Page 1 of 2
Gold Jewellery - Indulgences are Junks???
Posted: Sun Aug 10, 2008 4:47 pm
by Guest
In my opinion, indulgence is juck.
The only function of indulgence is increase allod....
After I invest lotssssss of money in Gold jewellery- indulgences.
I will show you something a incredible thing.
A tavern NET profit is 6 times than a indulgence.
Why the game design is so crazy and unfairable!!
Everything just playing beer-brewery-Tavern is enough!!
Seems there are misunderstanding in some people
I am talking about "Market" not "Workshop"
The optimize and working efficiency decreased only happened on "Workshop"
I present a 5640sqm tavern selling for you.
And my comparison is base on
"Each employee daily profit" in each market.

Posted: Sun Aug 10, 2008 5:14 pm
by Guest
you got that right ,they are junk

Posted: Sun Aug 10, 2008 8:14 pm
by Guest
The game is still young yet. Acording to these numbers, the indulgence market has greatly improved since I burnt mine down...
I think a year from now it will be better, I think...
I thank you Yo yo for your efforts
The littlewoman xoxox
Building size
Posted: Mon Aug 11, 2008 9:26 am
by Guest
You must also take in the difference in building size! a 2000sqm building is much more efficient per worker then a 4000 sqm building. try to compare equal sice buildings (or find out the effeciency code:P). wichever is easiest.
So i think that a 2000 sqm indulgence will score almost double profit per worker then a 4000sqm indulgence. then it is not all junk after all

I like your spreadsheet.
Posted: Mon Aug 11, 2008 9:29 am
by Guest
At first, thanks for your honesty and effort!
I have only one question:
Did you also include your workers in the production for this calculation?
You have only 100 building places and the rates between markets and productions are differently for different production groups. Even though, I also found some better and some worser products in my tests!
best regards,
Volki
Re: Building size
Posted: Mon Aug 11, 2008 9:54 am
by Guest
Sild wrote:You must also take in the difference in building size! a 2000sqm building is much more efficient per worker then a 4000 sqm building. try to compare equal sice buildings (or find out the effeciency code:P). wichever is easiest.
So i think that a 2000 sqm indulgence will score almost double profit per worker then a 4000sqm indulgence. then it is not all junk after all

I like your spreadsheet.
Thanks for your replying.
But market stalls are no relate with optimaize!!!
They are markets, not workshop~
My comparison is base on
"Each Employee daily Profits"
It means each employee can make how much profit within a day.
I have another 5640sqm tavern, the each employee daily Profits is around 7,333ct daily too. (If I sell beer more lower price, the profit will be more.)
I know the workshop sure depend on size and efficent related, but not on markets.

well
Posted: Mon Aug 11, 2008 2:21 pm
by Guest
i will accplain you something, for sqm to sqm you right, the tevern is much more profitbale but, if you expand you ingluance 6 times, and full ads, you will mack twice the money, you see, the static price will be dependeble by only you and an handful of people, so if you all rise the price, then the product will becume more proftable.
this is the basic idea behind ingluace(frogive my spelling mistakes). the bigger the faster the more proftibale, and you will have a huge chanke of the market if you have let's say amm 12ksqm inglunace.
Re: well
Posted: Mon Aug 11, 2008 8:20 pm
by Guest
matikonen wrote:i will accplain you something, for sqm to sqm you right, the tevern is much more profitbale but, if you expand you ingluance 6 times, and full ads, you will mack twice the money, you see, the static price will be dependeble by only you and an handful of people, so if you all rise the price, then the product will becume more proftable.
this is the basic idea behind ingluace(frogive my spelling mistakes). the bigger the faster the more proftibale, and you will have a huge chanke of the market if you have let's say amm 12ksqm inglunace.
Actually, the problem is the upgrading time of indulgence more longer than tavern. And a gold jewellery selling speed is extremly slow....
_________________Tavern : Indulgence
Expand time______: 18min : 30 sqm
Employee profts___:7,333ct : 1,390ct
and the top stats price of gold jewellery is 5797.1ct. I had made it in 08/03, and I test selling in the same day.
but for 12ksqm indulgence expand time, you can get a 20k tavern.
I'm SO confused with this game! :(
Posted: Wed Aug 13, 2008 12:28 pm
by Guest
I do not understand so many of these things you're posting.
I do not first and foremost understand.... WHY does the game allow a player to spend all the time and money increasing the size of a workshop... when in fact that is (by the way all of you are talking) a negative thing in the game. Why on Earth would it be better to have a smaller factory/workshop than it would to have a larger one???? Why would you not be able to produce more with a larger workshop?? It doesn't make sense to me.
Posted: Wed Aug 13, 2008 6:28 pm
by Guest
At first bigger workshops produce more than smaller ones ...
... but I think the basic idea of smaller production rates per worker for bigger workshops is that otherwise bigger cities would get bigger and bigger and smaller cities would never have a chance to follow.
The way it is, it is possible to follow the mega-cities or even overtake them in the ranking lists and this is great in my opinion!
However, this is a little off topic because alexyu7 talked about markets and not workshops!
Volki
ammmm
Posted: Wed Aug 13, 2008 10:12 pm
by Guest
what you said about expanding it's correct but you missed 1thing, i belive if you expand ur indglunce let's say to max size and also the max size of the tavern, the indlunce will be more proftibale.
Posted: Wed Aug 13, 2008 11:54 pm
by Guest
These numbers can all be worked out with a calculator and a little time well before you invest any money and take a wrong path.
Don't rage at the game because you failed to do your homework.
I should also add, if there were no wrong paths to take and success was assured it wouldn't be much of a game, would it?
Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 12:10 am
by Guest
Grenowey,
Its not that expanding is bad, its that each expansion is less of an improvement than the one before it. This is called diminishing returns. But the amount of decline is something like one half percent per employee.
Consider, the first employee you hire is the best available. The next employee is not as good. He's the second best available. The third employee is only the third best available. By the time you get to the thousandth employee, he's noticeably not as efficient as the first.
Sild suggested that at 200 workers the profit per worker is double that of 400 workers. Its an increase, but an example of diminishing returns.
Very confused still
Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 5:37 am
by Guest
kgauck wrote:Sild suggested that at 200 workers the profit per worker is double that of 400 workers. Its an increase, but an example of diminishing returns.
That just does not make any sense to me, I'm sorry. I'm not a mathematician (as I am guessing many in this game are huge lovers of math... but I'm not, I just enjoy playing the game)
How does it make any sense... that a building capable of having 200 employees earns
twice as much profit as a larger building able to have 400 employees???? Not sure what country this game is modeling itself after when it comes to determining worker efficiency. lol It's certainly not the U.S.
Posted: Thu Aug 14, 2008 10:13 am
by Guest
There are other reasons than the number of employees in the selling stores.
* costs are far away from ideal production costs
* selling over (arquebuses up to nearly 100%

) or under (beer 50ct

) the stats price
* the number of productions he needs
Lets conclude this stuff: This game is very complex and you have a lot of influencing factors but in my opinion these three cases cannot be compared!
Btw. what do you mean with:
lol It's certainly not the U.S.