Page 1 of 1

Double Quality setting required when using q0 raw materials?

Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2007 9:44 pm
by Guest
My end goal is to make Q2 casks. I currently have a Master Craftsman building. I do not yet have a Master Mason, so I'll assume Q0 Iron Ore as well.

I think if I'm understanding the formula correctly, I need to do double research in every step just to overcome the fact that I cannot upgrade wood. (Q0 is max for wood, stone, water)

So from the bottom of the production chain up, can someone check my math and understanding?
  • Coal takes Wood as an ingredient. If I want to get Q2 coal while using Q0 wood, my coal quality setting (and thus research) must be 4. (4+0)/2=2 -- Quality 4 Coal setting + Q0 Wood / 2 used qualities

    Iron takes Iron Ore and Coal as ingredients. If I want to get Q2 Iron, my iron quality setting (and thus research) must be 4. (4+0+2)/3=2 -- Quality 4 Iron setting + Q0 Iron Ore + Q2 Coal / 3 used qualities

    Tools take Wood and Iron as ingredients. If I want to get Q2 Tools, my tools quality setting (and thus research) must be 4. (4+0+2)/3=2 -- Quality 4 Tools setting + Q0 Wood + Q2 Iron / 3 used qualities

    Casks take Wood, Iron and Tools as ingredients. If I want to get Q2 Casks, my cask quality setting (and thus research) must be 4. (4+0+2+2)/4=2 -- Quality 4 Cask setting + Q0 Wood + Q2 Iron + Q2 Tools
It seems that anytime I'm making a product that uses an ingredient that cannot be upgraded beyond Q0, I'm required to double the research and quality setting of the product just to compensate for the repeated use of the Q0 ingredients. :cry:

I played a bit with the numbers here and even if I did build the master mason, I'd have to bump the iron ore research up to lvl 8 before it has any effect on the casks.

Is my understanding correct here? If so it seems that the Quality restrictions that according to the FAQ are supposed to help out the beginners, really throw a monkey wrench into the later quality calculations.

Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2007 10:10 pm
by Guest
It helps beginers in the way that they can sell those products without having to put effort in research first.

It also limits the speed you can increase the quality for some products, which i think was done on purpose. Because it also increases trade, because you are more likely to buy some high quality iron or tools now, since its not so easy to get all 3 products to a high quality yourself.

Posted: Mon Nov 12, 2007 11:40 pm
by Guest
I suppose that's one way to look at it.

Bear in mind though that every product in the game either comes from q0 material, or comes from things that themselves come from q0 material. So it's a very universal effect.

Now the thing I never quite got used to is counting inputs equally. Take wine for example. I'm supposed to believe that a tiny portion of a cask is as useful to good wine as the 20 quarts of grapes are? Now I know a good cask has it's place, but come on - you can't make really good wine from lousy grapes just by getting nice casks.

Posted: Tue Nov 13, 2007 12:22 am
by Guest
On the other hand, it helps me out and even makes sense for my products. I make high quality (for this stage in the game anyway) grain, and since I have grain research and make breads, I research breads too, in the same building. But I also produce chickens, and although I haven't bothered to research them, I feed them my good grain, and they turn out better. :D