If you want to correct this, my opinion would be to reset the contest, return the venison and start over again.
I would hate to think that the contest was ended without enough notice , just on a whim or a technical error.
That would only make it worse, then you should at least make it another product. Instead of a few that would have been left out, most would have been.
I think that this is a honest mistake, and its a mistake that has happened before. It has happened twice as I can recall, the first time there was someone that got in the same situation as Minas Tirith. He didnt get anything back. But that time there was 2-4 posts on the board about the subject in good time before the contest ended. Some of those was made from official persons. The second time the contest got changed, and an official post was made on the board.
This time, we all had to guess, and I for one is really really happy that we guessed right, if we had guessed wrong, the ending would have been altoghether different, and I would be in Minas's shoes now, feeling that I had lost something because of an administrative error.
I completely agree with PK that accident happen, and that indeed Theridan is doing a great job and should get a big thank you and not get yelled at. But that said, the circumstances made it really confusing, and not a lot of possibilities existed to correct any mistakes.
-There was a post on the board, but it was posted the same day as the contest finished, and there was no official announcment till after the contest was finished. So even though I read the post I still had to guess.
-You should be able to trust the journal, and since this has happened before, at least twice, I would think that it would lead to the facts being doublechecked. (That said, I would not have liked to be the one that has to do the kind of wierd logic as Therian explained in the other thread)
My point is that Minas Tirith has made a very understanable mistake, and had virtually no chance at correcting that mistake. At least he got no chance from any officials.
What should be done: My opinion is that he should be reinbursed in some way, that he should send all his venison to a moderator or something, at least check how many he has, and then he should get the reward that normally would recieved.
This will fix all the problems that has arisen because of a mistake made from the from Kapi-regnum. Noone wants to be bitter here, and I am sure that Minas Tirith will have no problem to forgive and forget if he got the award he should have gotten. I dont think that people should lose any rewards that they already have gotten, that would not be fair either. I dont think that any double reward in the contest, be it 1'st or 85'th place, will have any impact on the game. But this is up to the moderators to decide.
I won the gold, witch I am very happy with, but if it was indeed Minas Tirith who won, then he should get a gold medal too. (and if that is impossible, then he should have it, and I should have second.)
How much venison are you stuck with?
Just one last note from me. I completely understand that you are upset. As you can read above I support your case completely, but I also think that we should not direct it to Theridan, but to Kapi-regnum. This does not have to be an issue where anyone have to agrue, Theridan probably completely agree that this is not a perfect situation, but when you do so much unpaid work the last thing you need is to get shouted at. And when he does get shouted at, a lot of people (myself included) get the urge to defend him, even though the issues behind the anger it is valid. Because of the way they are presented. We are all on the same side here!