Page 1 of 1
contest rankings needs sorting out
Posted: Sat Feb 05, 2011 10:03 am
by Guest
Hello
My town in this game is called Itzstedt.
I have a query....
In the contest the 2nd and 3rd place have same total. In the real world they both came second and deserve a silver medal.
In other words that means I came 3rd and deserve bronze medal.
In other words everyone must come up a position.
If this is not the case please let me know why????
another example who came 44th
44 3,000 Boltzmannland
45 3,000 Vice_City
another example who came 66th
66 1,200 TmRo
67 1,200 Nissi
another example who came 82th
82 1,000 Lyvalla
83 1,000 Dregland
84 1,000 Dollville
85 1,000 zips
In other words all 107 towns should get a certificate as in real definition all are in top 100
Thanks Dave
Posted: Sat Feb 05, 2011 10:59 am
by Guest
I attended a few contests in real life. My experience shows that whenever 2 competitors have the same amount of points either a special rules decided which one was ranked first or both were ranked equal and the next place stayed free!
eg here.
1 Dover Castle
2 DS Minas Gerais
2 Vaticano (or any rule decided place 3)
4 Itzstedt ... cannot be 3rd because 3 competitors are better!
Sorry Dave, but this is my experience! Anyhow you are right the issue of the 2nd place have to be clarified!
regards, Volki
how does it work
Posted: Sat Feb 05, 2011 11:26 am
by Guest
with the rankings what formula is used
volki
Posted: Sat Feb 05, 2011 11:36 am
by Guest
Thank you for you perspective or insight on the matter.
In the Olympics games a medal can be shared with two contender countries for example boxing when it ends in a draw. or
Tournament Poker: Ties rarely occur, since multiple simultaneous player eliminations will rank the eliminated players by chip counts. However, if two or more players are eliminated in one hand, and both players started the hand with identical chip counts, the players will be tied in official rankings. It is impossible for poker tournaments to end in a tie (since one player must end up with all the chips), though multiple players may be tied for second place.
The fact that the top 3 produced more than me in not in Question here.
The question is if both get rewarded for second place then who gets rewarded for third????
My last question is... was this planned from both players that both add same amount or was it just luck ????
I just want a clear rule here .
Dave
Posted: Sat Feb 05, 2011 1:22 pm
by Guest
The rankings are alphabetical arranged so people with towns starting from A get a better slot when totals are equal that is not right
I think they are not.
Take a closer look at people with 2000 items (since there are so many of them it's most clear):
53 2,000 Brighton Castle
54 2,000 rastatt
55 2,000 Goodtimes
56 2,000 Temeshwar
57 2,000 Kronstadt Burg
58 2,000 Freimettigen
59 2,000 Grazer
See? B - R - G - T - K - F - G, it's hardly a good alphabet
In my experience (I'm rather small, so keep low in contests and often find myself in such lists) person, who added 2000
last will be
first in the list. And so on - if someone else comes with 2000, he will be first, etc, etc.
Posted: Mon Feb 07, 2011 10:42 am
by pearlbay
Hi everyone,
to answer your question, Dave: They both sent in the same amount, that is correct, but the town DS Minas Gerais sent them in first, so is ranked second, whereas Vaticano is ranked third, in spite of the fact that they have the same amount of points.
If we were to say, OK: If player x and player y have the same amount of points, they will receive the same medal, imagine what would happen if (in theory) all players decided to send in the same amount of items - should then everyone get a gold medal?

I am afraid, that is the reason why the system is set up as it is.
And, if you check the amount of items you sent in, is is indeed much lower than what places 2 and 3 have sent in. But no worries, this surely isn't the last contest on Regnum, maybe you will have better luck next time!
Best regards,
pearlbay