Page 1 of 1
Economics questions
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 9:37 am
by Guest
This is more of an advanced question, which is why I didn't put it in the beginning question forum. Basically, I was looking at Knolls' economics tutorial threads in the kapilands forum (I'm not currently playing or have ever played kapilands, although it seems pretty similar) and found one about calculating the perfect price to sell a product at in a retail store to maximize profit over time (can be found here:
http://www.forum.kapilands.com/viewtopic.php?t=4219). It's a pretty simple method, but something that I hadn't come up with on my own. I immediately set up a spreadsheet to calculate it for what I was currently selling.
Now, I've been seeing in other threads about the problems with people who sell at a really low price in order to sell out very quickly and get their money fast. I know the biggest problem is that it lowers the average price and overall profits go down over the long term. I'd actually been selling at a fairly high price because I don't have the production capacity to fill up my store yet, so I'd keep the store running for more of the time and increase profits overall.
Anyway, I had a question (or two or three...). What happens if the perfect price is below the average retail price? Does this ever happen? I originally had a calculation error that caused it to happen the first time I calculated, which is what made me think of it, but I fixed the error and now it isn't. It'd still be better in the long run to have a higher price, I'd think, but I thought I'd ask.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 11:11 am
by Guest
Anyway, I had a question (or two or three...). What happens if the perfect price is below the average retail price? Does this ever happen? I originally had a calculation error that caused it to happen the first time I calculated, which is what made me think of it, but I fixed the error and now it isn't. It'd still be better in the long run to have a higher price, I'd think, but I thought I'd ask.
By perfect price I assume you mean Profit maximising price. It does happen, its has happened to me twice in the orginal Kapilands, the first time I could still earn a reasonable profit when slightly above the stats price so I set the price to that. The second time, the stats price was 150% above the perfect price and at that price my ROI was 1%ish, so I listed it slightly above the perfect price*.
*Most of the time the perfect price is slightly below the stats price.
But thats just me, others may have a better system.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 4:39 pm
by Guest
If that happens I would second think the perfect price, because that price will certainly fall if the average price is so low. I would try to sell my product fast.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 5:48 pm
by Guest
I've done the calculation for two different products now, and both times the correct answer (after I fixed my mistakes, heh) was significantly above the average selling price. Maybe later in the game this won't be the case, but for now I think I won't worry about it. Just thought I'd ask.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 5:50 pm
by Guest
Knoll's retail pricing spreadsheet is a very good tool. However, there are a couple of challenges when using it in a new economy like Kapi Regnum.
First, it assumes you can determine a good transfer price to use as the "cost" for the goods you put in your stores. In an advanced economy like Kapilands this is easy, since there are lots of goods on the market and you just take whatever the market price is for the item. In Kapi Regnum, this is not the case. Most goods are thinly traded, so you have to make an educated guess as to what the market price should be for your item.
Second, Knoll's tool calculates maximium profitability for today, and so ignores any impact that your pricing might have on tomorrow's market. As a player, you want to maximize profitability both today and tomorrow. In a new economy like Kapi Regnum, each player can have a significant impact on the average selling price of an item. In order to maximize tomorrow's profitability, you want to sell goods at a price somewhat higher than Knoll's tool. The exact amount is extremely difficult to calculate and depends on where Knoll's number is vs. where the average selling price is. I typically end up with pricing 15%-20% higher than Knoll's number when I run the math.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 5:54 pm
by Guest
Huh, I was told before that pricing 15-20% higher than the average market price was a good idea, and that's more or less what I'd been doing. If Knolls' number is higher than the average price, then your actual selling price will be even higher, and profit over time, lower.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 6:01 pm
by Guest
Hi, thanks for the plug.
Firstly, let me remind you that 50% of all sales are below average. (OK, roughly 50% because it's a mean not a mode, but bear with me.) So if you are selling above average, it's guaranteed that someone else is not. By itself that's no big deal - but if they have a more profitable price, and you sell at a
less profitable price just because, then you are injuring yourself to help this stranger.
Secondly, market prices only have so much elasticity. This is why you can't move the average of apples up to 1000 and keep selling at the same speed. All other things being equal, a higher average is better, sure. But all other things are
not equal. So if you warp your price too much, then you are sacrificing big benefits for small ones. And helping all your competitors while hurting yourself.
