Variable market prices based on real time prices

Ideas how the game could be improved and suggestions for subsequent versions of the game. (this is just a space for ideas! We can't guarantee suggestions will be implemented!)

Moderator: moderators

Guest

Variable market prices based on real time prices

Post by Guest »

Warning! long post

I have read the threads on fixed minimums and maximums for market prices. This idea is different as it does not use a fixed pricing structure but instead a dynamic one. This will also eliminate to cheating of dumping goods onto the market for 0.01 caps and the opposite extreme of the 650,000.00 caps for a single unit of water/steel/etc. The other big plus is that the programmers already have all the data they need for this, so here it is...

First, the program will find what is the current average price per unit of each trade item. Ex:
300 oranges @ 4.00 = 1,200.00 caps
100 oragnes @ 3.50 = 350.00 caps
1000 oranges @ 3.00 = 3,000.00 caps
Pretending that the above represents the entire market we have 1,400 oranges with a combined total value of 4,550.00 caps for an average per orange price of 3.25. I know that when I click on 'oranges' the program displays all this information except average price so it probably already exists in a database.

Now some set percentage variance needs to exist. Let's say it is 50%. The minimum price allowed to post would be 3.25 * 0.50 = 1.63. The maximum price would be 3.25 *1.50 = 4.88. So lets say that someone dumps 500 oranges at 1.63. We now have:
300 oranges @ 4.00 = 1,200.00 caps
100 oragnes @ 3.50 = 350.00 caps
1000 oranges @ 3.00 = 3,000.00 caps
500 oranges @ 1.63 = 815.00 caps
So now our total market is 1,900 oranges with a new total value of 5,365.00 caps for an average per orange price of 2.82. If someone snatches up those 'cheap' dumped oranges then the market average automatically reverts to the previous 3.25 per orange. If someone wants to try to dump more oranges before those 500 are taken then the new minimum becomes 2.82 * 0.50 = 1.41 and the new maximum becomes 2.82 * 1.50 = 4.23. This step would obviously require the programmers to write something into every market posting that would have to then run a function call to this limit. I think most programmers would find this pretty straight forward since every entry level programming class deals with limiting input into fields.

The new issue that would come up is what to do with the oranges that are at a higher price if the price naturally continues to fall. I would propose a safe zone of an extra 20% for any items on the market. Once items fall out of that safe zone they are returned to the company that posted them. Using the above example of a new minimum of 1.41 and maximum of 4.23, lets say that someone had oranges at a higher amount posted. First, 4.23 *1.20 = 5.08. This is then a safe zone of 4.23 to 5.08 where anyone who already has oranges posted would still have their product available for purchase but no new oranges could be posted above the 4.23 number. So we have bounded the market dynamically and still allow for quick drops without burning a player with a valid, albeit high price. This may be where the programming gets trickier as there is nothing currently in the game that allows for dropping off a sale, except a reset of an account. In fact, most of the offerings at present that are 1,000% or more above the real market price are from people who stopped playing the game weeks ago so something like this may be a good separate idea anyway.

Finally, what to do about the different quality of goods. Two options would exist, either keep the above mentioned calculations separate based on quality ( a bad idea since there are some sectors, like advertising, that may only have 1 or 2 postings at a time at different qualities). The other option woud be to set another percentage into the calculation as a higher bound, say 25% per quality level increase based on the quality 0 price. Using our very first example of an average orange at 3.25 with a bound of 1.63 to 4.88 we would have quality 1 at 4.88 * 1.25 or 6.10 as an upper limit price so 1.63 to 6.10 , quality 2 at 4.88 * 1.50 = 7.32 or 1.63 to 7.32. This should also be fairly easy for the programmers to get these numbers.

So there it is, the longest post for a new idea ever. However, it shouldn't slow down the game either since whenever I click on 'oranges' or 'advertisements' or 'power' the game instantly displays those items and can even sort by quality or price so this is all being tracked already.

Of course Tycoon and company would have to come up with reasonable percentages since my are for example purposes anyway.

James
Supragoods Inc
suddenly growing lots of crappy lemons

Image
Last edited by Guest on 14.03.2007, 06:31, edited 1 time in total.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I like your idea, it would really help keep prices were they should be... no 00.01
Guest

Post by Guest »

This is a great suggestion and analysis, except that I can't agree with the part about automatically dropping the higher priced offers if the entire market moves downward.

Market forces change quickly over time, and why should those that placed their materials on the market for a price that may have seemed 'pie in the sky' when they placed it lose out because it took a long time and a big market fluctuation for them to finally get that price. Take this contest with Lemons for example....extreme conditions yes, but the next contest will come without warning and we won't know what the product is in advance.

For inactive accounts, I don't know how the admins would arbitrarily decide what the cutoff in days is for someone to log in and keep their account. Maybe they already do a periodic cleansing of the database and remove inactive accounts. If they do, it's definitely appropriate to remove any and all offer that these accounts have on the market.
Guest

Post by Guest »

yes there is a point there

with the contest the market has been really diferent because the stimulation of the contest has ahuge influence on the market, the price of the lemon jumped from 2 caps to 50 in a matter of days but after this is over the lemon price will go down to the original price

it is a good idea to prevent cheater you have but if they were no cheater you do not need to put any restriccion

if you have some microeconomic concept then you will understand me better but to make it easier there will always be some people putting the item to a very expensive price and to a very cheap price but the market will self regulate depending on the demand and on the offer!!!

almost in all the games they are cheaters some are smarter than other but i think we have to find a better solution (maybe if the admin as a register of all market transaction he could look at the cheapest transaction in every category and easily identify a cheater)
Guest

Post by Guest »

My suggestion actually allows for an upswing of prices. Take the lemons or steel for instance. The reason the price moved up was because the lower prices goods were bought up quickly. People posted new product at a higher price than before thus raising the average price upward. Eventually those higher priced goods were bought.

