Page 1 of 1
Goats vs Pigs
Posted: Fri Nov 30, 2007 6:43 pm
by Guest
I'm a goat producer q4 atm. but it seems that there aren't many producers in that area, so I was wondering maybe I'm missing something here and maybe pigs? are a better product to have.
I'm still in early stages so any change now won't be s dramatic..
Just like to hear what is better to produce and retail - pigs or goats?
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2007 12:31 am
by Guest
I'm not realy in the breeding buisness, but i know that pigs are used for both salt meat and dried meat. The salt meat buisness is still realy small but the dried meat buisness is very large 80k+ sold each day. Also dried meat is used in some other productionlines.
So my guess is that i might not be a bad idea to switch to pruducing pigs, if it wont cost you alot to make the transition.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2007 12:44 am
by Guest
Pigs are not good for retail. They are best used for production at this point. I don't know about goats.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2007 1:09 am
by Guest
Well, I took a look at them earlier, and based on the current market price of beets and the market price of goats, goats do not seem like a good product at this point in time. Goats take 50 buckets of water and 20 bags of beets, and 5 ct; considering you generally can't get beets for less then 4 or sometimes 4.5 in the market any more, that's a cost of, what, at least 97 ct per goat. Considering you only can make a little under 18 goats per hour, and look at how low the price of goats in the marketplace is, it's a terrible investment right now.
Frankly, everything you can make at the cattle farm seems pretty bad right now. I made one cattle farm, just to experement, and while I'm not doing TOO bad with it I would have been much better off with something else. Between the fact that the tutorial basically encourages new players to run with the cattle farm, so there are way too many of them now, and the fact that the price of beets is just going to keep going up as the free early game beets become a smaller and smaller part of the market, the cattle farm is not a building I'd suggest investing in.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2007 2:50 am
by Guest
Goats aren't selling so great on the open market. They are used to make milk. Milk is in high demand and turns decent profit.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2007 8:39 am
by Guest
Every product in the cattle farm is for production except chicken. Or is chicken for making something?
Cattle farms seems like a building people need but don't necessarily want. At least with the price of beets high right now. I would try chicken maybe. They take grain, and grain is cheap and plentifull.
edit: After looking at the stats I think that no one is seriously invested in the chicken market. the average quality has been less than 1 for about a week. There was someone in that market but they must have gone on to other things. I bet you could make profit with some quality chickens.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2007 9:13 am
by Guest
I produce a little amount of goats to make milk an also leather.
Then I use leather to produce shoes, that i sell in my draper market stall or in market.
But it's a little market for little profits.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2007 11:39 am
by Guest
thx for all the advices!!, I'm probably on the verge of leaving this business, and considering to move to beers. casks etc..
hope that will be a better investment:)
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2007 3:46 pm
by Guest
Duncan wrote:I bet you could make profit with some quality chickens.
With the high price of grain, I don't believe it would be worth it. Using current Market prices of water (.24ct) and grain (20ct), they "cost" just over 107 to produce. And why would you produce your own grain to feed the chickens, when you can sell on the open market.
The cheapest chicken on the market is 90 (and I don't know how long it has been sitting there -- maybe not so fresh

).
The average NPC price is 115, still not a great profit.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2007 7:10 pm
by Guest
WeGotGame wrote:Goats aren't selling so great on the open market. They are used to make milk. Milk is in high demand and turns decent profit.
The thing is, if goats are consistatnly selling that low on the open market, you're better off just buying them on the open market instead of producing them yourself.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2007 11:38 pm
by Guest
Duncan wrote:
Cattle farms seems like a building people need but don't necessarily want. At least with the price of beets high right now.
I don't expect the price of beets to come back down, either, at least not until it's profitable to grow them on the farm.
Can someone with a farm tell me, how many beets can you grow in an hour?
Edit: Never mind, it was on the wiki. Hmm, 142 an hour? That's actually pretty good proft there then.
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2007 3:46 am
by Guest
WeGotGame wrote:Duncan wrote:I bet you could make profit with some quality chickens.
With the high price of grain, I don't believe it would be worth it. Using current Market prices of water (.24ct) and grain (20ct), they "cost" just over 107 to produce. And why would you produce your own grain to feed the chickens, when you can sell on the open market.
The cheapest chicken on the market is 90 (and I don't know how long it has been sitting there -- maybe not so fresh

).
The average NPC price is 115, still not a great profit.
I think though that if you invested in quality the profit would come. You can buy quality grain for pretty cheap. Maybe if you had q5 chickens or something like that you could do well.