Page 1 of 1

Marble ... As a Product

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 8:17 pm
by Guest
Why not have Marble available as a new item that can be dug out of the stone pit and researched at the Master Mason?? It seems we are depriving a number of players of the opportunity to specialize in a new product and make some good money.

Split from the 'Wonders of The World' topic as it fits in better as a suggestion ;)
-Therian

fair.

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2008 10:44 pm
by Guest
i'm spacelising in macking expation matirales, so why i can't marbles too?
it will be fair that who want's to invest in it could mack marbles from stone pit.
if you don't allow this , it will be a huge disatventige to players like me

Posted: Fri Jun 06, 2008 4:38 pm
by Guest
a huge disadvantage? because there's a new feature not a lot of people were counting on (except the dutch/german people..) and you can't profit from it.. it actually is the same as with the stones --> you won't sell them above the 24 cT..
Just look at it like this; producing the marble would be more costly as just buying them off the market...

macking

Posted: Fri Jun 06, 2008 11:30 pm
by Guest
let's say it will tack 50 tools , 200 water and 50ct cost to produce.

so 50 tools= 600ct
200 water= 4.8
plus 50 cost

you get 654.8 ct cost to mack, so if i will mack marbles i can mack 345 ct from it! it's a very nice profit to mack.

Posted: Sun Jun 08, 2008 1:52 pm
by Guest
well..
lets say it takes;
100 tools
1000 water
100cT

Thi will give you above 1000cT alone with tools allready, and since you can't be sure what it takes to make marble, you could just think that the developers of this game made it easier on you for if you wished to produce the marble you would've made a loss anyway..

npc

Posted: Sun Jun 08, 2008 9:47 pm
by Guest
all of the products you buy at NPC you can mack them cheaper, at least 50%

so why they will change it now?

Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 1:39 am
by Guest
Because 500cT net gain is a lot!
It is not the 6cT (50% of 12cT for the tools) anymore...

A possible solution: organising it so that it takes enormous ammounts of time to produce it. But it then will take soo much time, no one will be trying to make it anymore:
starting towns: not enough money, nothing to sell for long times (boring!)
Advanced towns: not fast enough, everything is about time! Too many other products would be more profitable


Conclusion: not interesting, for anyone
unless you wish to cripple the game setting up 1 super-product, which all towns then will make...

Theoretically it is possible to adjust and balance it indeed... but it might be hard (and taking away an "extra", reducing it to just another product)

Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 7:31 am
by Guest
why doesn't it just take higher quality tools for example:

10 q10 tools 320cT
10 water 2.4cT
10 wood 240cT
10 q0 stone 240cT

A higher and particular quality would mean that someone has to do something extra to make it. That would be good.

That is still arnd 800cT, but if the miner is making all the ingredients, then he will make an extra 200cT on top of what they would get for selling everything separately. Which is fair enough I guess. Besides ppl will buy raw material from the NPC to make marble anyway.

Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 10:49 am
by Guest
The idea of making the marble only with high quality goods might work, but is very expensive for smaller towns. This would mean only the big towns can make the marble

I'm not sure if this is what the game wishes to create...


Also, higher Q tools can be sold for higher prices, so the possible profit from the marble is reduced a lot.
As soon as some cities (guilds?) can make the marble themselves, the value of the marble will go down, making the wonders not that prestigous anymore :?

Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 4:15 pm
by Guest
Well, a 200 ct profit would *still* be OBSCENE unless production was much slower as well. As in, at least 15 times slower.

In any case, the issue is largely moot. The game mechanics don't permit Q1 stone to be made differently from Q0, and there would have to be a truly compelling reason for upjers to go through all the hassle of backing out Q1 stone in 3 diffferent languages and converting it into a new product.

Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 5:32 pm
by Guest
mate, point is to make the wonder something we can contribute to by developing a new industry. Otherwise, it would only be the plain rich or those who have a lot of coins to turn into cash into marble that would be building the quickest wonders..

I'm not saying that this is/will happen, but this is what is very likely to happen.

Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 7:33 pm
by Guest
Isnt that how everything works? The rich or the ones selling coins to the rich are able to do what they want, if that is winning contests or building wonders (or investing to become even richer).

I think that it fits with the game that the big ones can build the quickest wonders. The good part is, that if the richest ones all use their resorces to build wonders, the smaller ones will be able to grow past them and then build a wonder even faster! woohoo!

smaller towns

Posted: Mon Jun 09, 2008 9:56 pm
by Guest
i don't think that smaller towns even intrested in marbels, why they will be intrested?

and about macking the marbels. you will need q10 tools let's say, and water, and 5 falnkets of wood. or macking it more intresting, saltpatre, in order to mack explosives in order to mine it.

as i want to say, what about beer, you macking of selling it to NPC about 300%.
i buy the grain from a contrect and the water from npc, caskes i mack myself, it still cost me 55ct to mack.

i sell it in my taveren for 200ct. this is 300% profit.

from the marble you mack 100% profit so it less profitbale or cost effctive then beer for exmple

repaky

Posted: Tue Jun 17, 2008 10:58 pm
by Guest
what no wise comeback? no something smart to say about "super-product"?

and if you want to speak about super product, tack arms dealr for exmple.

you can sell in arms dealer arqubuse for 1.5k easyly, and it cost to mack something around 500 if you macking all the metirals.

why you don't say something about that?

Posted: Wed Jun 18, 2008 6:42 am
by Guest
:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D