Page 1 of 2

Information about product value

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 4:02 pm
by Guest
Hi.

There have been enough threads where people are complaining about the fact that others are selling their products too cheap. I just want to inform about something, without complaining, because I don´t sell the product. It´s about boats this time.

What is the value of boats?

To answer that question, we need to know the value of the products used for boats: wood, pitch and tools. For wood and tools and water (for pitch) I take the cheapest market offer and substract the 10% market fee:
wood: 24 - 10% = 21.6
tools: 12 -10% = 10.8
water: 0.24 - 0% = 0.216 (let´s say 0.22, I buy water for that price)
pitch: 5 wood (108) + 2 water (.44) + prod cost (10) = 118.44 cT

Now the boats:

boats: 4 wood (86.4) + 1 pitch (118.44) + 2 tools (21.6) + prod cost (20) = 246.44 cT

So the value of q0 boats is at least 246.44. Even if you would buy the pitch for 100 (people are selling below value) the value of boats would still be 226 cT.

This calculation is once again only one example out of many, where people are selling wares below market price.

All I wanted to say is: Think twice before selling your wares for a price that is too cheap.

Greets.

Elwood

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 4:28 pm
by Guest
Even though i have discussed this topic a few times allready, i never get sick of agreeing with the phrase "dont sell too cheap!"

I produce and sell about 1200 silk every day (aprox. 2800 is sold in total), and even though i sell for about 100 cT over stat-price, it keeps dropping. This means that some1 is selling for a fair deal below stat-price, since i sell over 40% of all the silk for over stat-price and it still drops.

I simply cant understand why people would drive the price down like that, seeing as it is obvious that selling above the stat-price will increase the long term profit.

but i guess that is the name of the game. :?

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 4:35 pm
by Guest
Warming wrote:Even though i have discussed this topic a few times allready, i never get sick of agreeing with the phrase "dont sell too cheap!"

I produce and sell about 1200 silk every day (aprox. 2800 is sold in total), and even though i sell for about 100 cT over stat-price, it keeps dropping. This means that some1 is selling for a fair deal below stat-price, since i sell over 40% of all the silk for over stat-price and it still drops.

I simply cant understand why people would drive the price down like that, seeing as it is obvious that selling above the stat-price will increase the long term profit.

but i guess that is the name of the game. :?
You have to sell at a price to clear all your inventory sometimes when you don't have the cash to upgrade your market. With larget markets you lose a lot of potential cash flow while upgrading.

That's one reason. That doesn't explain why people would do that on a regular basis though.

- Duncan

Elwood,

Don't look a gift horse in the mouth.

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 4:38 pm
by Guest
Also,

I tracke the price/quality stats. I can promise you that selling below the stat price does not hurt the market. What lowers the price is increases in the quantity supplied above 9% a day. As long as the market is under supplied you can still get the same price regardless of what others are charging.

- Duncan

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 6:48 pm
by Guest
Duncan wrote:Also,

I tracke the price/quality stats. I can promise you that selling below the stat price does not hurt the market.
- Duncan
I track the price/quality stats also and came to the exact opposite conclusion. When I have experimented with pricing in markets that I control, I can clearly see the positive and negative infuences of selling above or below stats price (after adjusting stats price for the Q you are selling).

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 8:24 pm
by Guest
Cash is Kingdom wrote:
Duncan wrote:Also,

I tracke the price/quality stats. I can promise you that selling below the stat price does not hurt the market.
- Duncan
I track the price/quality stats also and came to the exact opposite conclusion. When I have experimented with pricing in markets that I control, I can clearly see the positive and negative infuences of selling above or below stats price (after adjusting stats price for the Q you are selling).
The operative word is control. That has everything to do with control and not the average price, because the average price is YOUR price.

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 8:45 pm
by Guest
Here's some stats to illustrate my point. This is for the dried meat market starting 1 week ago. The percentage increase is for the following days. I do not control the market, however I have enough market share for my actions to show up on the stats. On the second day I started clearing some inventory. You can see the percentage increase in quantity and the drop in stat price. I did that for 2 days and then I raised my price up to normal. Notice that the stat price returned to normal trend.

