Page 1 of 2

Discussion about private bids in the auction section

Posted: Tue May 13, 2008 4:39 pm
by Guest
[edit by elwood74: This discussion was moved here, coming from a different Thread]

Imp note: Considering bids via PM or pigeon. Well, as you know, kapi-regnum auctions do not have an automatic bidding system. And am not capable of robotically matching bids by others in the last minute.

So, for any private bid, I would publish it at the beginning of the last hour.

If you win as a result, then you will pay the average of someone's lower bid (the one that just lost) and your private bid, or the losing bid + the minimum step.

eg:-

Case 1.

There is a next highest bid (at the end of auction) of 23 million cT

I received a private bid of 29 million. I will publish this one hour prior to closing. If you win, you pay (23+29)/2 = 26 million.

Case 2.
minimum bid step is 1 million cT

There is a next highest bid (at the end of auction) of 23 million cT

I received a private bid of 24 million. I will publish this one hour prior to closing. If you win, you don't pay (23+24)/2 = 23.5 (X). You pay (23 + 1) = 24 million cT.


This is to make it fair on everyone here. And give those who can't be up at weird hours, or not at home a chance. And I still suggest getting genuine bids in well in time. Mods may want to publish this rule if they like. I think it is the fairest of what I could think of.

Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 9:04 am
by Guest
I´m sorry, but this kind of bidding cannot be accepted:

1. It´s just unfair for others if the auctioneer has a max. price in place, but no other user knows this price.
2. The bidder always has to pay the written price. There will not be any average prices.
3. If someone really wants to win an auction and cannot be online by the ending time of the auction, he will have to ask some third party (friend, trade partner, etc.) to bid for him up to a certain price. He cannot place a max. bid by IGM and tell the auctioneer to bid for him up to that price. This could also lead to some kind of corruption very quickly.

Regards.

Elwood

Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 9:29 am
by Guest
The thing is that everyone here knows how to ebay, and using that as reference, it is very possible to put in automatically increasing bids.

point is, ppl live in all sorts of time zones, so really not everyone can be online at all times.

Also, why should people have to pay tons more than the next lower bid just because they can't be online.

That is why,
To make it fair to the private bidder - I allow them to pay the lower bid + minimum step / average if the difference is too much (this is a penalty for private bidding)

To make it fairer to the board bidders - I would publish all private bids an hour before the auction ends. If they are too low, bad luck for the private bidders, but otherwise, everyone gets a whole ONE HOUR to better their bids.

It is either this or you ban private bidding, but then what is the point of online games if ppl can't play with time zone differences.

btw, who gives a heck if you got trading partners etc.. finally ur decesion is your own and nobody can bid better than you. So, really, cut the crap out. Allow private bidding, and allow everyone a fair chance to match those (sufficient time is a good idea)

Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 9:31 am
by Guest
This is absolut overpolicing.


Exactly why things get tedious and cumbersome. If you want a perfect world with no competition, then there should be no capitalism and thus no Kapi-regnum. Are you really talking for Upjers here??

Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 10:09 am
by Guest
Elwood, actually the general rule of this auctions board have not

metioned that there is no private bid.... I have already seen all the rule

of this board.

So in my opinion, if the rule is abcent, it means that anyone could do it

until you revised the rule. And it must be based on the spirit of the

board's name: Auctions.

So, he is the first one who steps the first step, and in fact, with not clear

rule, he have the right to do it. And if you hope to stop these actions, you

just revised the rule and announce again. It would be the good choice for

you :P

Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 11:01 am
by Guest
The general rules state that unpublished bids are not valid. And I have no problem with private bids, if this means bids by IGM/PM. But it has to be published in the auction thread to be a valid bid.

And once it is published, the price has to be payed, even if you overbid yourself (stated in the rules since years). You cannot say: I place a bid one hour before auction ends, but don´t pay that price, because it was just a "security bid", because I was not online at the ending time.

I also think it causes a lot problems, if bidders ask the auctioneer to bid for them up to a certain price. I already changed the auction hints in that point.

Regards.

Elwood

Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 11:08 am
by MarcusSchwarz
pk wrote:Are you really talking for Upjers here??
Yes, he is...

Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 11:38 am
by Guest
Time Zones will always be an issue, regardless of games played - In some other games the use of private bids is completely forbidden.

