Page 1 of 2
Upgrade water and farm products?
Posted: Sun Sep 21, 2008 4:01 pm
by Guest
Hello, i am new to this game, so i have a question.
I searchd on forum for this but didnt find anything.
How can i upgrade watre to be quality lvl 1 or higher?
Same question for farm produtcs like herbs, grain and beets?
I know its not on knowledge menu.
So i cant make goats q.l. 3 cuz i dont have water and beets q.l. 3.
Tnx
Posted: Sun Sep 21, 2008 4:10 pm
by Guest
Water stone and wood cannot be upgraded, it will always drag doen the quality of products you make with them...
You can upgrade farm goods in the monastery garden. You will find this building in the knowledge section - that is in your city hall where you bought your farm, lower on the same page.
Welcome to Kapi-regnum!
The littlewoman from Haltonhills xoxox
Posted: Sun Sep 21, 2008 8:22 pm
by Guest
Thanks for help and thanks for warm welcome!
Posted: Sun Sep 21, 2008 9:31 pm
by Guest
Another tips for new cities:
Water production is "not" profitable at all. It is not smart to build wells. You could earn more money if you invest your cash into somewhere else.
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2008 10:39 am
by Guest
In the long run, its cheaper to produce your own water. There is a positive return on investment for water that you use for your own production, its just slower than other buildings. It takes 15 days for a well upgrade to pay for itself. Building a new well would take months to pay for itself, so I certainly wouldn't build a new well (unless I was cash rich and wanted to be self-sufficient).
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2008 10:58 am
by Guest
In the long run, it is NEVER EVER worth producing your own water. You can learn it the quick painless way, or the hard time-consuming way.

Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2008 10:36 pm
by Guest
I forget at which rank I was when I did the math, but at the time it would have cost me 58,394 thalers to upgrade my well by 20 sq ft. Adding 24 hours of water at .02 thalers adds another 5300 thalers.
Buying the same amount of water at .24 thalers will reach, and then exceed the cost of well expansion near the beginning of day 14.
I did my calculations for 20 sq ft because I also ran the costs out for building a new well. A new well takes 22 days.
Its hard to understand why anyone would argue why water is not cost effective since buying water costs more than producing water.
The real issue at hand is whether your money is better spent on some other project. If that "other project" is to sit in your treasury, by all means, expanding your well is a better investment.
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2008 11:14 pm
by Guest
I like my three wells. they are 4500sqm because I upgraded them...!
I know, I know, I know.... all the arguments, even got rid of a couple to make room for production buildings, still, I rarely buy water...
Posted: Mon Sep 22, 2008 11:20 pm
by Guest

mine are also crossing the 4k ... and i dont need to buy as much water as i had to bevor .. i got 3 wells 2 producing at all times and one upgrading at all times. I started out with 6 until they where up to 1000sq.
Some say its a waste of time and space .... but i realy dont care .... its a game.
City of Freimettigen
Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2008 1:22 am
by Guest
Everyone has their own opinions about wells, some people play casually and prefer not to advance as quickly or efficiently as others and that's perfectly fine if they're enjoying themselves playing the game the way they like it.
Cheers
Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2008 1:56 am
by Guest
For the benefit of Dusan84, who raised the original question, the argument against water is that if you only have 60 spots available for buildings, then these sixty spots are very valuable, and you can put a building there which can make you more profit than the money you lose on buying water.
Its not that a well is not economically good, but rather some other choice is significantly better.
However, I will point out that this choice doesn't favor the water-buyer until he has built all of his slots, and that secondly, having no wells during the early part of the game, means spending precious cash on water, when I think its pretty clear that money is better spend elsewhere in the early game.
But certainly in the middle game (when you have used up all your building slots) you can do better with a building that makes you money than you can with a well (which saves you money).
A 200 sq ft well might save you around 42,000 thalers per day, but you can make 42,000 thalers with 20 or 30 sq ft of brewery (and another equal amount of grain farm).
So as a beginner, I certainly recommend you keep your well until you are full up, then you might very reasonably decide to get rid of your well and use that slot more productively buying water.
Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2008 2:32 am
by Guest
Dusan84 never raised the question about whether or not to build wells.

Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2008 3:11 am
by Guest
No one said he did. But it stands to reason that we should not conduct a debate on wells that simply assume the arguments and do not explain them in a thread started by a new player asking about water.
Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2008 6:37 am
by Guest
I would still regard it a better option to make a few lubmerjacks and buy water to make wood and then sell sood instead!
to be honest, I had 3 X 10k wells.. I sold mine b'coz I was still buying 2/3rds of my water requirement. So, after maybe huckster or something, its definitely not worth retaining them... and if yo u still have a few, wy not sell at discount to a friend who is starting and make a long term trade partner and friend

Posted: Tue Sep 23, 2008 6:43 am
by Guest
kgauck wrote:So as a beginner, I certainly recommend you keep your well until you are full up, then you might very reasonably decide to get rid of your well and use that slot more productively buying water.
This suggestion is definitely poison.
Let's talk about a simple comparison between a farm and a well. It is a fair comparison since the building cost, expansion cost and employee fee are equal.
At freeman level, how much money one well could earn per hour?
Assume we could sell all water as 0.24ct:
1069.31(bucket per hour) x (0.24-0.01)ct = 245.9 ct/hour
How much money one farm could earn per hour?
We buy 2 buckets of water from the NPC and unit cost of q0 grain shall be 1.48ct. Assume we sell all grain as 30ct.
26.73(bushel per hour) x (20-1.48)ct = 762.3 ct/hour
Please take a look at the market price, we shall find that the price of grain is much much higher than what I assume here. Other farm products, such as beets and herbs are also hot.
To build one well instead of one farm, we lost more than 500 ct every hour. Wells will not save us any money, they corrupt our economy in a different form.
The only good reason to build wells is that might reduce inflation since water producers won't earn much money from system.