Page 1 of 1

Available ranks and logic

Posted: Sun Feb 17, 2008 2:13 pm
by Guest
Okay, I am pretty confused about the order of the rank system. Let me use Wikipedia to show you what I mean.

Villein:

A villein was the most common type of serf in the Middle Ages. Villeins had more rights and status than those held as slaves, but were under a number of legal restrictions that differentiated them from the freeman.

Ok, that's logical.

Next, Freeman:

An individual not tied to land under the Medieval feudal system, unlike a villein or serf

Ok, that's easy enough

Next, Bourgeois:

Bourgeoisie (RP /ˌbɔː.ʒwɑːˈzi/, GA /ˌbu(r).ʒwɑˈzi/) is a classification used in analyzing human societies to describe a social class of people who are in the upper or merchant class, whose status or power comes from employment, education, and wealth as opposed to aristocratic origin. Petite bourgeoisie (also Petty Bourgeoisie) is used to describe the class below the bourgeoisie but above the Proletariat.

Ok, it pretty much means that a bourgeois is a person from the middle to upper class. But here it gets funky.

Introducing, Huckster:

A huckster is a seller of small articles, usually of cheap or shoddy quality, or one engaged in haggling or making petty bargains, that is, a certain type of peddler or hawker.

Well, that's not pretty good. Actually, I like the title Bourgeois a lot better than this one.

Next up, SIr:

Sir is an English honorific used in several modern contexts.

It was once used (without the person's name) as a courtesy title among equals, but in common usage it is now usually reserved for one of superior rank or status, such as an educator or commanding officer, or in age (especially by a minor); as a form of address from a merchant to a customer; in formal correspondence (Dear Sir, Right Reverend Sir); or to a stranger (Sir, you've dropped your hat).

So, basically it is a simple courtesy title. I still like Bourgeois better than this one.

Getting strange now, Merchant:

Merchants function as professionals who deal with trade, dealing in commodities that they do not produce themselves, in order to produce profit.

Wow, that mean pretty much nothing.... I mean, that's what this game is about right?

I could go on and on about this, but I think people take my point now.

That is all :p

Posted: Sun Feb 17, 2008 9:14 pm
by Guest
And you stopped long before it got interesting!

Anyways, first of all, I would have to guess that the game designers reserve the right to use whatever titles they darn well wish. To be honest, though, I would have used a slightly different titling scheme.

Secondly, we are seeinga mixture of different cultures and languages in the titling scheme. Bourgeois was a French term, sir is an English term for a title that was common throughout medieval Europe and usually referred to knighthood. Councillor and Patrician were Italian titles and could often be found in years of Republics and duchies. Prince-Bishop was a German Elector title from the Holy Roman Empire days (and was actually a bit rare). Esquire is one of those odd terms that started out as an assistant to a knight and later evolved to a town/hamlet official.

So we have a hodge podge of different titles and influences. I would recommend a restructuring of the titling scheme, but wouldn't worry about it too much overall.