If someone wants to bid on an item they aren't necessarily inclined to pay the minimal increase; If the current bid is for example 17 million, and the auctioneer states a minimal increase of 500k with a buy-it-now price of say 25 million.

The bidder doesn't necessarily have to stick to that 500k minimal increase and bid 17.5million; They could easily post a 'safety net' bid of 22.5 million (for example) which means they are not paying the buy it now price, but at the same time have a solid bid in place anyway.

If they are outbid then fair enough, they tried - the only other option would be for them to buy it straight out anyway. This still applies even if there is no buy-it-now option in place. They could give a decent bid and wait and see what happens; and if they are outbid then do their best to get online to post another if at all possible.

In regards to Ebay, what you also have to consider is that they have several (10+) different site-languages, each with their own time zone appropriate to various users.
Even if you cannot understand for example Chinese you will still find goods available from China, and Hong Kong on both ebay.co.uk and ebay.com - These are appropriate to those time zones.

Now, baring in mind that midnight in Germany would be 23:00 in the UK not only are many people asleep at this time, but in case of the US which is generally 7 hours behind Germany it would only be 5pm.

Now I don't live in the US, so I don't know with any certainty, but generally most people wouldn't even arrive home from school until 4pm, and likely would either go straight out, or on to the computer at 4:30~ish - Some even have dinner at that time, but it depends on them.
Yep, they get about 30-60 minutes to bid, but they also wouldn't necessarily be checking Regnum in that time, and may still miss the auction end.

But what about those who work 9 til 5 jobs, or later? They wouldn't finish work until 5pm, and therefore the auction would have ended before they even got out of the door.

There is no 'perfect time' for everyone, but you can only try to accommodate as best you can. Perhaps the ideal time frame would be 02:00 ending on a Saturday morning, or 23:59 on a Saturday evening. This way the chance is that more people will be awake, and at home during these times and actually do get chance to bid.
If they were completely serious they'd stay until the end, but then if they were serious they'd just buy it straight out anyway.

Now, back to the subject on Private Bidding - Obviously an unpublished bid is a very dubious one. Anyone could say "Psst, whatever the final bid is I'll pay a million extra to that price" and noone would be none the wiser.

If the auction was currently at 22 million, and they posted, privately, a bid of 28 million then that would in a sense be a reserve price, but no one would know of that fact. Yes, there are reserve prices on Ebay but they have an icon which clearly state such in the first place.

Why would people want to bid privately anyway? We'd find out who they were sooner or later anyway when the auction ended as the winner would need to be stated. Perhaps they just want to try to get the 'goods' for a cheaper price, even though by bidding privately they probably end up paying more anyway.

Private Bids, or anything, should be made and posted with a limit, for example at least 12 hours before the auction ends so people can see that bid and act on it.

Obviously we need to be fair on this, but to make private bids against the rules entirely? It does seem extreme, but something along the lines of 12 hours could be both fair, and do-able. Additionally with an optional note of letting the auctioneer decide whether they accept them at all, which would need to be noted in the first thread of the post.
If they suddenly decide to say someone had sent an IGM/PM with a bid then they would be going against their own rules of the auction too.

Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 12:57 pm
by Guest
I agree to Therian. We should not forbid private bids entirely. But as we can see now, they can lead to some problems.

So if a seller accepts, a buyer could ask him to place a bid one minute before auction ends with the min. increase on the last bid. As far as I can see, it is not against the rules now, but all other people that did not contact the seller with such a private bid will most likely not have any chance of winning the auction. And since it is a private bid, no one could see that this bid was against the rules. (Bids have to include the price per unit)

PK suggested a time of one hour, Therian was thinking of 12 hours before auction ends. I think we should take something in between and say that bids by IGM or PM have to be published at least 6 hours before the auction ends.

Some other boards (e.g. at kapiland.de) don´t allow bids by IGM/PM at all. Maybe we will do the same thing here when we will have more than 14,000 user on this board, but for now I think we should still allow private bids.

Regards.

Elwood

Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 3:49 pm
by Guest
elwood74 wrote:I agree to Therian. We should not forbid private bids entirely. But as we can see now, they can lead to some problems.

