elder - Agreed. The math was a quickie really - mainly to establish the general ROI. Doing math for current conditions/contests becomes to much like guesswork for my taste and experience. Still, you are correct that AV (Actual Value) is something that gets ignored frequently. In this case, pure mining ROI for 20m2 buildings sold at current market prices is almost the same (with market comission I think it comes to slightly "less" - higher ROI that is). Past that, the contest/chemical issue only comes in play if you have the research capacity to make the q1, which changes the math again.
I think the general answer I can give to both of you as to the larger value of steel vs. pure mining is the oppurtunity costs/benefits;
1. You will either use it or sell it on contract close to market prices, forever, which is something a pure production "unit" will not do.
2. It is stable and low risk.
3. By having a fairly diverse "unit" in place you have the oppurtunity to refocus more easily for contests etc...
In the end, the origional question of the thread got answered, and then some. I almost think there needs to be a newbie guide that covers concepts, like ROI, AV, expansion costs, and such, since it seems like most of these posts end up going there anyway. Maybe it should be titled "feel free to undersell your intial steel and fail to make profits off fruit, but afterwards you might read this and reset".
- Capi
@Elder - Agreed. The math was a quickie really - mainly to establish the general ROI. Doing math for current conditions/contests becomes to much like guesswork for my taste and experience. Still, you are correct that AV (Actual Value) is something that gets ignored frequently. In this case, pure mining ROI for 20m2 buildings sold at current market prices is almost the same (with market comission I think it comes to slightly "less" - higher ROI that is). Past that, the contest/chemical issue only comes in play if you have the research capacity to make the q1, which changes the math again.
I think the general answer I can give to both of you as to the larger value of steel vs. pure mining is the oppurtunity costs/benefits;
1. You will either use it or sell it on contract close to market prices, forever, which is something a pure production "unit" will not do.
2. It is stable and low risk.
3. By having a fairly diverse "unit" in place you have the oppurtunity to refocus more easily for contests etc...
In the end, the origional question of the thread got answered, and then some. I almost think there needs to be a newbie guide that covers concepts, like ROI, AV, expansion costs, and such, since it seems like most of these posts end up going there anyway. Maybe it should be titled "feel free to undersell your intial steel and fail to make profits off fruit, but afterwards you might read this and reset".
- Capi
-
Guest
I agree. I especially like the ROI concept. I've been looking for something like that to evaluate different chains. I think I would still like to look at the profit/time after you've paid for your buildings though. So you invest a certain amount of money in some buildings for a particular product chain. Then it takes you a certain amount of time to recover your startup costs. Then how much profit per unit time do you make with the result. I realize, if you keep expanding the buildings for the same product line, this probably doesn't really matter, but it is helpful to know how much profit this arm of your business is bringing in if you move on to work on other areas or develop your research.
I agree that a lot of things change with player level. Once you take into account number of building slots, then you have to ask yourself, if I fill up all my slots for this production, what is my ROI and profit per time. Then for future consideration, you might ask yourself, when all my buildings are 100qm what does my profit / time look like. I only suggest this, because untill you get to manager level, it is very expensive to change your buildings. And I've learned from experience that you can fill up 100 building slots and get many of them to near 100qm before you actually make it to manager and can momre freely convert to another business.
I agree that a lot of things change with player level. Once you take into account number of building slots, then you have to ask yourself, if I fill up all my slots for this production, what is my ROI and profit per time. Then for future consideration, you might ask yourself, when all my buildings are 100qm what does my profit / time look like. I only suggest this, because untill you get to manager level, it is very expensive to change your buildings. And I've learned from experience that you can fill up 100 building slots and get many of them to near 100qm before you actually make it to manager and can momre freely convert to another business.
-
Guest
Even on older buildings, ROI is still a good way to compare the relative worths of buildings/products. Profit per day is one of the two primary factors in ROI, and fairly easy to pull out.
ROI for expanded buildings is a little more math, but in the end not much harder.
ROI for research .... is much more speculative.
If you take this game and apply math to it you still end up with speculation. To me, that is what makes it interesting. Market trends and events are the parts that math has a hard time pinning down.
ROI for expanded buildings is a little more math, but in the end not much harder.
ROI for research .... is much more speculative.
If you take this game and apply math to it you still end up with speculation. To me, that is what makes it interesting. Market trends and events are the parts that math has a hard time pinning down.
-
Guest
-
Guest
Here's a funny piece of math.
Our math is based on a single 20m2 red factory on merchant.
Materials are priced at 10 coal, 10 iron, 16 chem, and .06 power.
Sale price is 132 on contract.
ROI looks like 9.62.
If you add the cost of the materials used each day (this assumes a 24 hr production run with all materials up front) as a "facility cost", ROI is 12.
Just something to think on.
- Capi
Our math is based on a single 20m2 red factory on merchant.
Materials are priced at 10 coal, 10 iron, 16 chem, and .06 power.
Sale price is 132 on contract.
ROI looks like 9.62.
If you add the cost of the materials used each day (this assumes a 24 hr production run with all materials up front) as a "facility cost", ROI is 12.
Just something to think on.
- Capi
-
Guest
It's worse than that, isn't it?
Net
Coal: 50
Iron: 20
Chem: 8
Power: 12
Manuf Cost: 15
-----------------------
Total: 105
132 - 105 = 17
Total / day from one red factory @ Merchant = 534
534 * 17 = 9078
200,000 (Red factory) / 9078 = 22 days
Which is what a lot of us have said from the beginning (albeit not so much lately) - Steel isn't where the money is. Mining is where the money is.
In fact the magic number is 13.40 an average on Coal / Iron. Above that price it's not worth making steel at all. Of course that would beg the question of who's buying it ...
Net
Coal: 50
Iron: 20
Chem: 8
Power: 12
Manuf Cost: 15
-----------------------
Total: 105
132 - 105 = 17
Total / day from one red factory @ Merchant = 534
534 * 17 = 9078
200,000 (Red factory) / 9078 = 22 days
Which is what a lot of us have said from the beginning (albeit not so much lately) - Steel isn't where the money is. Mining is where the money is.
In fact the magic number is 13.40 an average on Coal / Iron. Above that price it's not worth making steel at all. Of course that would beg the question of who's buying it ...
