Page 1 of 2

Building new vs. expanding

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 11:25 pm
by Guest
There's been a debate about this in the forum already, although I don't remember exactly where now. But I just thought I'd show some numbers and calculations I did to decide for myself whether building a new building was better than expanding the ones I had. I'm going to calculate here the prices to build a new building or expand the same type by 20^2, either one of which will give the same amount of productivity increase.

First, some market prices:
Stones 12
Tools 12
Wood 16

Except for tools, these aren't the NPC prices, because people are offering them cheaper.

Each building generally requires 100 Wood, 50 Stones, 10 Tools to build new, and also to expand by 1 m^2. This comes out to a cost of 2320 using those market prices.

For a building that costs 60000, which is many of the starting ones (well, farm, cattle farm, lumberjack, fruit picker), the total cost to build a new one would then be 62320. I'm ignoring employee costs because they'll be the same for a new building or an existing building that's expanded by 20 m^2.

Expansion costs 1500 + the above material cost of 2320 per m^2. For 20 m^2 that comes to 76400. This is obviously more than 62320, so the conclusion is that if you buy all your materials from the market, expanding is more expensive.

But wait. What if you don't buy all your materials from the market? One possibility is my own situation, where I produce wood myself. I don't have to buy wood. In this case we have to calculate the value of the wood produced and add that in instead of the market price of wood.

Wood costs 2 to make and uses 20 water, which is worth .24 each (market price). So the total value of wood produced is 6.8. Plus some for your production time, since you don't want to steal from your production. Say 8.

So using 8 for the value of wood instead of 16, we get a materials cost for building of 1520 instead of 2320. That means that a new building will cost 61520, and expanding by 20 m^2 will cost 60400. Now it's cheaper to expand. If you made both wood and stone, your savings would be more. Plus, the cost you actually see is less. You're using what you've already invested (in the form of a lumberjack or stone pit) instead of paying out of pocket for your building materials.

The numbers end up being pretty close. It actually depends on the individual prices and how you value your materials. Using the cost of production plus a bit for all three, you can come up with an expansion price of 58000 vs. 61400 for a new building. Using the actual selling price, it's 63200 vs. 61660. And using market prices, as above, it's 76400 vs. 62320.

Because it's that close, paying a little more for extra materials to expand can be thought of as an investment into keeping a building slot open for something else, too. Doesn't matter much at the beginning, but later on it could make a difference. For a market stall, fewer buildings means fewer ads needed later, for instance.

Hope this helps.

Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 11:40 pm
by Guest
Uhm, the worth of the product, even if you produce it yourself, is STILL the price you can sell it for. And not suddenly lower...

Stop stealing your own profit :P

Posted: Mon Nov 05, 2007 12:36 am
by Guest
the worth of the product, even if you produce it yourself, is STILL the price you can sell it for.
Smart man.

Also you should take into account Opportunity Cost.

When you build a second building, your first building is producing all that time. When you expand that first building, the space you already have stops being useful for 5 hours (or however long the expansion takes).

So even if the costs are equivalent (and they will be less so after the wood and stone prices inevitably move up), you get hours of extra production by building instead of expanding.

Also, once you hit Bourgeois your material requirements go up. Since expanding uses more materials, that cost is going to climb more.

Posted: Mon Nov 05, 2007 1:54 am
by Guest
It's still pretty close at the beginning though. And you still can't sell a product for market price, so what you can buy it for is more than what you can sell it for. So there's still a difference.

And at the beginning, unless you're really clever (and you guys probably are, but not everyone is), it's not easy to find a balance of buildings that allows you to run them all 24 hours a day anyway, due to either material balancing or real-life time balancing.

One other consideration is the need to have more cash on hand to build a completely new building. If you've got the materials already, then it only takes 30k to upgrade a building by 20 m^2, and you can even do it in 10 m^2 increments (15k). If you've invested most of your cash in your initial setup, or have recently built or expanded other buildings and don't have much cash left, then you can expand faster than you can build new.

As a rough example, if you're currently getting 20k/day profit from the building you want to expand, and expanding will allow you to double your output, then once it's done, you'll get 40k/day profit, theoretically. So you give up 4k now (five hours at current output), spend 30k on the upgrade, and the next day you'll make 20k more, and have your 30k again in a day (or two, depending on how long it takes to sell or whatever). Whereas, if you have to wait until you have 60k to build a new building, then you have to wait a day and half (have 30k already, and get 20k/day) to build a new building, which takes five more hours to build, and then you'll start getting 40k/day in almost two days from now. With the first scenario, you could make a second upgrade by the time you finish the first upgrade in the second scenario.

Posted: Mon Nov 05, 2007 2:07 am
by Guest
There are a few buildings that I like to buy expand early. They are the guild masters buildings. Expanding these buildings is a must.

I'm sure building more and more monastic gardens becomes a waste eventually. Expanding the 1-3 that you have will be much more profitable than getting another one.

Posted: Mon Nov 05, 2007 2:57 am
by Guest
telyni wrote:One other consideration is the need to have more cash on hand to build a completely new building.
That's a good point telyni. Supplies sitting in the warehouse aren't earning you any money.

Also, based on what I said you could make the case it's better to expand early when it requires fewer materials. Basically use 10 tools to build and 100 to expand, then 12 to build at a later level. Instead of using 10 now to build and 10 to expand, and 120 later to expand.

I still wouldn't go that way, but you are right that there are benefits.

Posted: Tue Nov 06, 2007 7:03 am
by Guest
they give the same boost to production right? if i have a 20m3 building if i make it into a 40m3 or make another 20 m3 building my production goes up by the same amount right?

Posted: Tue Nov 06, 2007 2:02 pm
by Guest
sneeperofsand wrote:they give the same boost to production right? if i have a 20m3 building if i make it into a 40m3 or make another 20 m3 building my production goes up by the same amount right?
If this is the same as Kapilands: No. There, when you hire more workers, your production per employee actually decreases. You're better off adding new buildings until you hit your limit.

Posted: Tue Nov 06, 2007 3:44 pm
by Guest
Actually, it appears to be the same. My 40 m^2 building appears to make exactly twice as much as it did when it was 20 m^2. As I told Knolls, maybe there's a tiny decrease in productivity that I can't see at this point, but for all intents and purposes there appears to be no decrease right now.

Maybe it isn't obvious, but this isn't the same game as Kapilands. Yes, some things work the same, but some don't. And it doesn't have to be the same.

Posted: Tue Nov 06, 2007 10:50 pm
by Guest
Actually there is a small decrease :(

A 40M2 building only produces stuff 1.98 times faster than a 20M2 one, but I think the decrease is smaller than the one in the orginal kapilands.

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 12:07 am
by Guest
still thats not bad

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 4:33 am
by Guest
Puzzman wrote:Actually there is a small decrease :(

A 40M2 building only produces stuff 1.98 times faster than a 20M2 one, but I think the decrease is smaller than the one in the orginal kapilands.
Eep. Well that's only one level, you'll be feeling it at 400 and 4000 m2.

Is there an "optimize" option after 400 employees like in the orig?

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 2:00 pm
by Guest
since no one has that yet were not yet sure.

Posted: Wed Nov 07, 2007 4:32 pm
by Guest
What did the optimize function do in kapilands?

Posted: Fri Nov 09, 2007 7:40 pm
by Guest
It gave u a small amount of faster production after 400 employes