So if a seller accepts, a buyer could ask him to place a bid one minute before auction ends with the min. increase on the last bid. As far as I can see, it is not against the rules now, but all other people that did not contact the seller with such a private bid will most likely not have any chance of winning the auction. And since it is a private bid, no one could see that this bid was against the rules. (Bids have to include the price per unit)

PK suggested a time of one hour, Therian was thinking of 12 hours before auction ends. I think we should take something in between and say that bids by IGM or PM have to be published at least 6 hours before the auction ends.

Some other boards (e.g. at kapiland.de) don´t allow bids by IGM/PM at all. Maybe we will do the same thing here when we will have more than 14,000 user on this board, but for now I think we should still allow private bids.

Regards.

Elwood
I really like this idea..
All I was asking for was a fair framework within which private bids can still be used. B'coz, to be honest, I do myself both like & dislike them for very obvious reasons. Now, the problem was getting all those bids, and I think the reasons for ppl putting them in are fair enough, I really did not feel like telling people to go stuff themselves. They have genuine reasons.
The absence of clear guidelines meant that I had to try n accommodate all while being fair 2 all. This was hard.
There is no 'perfect time' for everyone, but you can only try to accommodate as best you can. Perhaps the ideal time frame would be 02:00 ending on a Saturday morning, or 23:59 on a Saturday evening. This way the chance is that more people will be awake, and at home during these times and actually do get chance to bid.
If they were completely serious they'd stay until the end, but then if they were serious they'd just buy it straight out anyway.
I do try to keep all my auctions on saturday noon timings.
pk wrote:
Are you really talking for Upjers here??


Yes, he is...
Sorry if I sounded like an annoyingly loud horn, all I meant was that the game's makers would want everybody to be able to play it. And Elwood's first response was a little too 'draconian'. But, I know that in essence, he does agree with what we feel.

Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 4:07 pm
by Guest
I think that even if we would allow private automatic bids up to a certain amount, with one hour deadline before bidding stops, we would still get the same problems with timezones. But not only that, the auctioneer would be forced to be online one hour before auction ends, and that isnt always possible.

I can only see two reasons for private bids, and that is if you havent registered, or if you dont understand how the board works.

There is a very real (at least on my auctions) danger that the auctioneer doesnt check his messages till after the auction is done. Sometimes I cant get on till right after my auction is done. So if I get a private bid 6 hours before my auction is done, I might miss it, and then thats too bad for the bidder...

EDIT: Stupid norwegian cant spell...

Posted: Wed May 14, 2008 4:52 pm
by Guest
Wow, the keepers of this game have their work cut out for them on this issue.

I tip my hat to the keepers for their patience and dedication...

The littlewoman xoxox

Posted: Thu May 15, 2008 10:41 am
by Guest
pk wrote: And Elwood's first response was a little too 'draconian'. But, I know that in essence, he does agree with what we feel.
I´m sorry for that, I did not want to sound "draconian". I will try to explain myself better in the future.


To clarify another thing: No seller has to accept bids by IGM/PM. If I should get such a bid, I will publish it immediately. I will not accept any requests saying: Please publish at that date and that time. Or "publish 6 hours before auction ends." And still I might not be online for some time and might miss this private bid.

There is another reason for placing a private bid. We had the problem that the buyer could not be online when the auction ended. He send a private bid to the seller that should only be published, if some other bid would beat his last one. Bur only the seller and the buyer knew what this max. bid was. This was the point that caused this little confusion, because it is of course unfair to other bidders, who place a bid 5 min. before the ending and hope to win. In the case it caused no harm, because there was no other bidder. And in the future it is not possible any more, because private bids cannot be published in the last minute.

I´m glad that this solution seems to be fair for everyone.

Regards.

Elwood

Posted: Sat May 17, 2008 11:26 pm
by Guest
Aren't sealed bid auctions allowed?

A less painful method than automatic bid increases is for the price to be that of the *second* highest bid, period. That makes for a clean auction system with sealed bid, since the logical thing to do is to send in a bid for the absolute max you would pay. With open bidding there are problems though if somebody starts out with a very high bid.

Posted: Sun May 18, 2008 1:50 pm
by Guest
I guess a sealed bid auction by advertising through the building (or whatever trade) section should be alright.that is just an advert of sale right??? with whatever conditions. But then you have to trust the seller,.. of course.