Now that said, the top of that profit curve is relatively flat. So you can move a bit to the higher side if you aren't too far off, particularly if it helps you balance out your production. But don't move too far, as the drawbacks outweigh the benefits.
(BTW, the curves I've drawn for Regnum are a lot steeper on the high side so I suspect the formula has changed a bit. The math still works, but this makes optimizing even more important.)
edit since I type slowly:
Cash is Kingdom wrote:First, it assumes you can determine a good transfer price to use as the "cost" for the goods you put in your stores. In an advanced economy like Kapilands this is easy, since there are lots of goods on the market and you just take whatever the market price is for the item. In Kapi Regnum, this is not the case. Most goods are thinly traded, so you have to make an educated guess as to what the market price should be for your item.
That is a very good point. You can check the German version for a price sanity check if you want, it seems our prices are pushing to the same point (partly on purpose I suspect). But I recommend using this in conjunction with some of the ROI tools for valuing your production. Some day I may update that with the method for calculating a
chain-maximized return, where you would figure out not only the optimal price, but the best ratio of manufacturing facilities to stores.
As for long-term vs short term, I covered that a bit above. If you want to vary, draw the chart anyway and you can see exactly how much profit you give up by being off the peak. Since a lower average can cost you a couple points, giving up a little profit on the high side to keep it up may balance out. But just a little, I don't think I'd deviate more than 10%. And if the average is
below where I tell you to go - I wouldn't drop at all. If that's true, then you get to have the perfect price
and move the average up. Win/win.
BTW, that's another user here who hadn't played Kapilands. I'd just assumed most people had played that first, as I know that's how I heard of this. I'm going to go to the User to User forum and start a "how did you hear about this game?" thread.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 6:10 pm
by Guest
Yes you are correct. My second point above only applies if Knoll's price is below or roughly equal to the stats price.
If Knoll's price is 15%-20% or more higher than the stats price, then using Knoll's price will maximize profitability for both today and tomorrow.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 6:16 pm
by Guest
Knolls wrote:
BTW, the curves I've drawn for Regnum are a lot steeper on the high side so I suspect the formula has changed a bit. The math still works, but this makes optimizing even more important.
Very glad you mentioned that. I have found the exact same thing.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 6:18 pm
by Guest
Cash is Kingdom wrote:Knoll's retail pricing spreadsheet is a very Second, Knoll's tool calculates maximium profitability for today, and so ignores any impact that your pricing might have on tomorrow's market. As a player, you want to maximize profitability both today and tomorrow. In a new economy like Kapi Regnum, each player can have a significant impact on the average selling price of an item. In order to maximize tomorrow's profitability, you want to sell goods at a price somewhat higher than Knoll's tool. The exact amount is extremely difficult to calculate and depends on where Knoll's number is vs. where the average selling price is. I typically end up with pricing 15%-20% higher than Knoll's number when I run the math.
Maybe for you because you are huuuuuuge! The rest of use have little impact on the market.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 7:02 pm
by Guest
You or I by ourselves may have little impact on the market, but if a lot of sellers choose a price lower than the average just because it's more profitable over time at the moment, then the average will be pulled down, and that's not good for long-term profitability. I think that's mostly what he meant.
Thanks for the clarification, Knolls, by the way.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 7:08 pm
by Guest
telyni wrote:You or I by ourselves may have little impact on the market, but if a lot of sellers choose a price lower than the average just because it's more profitable over time at the moment, then the average will be pulled down, and that's not good for long-term profitability. I think that's mostly what he meant.
Thanks for the clarification, Knolls, by the way.
No. The small producer will maximize profit with knoll's price. A very large producer may want to price a little higher to make more profit in the future.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 7:17 pm
by Guest
Yeah, exactly, I don't disagree with that. But if sellers choose a price lower than the average purely because it's profitable, then they may be affecting their future. For a small seller that might not be an issue, but if a lot of small sellers do it, then it could still affect the market.
Posted: Sun Nov 04, 2007 7:55 pm
by Guest
True. That really depends on if the market if oversupplied or not. With a normally or undersupplied market I don't think that will happen. In that market all of the suppliers could use knoll's price and the price would not fall faster than normal. Except in the case where the market is very undersupplied then you might want to sell for more (becuase future price might be higher), but that should not be an event that will usually occur.