Prices

d1:185.4 d2:180.73 d3:181.92 d4:184.92 d5:192.76

Quantity Supplied

d1:63,125 d2:66,380 d3:74,108 d4:83,712 d5:85,791

Percent increase in quantity

d2:11.64%d3: 12.96% d4:2.48% d5:-2.09%

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 8:46 pm
by Guest
Duncan wrote:The operative word is control. That has everything to do with control and not the average price, because the average price is YOUR price.
Sorry, I don´t get the point of this. The average price of ware x is the average of all ware x sold in market stalls on the previous day. In the entire regnum world. And so is the quality. And the stats price and quality affects the profit you can make in your market stalls.

Now you can say: I only have 2 taverns, my 400 beer daily don´t have an effect, so I don´t care about the price. But if 50% of all people think like that, they all together will have a very strong effect on the stats price. No wonder why warming cannot raise the price while controlling 40% of the market.

It´s like people that don´t vote because the think their one vote does not have any effect on the result of an election or like people who don´t try to avoid CO² pollution, because of the same reason. If they all would recognize that everybody can change things to the better, we would have no problem raising the stats price to get a better profit from the market stalls.

Sorry, didn´t want to start preaching here, but I think I sound like a preacher.

Elwood

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 8:49 pm
by Guest
I have a question, Duncan: How much dried meat do you sell every day?

Elwood

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 9:06 pm
by Guest
elwood74 wrote: And the stats price and quality affects the profit you can make in your market stalls.
You do know that that makes no sense whatsoever in consideration of real world economic principles? Why would the creators of the game do that?
elwood74 wrote: Now you can say: I only have 2 taverns, my 400 beer daily don´t have an effect, so I don´t care about the price. But if 50% of all people think like that, they all together will have a very strong effect on the stats price. No wonder why warming cannot raise the price while controlling 40% of the market.
Of course they will have an effect on the stat price. That doesn't mean that they can't raise their prices though. If they want to continue with the low price that is their stupid decision, but they are more than free to raise it.

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 9:07 pm
by Guest
elwood74 wrote:I have a question, Duncan: How much dried meat do you sell every day?

Elwood
10,000 normally.

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 9:37 pm
by Guest
I produce boats and sell them at 200 cT.
My average price by boat is 56,46 cT because I also produce wood, iron and pitch.
My benefit is almost 250 %


I suppose I sell these boats to fishermen.
With boats at 200 and fishing nets at 150 the average price of fish is 25,50 each.
Fishes can be found at 95 Ct.
Benefit for fish is almost 260 %

How to calculate the good price for selling boats ?
I don't know.

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 9:53 pm
by Guest
Sohayb wrote:I produce boats and sell them at 200 cT.
My average price by boat is 56,46 cT because I also produce wood, iron and pitch.
My benefit is almost 250 %
Aha. And now think about selling the 9 wood you need for the production for 24 at the market. Or sell them for 21.60 by contract. Would give you 194.40. And now sell the 2 tools for 12 at the market or 10.8 by contract. Another 21.60 you get. And you sell the entire boat for 200 ???

I was not talking about the fact that you don´t make profit or you sell below production cost. But the components used for the production of a boat are worth more than 200.
Sohayb wrote:How to calculate the good price for selling boats ?
I don't know.
In the end the market decides about the price. But unless you get more for the material than for the boats, just stop producing and selling boats and sell wood, and tools.

Again: I´m not selling boats. I´m producing exactly as much boats as my fishermen use, so I am not trying to push the market for my own profit.

Elwood

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 10:26 pm
by Guest
Ok Elwood.
I understand better this way.
I 'll try now to sell my boats at 450 cT or more.
Am I right ?
Thank you for the lesson !

Posted: Tue Dec 04, 2007 10:43 pm
by Guest
Elwood wrote:Again: I´m not selling boats. I´m producing exactly as much boats as my fishermen use, so I am not trying to push the market for my own profit.
I do the same with horses, for when i produce silk. They normaly cost me about 280 cT to produce (Q3), but i could easily sell them for about 4 times that much at the market. But since they are vital to my silk-production their value to me is much greater than that, because i have set my mind on being one of the biggest producers of silk.
So i dont think it's always "fair" to calculate the value of you components based on the market value alone. Some times you have to add an additional value to your stuff, based on what you goals with the game is (not all of us can aim for the top spots on the overall allod or total-assets list).