Page 1 of 1
Make the game more like real life
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2007 3:54 pm
by Guest
In a lot of ways this game is real to life but one thing that doesn't make any sense is that when you upgrade your buildings you lose efficiency. That's just not right except where your buildings get to a certain size.
At the least you should publish this better so that people know that there is something about the game that doesn't make sense in the real world.
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2007 4:00 pm
by Guest
I guess, its not all that unreal.... bigger stores, managers more thinly spread out, less control, lazier employees, more smoke breaks.
But I guess, there should be a general efficiency research building when you get to a certain rank. (manager training / staff incentives in real life)
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2007 4:33 pm
by Guest
pk wrote:I guess, its not all that unreal.... bigger stores, managers more thinly spread out, less control, lazier employees, more smoke breaks.
Yes, that is why all the stores with 2 employees are so successful these days. And the very large stores can hardly stay in business. May I suggest a book, The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith.
But I guess, there should be a general efficiency research building when you get to a certain rank. (manager training / staff incentives in real life)
Why would you have to research efficiency?
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2007 4:52 pm
by Guest
A comment to the "real life" part
Duncan wrote:pk wrote:I guess, its not all that unreal.... bigger stores, managers more thinly spread out, less control, lazier employees, more smoke breaks.
Yes, that is why all the stores with 2 employees are so successful these days. And the very large stores can hardly stay in business. May I suggest a book, The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith.
Well, you know why some internet retailers can sell products up to 70% below the advertised value by the producers? (If you dont know them Woot, IBOOD are just 2 examples, there are lots more who work on the 1 product day or some on a "club" basis.)
Because they work way more efficient than bigger companys.
Big companys = Huge (work cost?) but many products to spread them onto. But also a big profit on a low profit margin due to the waste anmount of products sold.
Medium companys = Medium (work cost?) but less products to spread them onto so the price has to be quite equal to the one of a big company, but they probably make less profit per sale.
Small companys = Barely any (work cost?) if its managed right, but very few products to spread it onto, the biggest chunk added here is usualy the profit, which is still not that big because of the low anmount of products sold.
Duncan wrote:
pk wrote:
But I guess, there should be a general efficiency research building when you get to a certain rank. (manager training / staff incentives in real life)
Why would you have to research efficiency?
You know how much money goes into research and obviously the training part of employees to increase efficiency?
And also refering to another post of you.
You dont lose any efficienty in your sales buildings, just take 2 same stores of diffrent sizes and put an anmount in equal to the size(i.e. 400 units in a 200 sqm store and 200 units in a 100sqm store ), and with the same quality/price of course, you will see the sale time will be 100% same.
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2007 5:41 pm
by Guest
These are not internet companies. This is suppose to be the Middle Ages. Please read Adam Smith, specifically his analysis of the pin factory.
Posted: Thu Dec 20, 2007 9:36 pm
by Guest
Hmmm.. I think I was wrong about the markets loosing efficiency. I tested a 2m building with the same advertising. The optimal price must have dropped for another reason. I'll test it at different sized also.
Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2007 1:32 am
by Guest
hmnn... I'll have to read that sometime.
But I really do stand by "bigger stores are less productive", in real life.
You see, everybody tends to care a little less. They can cut prices because even smaller margins can create big profits at high volumes, and end of the day, what they look at is the balance sheet, profit per share. And, more often than not Big companies borrow money to invest in production and the increased profits/share value goes to the same number of shareholders.
While in real terms, they have just cut out others who produce smaller volumes (often without debt). The whole cycle, these ppl are replaced in the consumer queue with the ppl with the wall street cheque and their own employees and it goes on and on.
But point taken : Read the Wealth of Nations.
And regarding efficiency research,... well, going up through ranks, our selling rates decrease, but a bigger store should be able to invest in better training facilities.. blah blah.. n so on.
Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2007 5:35 am
by Guest
pk wrote:hmnn... I'll have to read that sometime.
Just look it up in Wikipedia or something. I would say it might help you with this game, but unfortunately that's not necessarily true.
Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2007 12:42 pm
by Guest
I think it would cause a server-overload if this game had to be exactly lke real life. There are so many different theories that plays out in different aspects of the real world.
Two theories that i keep thinking of, when i read discussions like this one, and they actualy tell us two completely opposite things.
1: The law of diminishing returns.
This theory says that as you keep adding to a production-facility the marginal product will at some point begin to decrease, at one point the marginal product will be zero, and then go below zero.
the marginal product is the extra production you gain from adding one production-factor (labor, machines or something like that)
2: The theory of size benefits.
In shorter terms this tells us that large factories are more likely to benefit from added workers or new machines than smaller factories.
And there are many many more theories like those ones.
And now that we are suggesting books: "managerial economics in a global economy" by Dominic Salvatore.

Posted: Fri Dec 21, 2007 4:14 pm
by Guest
Warming wrote:
And there are many many more theories like those ones.
Well those are not really theories, especially the laws.
But good show.

Posted: Sat Dec 22, 2007 10:23 pm
by Guest
yeah, well, i kind of knew they werent theories, but im learning about them in danish, and i couldn't realy find a better word

Posted: Sun Dec 23, 2007 2:03 am
by Guest
I'm sure bud. That's for whomever,s benefits who needs it.
Posted: Wed Jan 02, 2008 9:14 am
by Guest
Well, the Law of Diminishing Returns is a law and you have it pretty much right on. As you add more units of production (i.e., workers), you initially have a great boost in production return. As you continue up the slope of the bell curve, the steepness of the slope decreases and each additional unit of production offers less and less return until finally you hit the peak of the slope where additional units of production return a zero increase in output. As you head down the slope on the right hand side of the bell curve you start to lose production as units of labor are added.
And the English name for your number 2, Warming, is Economies of Scale. It follows along much the same path as the Law of Diminishing Returns wherein you increase your overall size of operations until the costs of each piece of output is minimized. For example, the cost to make 10 items will be higher
per item than if you make 1,000 items. Of course, the overall cost to produce the 1,000 items will be higher than if you only produced 10, but that's how the real world usually works.
The trick is to figure out what all the costs are and to do regression studies. However, that's a bit too much work for me to put into a game, heh.

Scalling
Posted: Wed Jan 02, 2008 12:12 pm
by Guest
in real life, when you work in a large factory, the cost to mack 10 unit is might be higher then 1000.
let's say that you mack 10 units of something in 1 hour, and each unit cost to produce is X(includeing rew matireal,work force and other things). each hour of work you pay your workers Y
the next 12 hours(let's say 12 hours but in real life it can be diffrent).
the next 11 the factory won't mack a thing and therefor it cost you money like 10X + 11Y. but if you mack 1200 units then you pay 1200X. but the diffrence is in the cost per 1 unit. if you mack 10 units you pay 1X+1.1Y per unit. but if you mack 1200 units you pay X only, so you pay less per unit but more in genraly.
but if you mack profit of 2X(100% profit) then in 10 you mack less money or even losing!