Page 1 of 2
knowledge sharing
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 10:26 am
by Guest
it seems i have discovered a bug. or maybe it had been already known.
the quality check while producing a product is only done at the beginning of production. we can sell the knowledge after giving instructions to the buildings.
or we can borrow the knowledge, instruct the buildings and return back the knowledge to city from where we have acquired it.
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 10:29 am
by Guest
Yes, that is a well known exploit (or maybe not that well known after all!)
Cool isn't it! I only wish that there was a way to possess more than one instance of a particular knowledge. It would help in buying off those for the members who aren't councillors yet!
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 5:49 pm
by Guest
Well that's a nice bug indeed!
I knew that you could keep your production happening after selling a knowledge but I never thought of borrowing a knowledge...
Cool.....
I thank you!
xoxox
Posted: Thu Feb 19, 2009 6:41 pm
by Guest
i think we should get it clarified from a mod that we can use this method of knowledge sharing or it will be marked as cheating.
certain things have to be kept in mind that before accepting a higher knowledge we should sold our own knowledge to own city. for ex- i ahve 30 q grain and befor i buy higher q i should sell the knowledge to my city and then buy it back after the higher quality is returned to the borrower.
the method is however based on faith. but it will be good to sell the knowledge at very high price so that the city who had borrowed will be forced to sell it back.
Posted: Fri Feb 20, 2009 2:18 pm
by Guest
your idea about selling our own knowledge to ourselves is fantastic!
This way I can buy some starter knowledge from the market or just start it up myself and upgrade it to start up a nice young city, would be awesome. Especially for us guild leaders etc... Being a focal point of help helps

Posted: Fri Feb 20, 2009 3:33 pm
by Guest
The knowledge would have to completely leave the city.. It is still yours as long as it is in a contract...
This is awsome... I am looking forward to getting permission for this...
I think though that this is a creative idea that has no reason to be called cheating... Just creative...
I would love to start playing around with this idea today, but I will only dream of what can be done with this until one of our fine game keepers gives us a green light!!!!
Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 1:43 pm
by Guest
ishnuporah wrote:i think we should get it clarified from a mod that we can use this method of knowledge sharing or it will be marked as cheating.
I think it is cheating to borrow a knowledge to another player and buy it back.
I cant renember, that it was clearly said at german servers, but so some people will get a big advantage by sharing knowledges.
Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 1:58 pm
by Guest
Ithaka wrote:ishnuporah wrote:i think we should get it clarified from a mod that we can use this method of knowledge sharing or it will be marked as cheating.
I think it is cheating to borrow a knowledge to another player and buy it back.
I cant renember, that it was clearly said at german servers, but so some people will get a big advantage buy sharing knowledges.
Hmnn.... Interesting! I thought that experienced masters of guilds would often be sent to a neighbour Lord's castle on goodwill or payment. It wouldn't be totally out of character for the game.
Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 4:29 pm
by Guest
i think we can give advantage to knowledge lender by giving some lower price when we are returning the knowledge.
let's say i buyed the knowlede for grain at 20 million then i will return it back at 18 million to give profit of 2 million to the lender.
Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 5:50 pm
by Guest
If I'm correct this so-called 'bug' has been fixed in Holland, I've never checked after they said so, but I suposse it's been fixed..
But my assumption was it was here fixed as well, since this was considered cheating in Holland..
Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 7:42 pm
by Guest
I think if it were cheating we would have been told by now...
We can sell coins and then buy them back at an increase/decrease.
I am still not ready to start shipping my knowledge around... I will wait a while longer yet - just in case no moderator has seen this post...
It does give an advantage alright, it also encourages building buisness partners...
I think it would be a great way to keep the new cities active and interested... That would increase our population and maybe have more people to purchase coins from the system...
Posted: Sat Feb 21, 2009 10:00 pm
by Guest
i agree it will also help smaller bussinesses[/quote]
Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 12:45 am
by Guest
ishnuporah wrote:let's say i buyed the knowlede for grain at 20 million then i will return it back at 18 million to give profit of 2 million to the lender.
in my eyes its cheating
littlewoman wrote:
We can sell coins and then buy them back at an increase/decrease.
and this is cheating, too
on (or by?) both ways you can transfer millions of cTs in one direction. Be sure, the game administration is looking after such one direction trades
i would be careful
Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 1:27 am
by Guest
I kind of agree with Ithaka there... such transactions ARE technically cheating.
I admit to doing some of them. But with a pre declared intent. Like running a lottery or contest. Practical needs of this game (small player base) dictates that rules be looked at more flexibly and with regard to encouraging players on this forum.
Also, seriously, knowledge trading is a grey area. For example, if I was desperate for cash, I might sell my knowledge on the market a bit cheap! Now, I might get my cash back soon and try to buy it back! It would obviously benefit the other person. Would that be cheating? Or if I sent my knowledge to another player so that they can upgrade it a bit for me in one of their lodges. And I would obviously pay a premium to buy it back. Would that be cheating?
Extreme cases such as a regular exchange of knowledge on a sort of daily basis between two players could be viewed as cheating. Then again, it could be a strategic partnership where the two players are in fact playing towards raising a knowledge each and producing better goods. In plain terms, I would call that 'On the line'.
Transferring knowledge around at the same level on a daily basis but with a financial advantage to one side would definitely be cheating, IMHO.
That is my take on this. Honestly. I hope the mods agree with a bit of it and don't make it too complicated

Posted: Sun Feb 22, 2009 2:32 am
by Guest
pk wrote:
Also, seriously, knowledge trading is a grey area. For example, if I was desperate for cash, I might sell my knowledge on the market a bit cheap! Now, I might get my cash back soon and try to buy it back! It would obviously benefit the other person. Would that be cheating?
difficult, because its a kind of credit - and they are not allod by rules. but i think its so problematical. In most cases it is only done once. I think this is ok and there will be no problems.
pk wrote:
Or if I sent my knowledge to another player so that they can upgrade it a bit for me in one of their lodges. And I would obviously pay a premium to buy it back. Would that be cheating?
Yes, it is. at the german server its called "auftragsforschung" (contract research) - and it has been prohibited some monthes ago. Players are not allowed to say: Please research product X for me. If you have finished, i will pay you XXX cT. the same thing with buildings - contract build has been prohibited, too. But it is possible to sell buildings/researches which are not longer required.