Page 1 of 3

Morals?

Posted: Wed Nov 14, 2007 4:26 am
by Guest
Is it wrong to take advantage of players who purchase over NPC? I've consistently seen water over NPC price on the open market. I tested it twice today and once sold water at NPC and the other over at .30

So it is obvious that all those players above NPC are taking advantage of others' ignorance. Right, Wrong, Such is Life in the Real World?

Posted: Wed Nov 14, 2007 4:37 am
by Guest
such is life, i mean if the player buying the product doesn't buy it from npc if nothing is cheaper then thats his/her own fault of negligence

Posted: Wed Nov 14, 2007 5:01 am
by Guest
a fool and his money are soon separated...

Posted: Wed Nov 14, 2007 9:47 am
by Guest
Its like the question wether to buy coins/trade with them or not. Everyone has to answer this for themselfs.
My opinion is, you may get lucky and have someone buy your overpriced product, but basing your strategy on this behaivour is a great risk. Like sandman said, a fool will be short on money pretty fast so its unlikely that you can expect to sell great quantities of these goods with such a price. And for every unit which lies on the market and isn't sold you loose money.
And of course there is the question what others may think of you. Would you like to trade with someone who tries to ripp off inexperienced players with overpriced products?
Under- and overpricing happens, as its hard to determine how the price of a product will develop in the near future (say some hours) but the NPC sets an obvious limit to some products. Selling above this means "I hope you/somebody is stupid enough to buy this" and i know i would'nt like to make more serious contracts with a person, which shows such attitude towards his customers.

But thats just my opinion, maybe there are people who feel its perfectly acceptable to sell above NPC-price. As said, thats a personal question, there is no obvious or objective answer to this.

Posted: Wed Nov 14, 2007 12:10 pm
by Guest
I know it's not against the rules but I do feel like it's a form of pushing. I don't like it. It spoils the game for me. I mean my not liking it spoils the game for me.I think the market lists should be ordered in terms of price, straight off the bat, no pressing the price button. No pushing/cheating/multi account users...

As far as suggestions go it will never happen, like 99.9% of suggestions. It will be too hard to implement. MAYBE next version...

Posted: Wed Nov 14, 2007 1:29 pm
by Guest
In Kapilands (1 & 2) I can understand how new players might be confused because of the color difference, but (at least on my PCs) the NPC's item is the same color, so blends in.

I guess I should worry more about my own account (that loses ground daily) than new players being taken advantage of.

Posted: Wed Nov 14, 2007 4:35 pm
by Guest
TheSmell wrote:I know it's not against the rules but I do feel like it's a form of pushing.
Exactly. And it can be suspected to be cheating very quickly.

Maybe not if you sell water for .3, but what about selling water for 1 or 100. If someone buys that, it´s definitely cheating for me. And no one knows at what price to draw the line...

So you should be careful selling overpriced stuff.

Elwood

Posted: Thu Nov 15, 2007 12:57 am
by Guest
I figure in this game you really aren't playing to win because other people will be buying and selling different amounts of coins anyway, so no it's not immoral.

Posted: Thu Nov 15, 2007 10:29 pm
by Guest
Its the sellers problem if to risk for higher income with possible 10% loss
and buyers stupidity to buy it over priced

Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2007 1:23 am
by Guest
TheSmell wrote:I know it's not against the rules but I do feel like it's a form of pushing. I don't like it. It spoils the game for me. I mean my not liking it spoils the game for me.I think the market lists should be ordered in terms of price, straight off the bat, no pressing the price button. No pushing/cheating/multi account users...

As far as suggestions go it will never happen, like 99.9% of suggestions. It will be too hard to implement. MAYBE next version...
this wont be changed. you are meant to use your brain, this is a game for people who like to think and calculate stuff. I think everyone can be expected to look for the cheapest offer of Q0!! water and thus click once!! on sort by price. I think this is the simplest of things to do, but it is also an integral part of the game.
IF you sort this by price by default, then other people are going to come and say, can you please filter beer by quality because i want to see the highest quality first etc...

Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2007 3:29 am
by Guest
Oh yeah, use your brain, ask your friends at kindergarden to buy your water for 100 then say it was a natural mistake. Worse still, get your mum to buy it from her work for 40CT and use the same excuse.

Give dishonest players an excuse to cheat and they will. Remove the excuse and they wont be able to use it. If it's too hard to play by the rules because some others aren't, then just stop playing games with huge loopholes.

Seriously, why are you offering the cheaters any room for excuses? So you can ban them? So all the honest players will leave? So the dumb players can get their backsides wooped? Get smart, the smart players don't need to practice being smart, they are either honest or not.

If it's supposed to make you think then think about the loopholes, get some players to buy coins so they get in front of everyone, then let the dishonest players try to catch up by pushing their friendly accounts.

I think that it's time for someone to post a link to another hopeless thread where we are told that everything is being done to stop cheating. One of those threads where we discuss just how much you can cheat by before you get banned.

I'm not going to buy an IP changer because it's dishonest in a lot of situations, and I can't afford it either. It's not a game.

Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2007 1:53 pm
by Guest
are you responding to what i said? coz this sounds like a lot of rambling.. about cheating and i have no idea what you are on about.
All i said was that a simple thing like pushing a link to "sort by price" is an important part of this business game.

Maybe you had a good night out :) hehe who knows
TheSmell wrote:Oh yeah, use your brain, ask your friends at kindergarden to buy your water for 100 then say it was a natural mistake. Worse still, get your mum to buy it from her work for 40CT and use the same excuse.

Give dishonest players an excuse to cheat and they will. Remove the excuse and they wont be able to use it. If it's too hard to play by the rules because some others aren't, then just stop playing games with huge loopholes.

Seriously, why are you offering the cheaters any room for excuses? So you can ban them? So all the honest players will leave? So the dumb players can get their backsides wooped? Get smart, the smart players don't need to practice being smart, they are either honest or not.

If it's supposed to make you think then think about the loopholes, get some players to buy coins so they get in front of everyone, then let the dishonest players try to catch up by pushing their friendly accounts.

I think that it's time for someone to post a link to another hopeless thread where we are told that everything is being done to stop cheating. One of those threads where we discuss just how much you can cheat by before you get banned.

I'm not going to buy an IP changer because it's dishonest in a lot of situations, and I can't afford it either. It's not a game.

Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2007 6:14 pm
by Guest
he very well makes sense, what world are u in :?: A smart man does not need to practise a dumb one does. so if its putting automatic filter on it, then well makes life easier for us ansd herder for cheaters

Posted: Fri Nov 16, 2007 11:52 pm
by Guest
I really think you guys are confusing something. Cheating is when people create multiple accounts or transfer goods or coins between accounts for 0 Thaler or millions.
The argument here is whether it is a good idea to implement an automatic filter to automatically sort all offers by price. Which I think is convenient but would take a, in my opinion, integral part of the game away. The part where I go to the market, make a conscious decision to either just buy anything, or sort by quality or sort by price, or by the latest offer. If I am being "guided" to the cheapest offer, what happens to the people that offer good quality at higher prices, they just loose out.

Posted: Sat Nov 17, 2007 2:44 am
by Guest
Hogs Head wrote:I really think you guys are confusing something. Cheating is when people create multiple accounts or transfer goods or coins between accounts for 0 Thaler or millions.
The argument here is whether it is a good idea to implement an automatic filter to automatically sort all offers by price. Which I think is convenient but would take a, in my opinion, integral part of the game away. The part where I go to the market, make a conscious decision to either just buy anything, or sort by quality or sort by price, or by the latest offer. If I am being "guided" to the cheapest offer, what happens to the people that offer good quality at higher prices, they just loose out.
I agree with this.

When you goto buy a car, the salesmen doesn;t show you thier cheapest cars first, nor do they create a list of the cheapest to the most expensive cars on a list.

Having the cheaper price is because the player seeks out that offer, they can simply click "price" to arrange that and see who offers the cheapest.

Making everything autmoatic decieves the purpose of this game. People here are too make money whether they beat the lowest seller or sell above 10% market price. It is luck, is that not a factor in business? Being lucky?

Take out one factor, and you might as well take out the rest.