I will admit that it does not take into account those super-speculators who put goods out in all categories at 1000% or more over current prices. This did work out really well for the lemon speculators... or did it? If they instead held their goods for sale later their 20.00 cap lemons would have sold for 40.00 to 70.00 caps. However, in the end you are right about lemons since the market first started dropping dramatically (from 4.00 caps minimums to 3.00 caps minimums in just under a month) so those that were priced higher would have been dropped using my suggestion.

It looks like I was unclear about the dropping of players. I should have elaborated and said that their account should just be hidden, not purged, for a period of time determined by the Kapilands team, hopefully represented by weeks and not days. Again realizing that this is something that does not currently exist (hide my account) it may not be a simple thing to do.

Lastly, I suspect that the Kapilands team really wishes to support their more regular players since we tend to buy coins to support their game. I also suspect that most people will dedicate time at least once a week to maintaining their account and partnerships unless they are on vacation.

By the way, thanks racingtiger for the positive comments on the suggestion and analysis. It is greatly appreciated.

James
Supragoods Inc

Image
Last edited by Guest on 14.03.2007, 16:32, edited 1 time in total.
Tycoon
Moderator off duty
Posts: 1911
Joined: 21.01.2007, 11:04

Post by Tycoon »

I do have no idea at all about the work for the programmers on this... just telling you in advance, as they would have to decide such a proposal.

But I now thought about this proposal, which is (in my mind) a good one. Just thought:
There are only very few offers on the market for some products (I now clicked only some of them and found e.g. glass with only 30 offers. The biggest offer consists fo 1,000 items with a total price of 28,000.

So what, if now someone wants his best friend to have 1 glass for 600,000 caps (which happens.. unfortunately)? The average price allowed from the new "market tool" would jump immediately. This is not a seldom case... there are more products which have only a few offers on the market. I did not calculate this example with the glasses... and I am not good in calculating at all ;-) but I fear that both, an offer of 600,000 as well as one of 0,01 (or say 10 of 0,01) could really bother the producers of the respective product.
Guest

Post by Guest »

The new issue that would come up is what to do with the oranges that are at a higher price if the price naturally continues to fall.
My question is what about those of a lower price do they also disappear. If the price is raising.

You could also have big players dumping huge quanties on the market to drive prices down.

Somebody might be putting things on the market at a high price, because they know, while they won't sell right away, they will sell within X amount of time, and the way they are playing their company suits their r/l(real life) commitments.

Don't get me wrong i like the idea, but at the moment i feel it's aimed at keeping prices low, if it could be altered so anything that happens to high prices outside the range also happens to low prices outside the range.

The other thing is the 10% it costs to put things on the market, this is what should be discouraging people from putting things on the market at silly high prices. So it's the low pirces that need stopped not the high ones.

The problem is when a new player buys stuff below production costs, becasue lets be honest here. if you've spent any amount of time in the forums your well aware of the problem and you know you shouldn't buy below production costs. With the simplier products this is easy enough to work out, but for some of the more complex products, it could be easy for a slightly older newbie to still make the mistake.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Hi Tycoon, I'm really glad you chose glass. I think it has a good number set to work with. Plus it lets us use a real game example instead of the numbers that I made up in the initial post. Below are all of the current offers for glass (we were lucky because they all fit on one page). I've color coded them by quality. I'll first tabulate the totals for quality zero, get the average price, give the range using my suggestion above and then show what the range would be for the higher qualities.

Ware Company Quality price/each price/all Action
1,307 Glass Golden Water 3 44.00 57,508.00 buy

260 Glass Bruin Industries 0 24.00 6,240.00 buy
1,800 Glass World Power AG 0 24.00 43,200.00 buy
52 Glass G T 0 25.00 1,300.00 buy
100 Glass DORIANA 0 26.00 2,600.00 buy
352 Glass Bruin Industries 0 28.00 9,856.00 buy
250 Glass Gnaulers 1 38.00 9,500.00 buy
778 Glass Continuum Corp 0 27.99 21,776.22 buy

18 Glass DelVanda VaRn 1 37.00 666.00 buy

100 Glass HPLtuning 0 28.00 2,800.00 buy
1,000 Glass HPLtuning 0 28.00 28,000.00 buy
500 Glass Braga Global 0 28.00 14,000.00 buy
19 Glass CRASH RACING 0 44.00 836.00 buy
69 Glass TORO 0 29.50 2,035.50 buy

30 Glass King 2 50.00 1,500.00 buy
450 Glass Ventrue 2 38.00 17,100.00 buy

350 Glass SwiftCorp 0 29.00 10,150.00 buy
98 Glass RickD Inc 0 33.50 3,283.00 buy
860 Glass webby inc 0 40.00 34,400.00 buy
64 Glass Fear Factory 0 38.00 2,432.00 buy
910 Glass EG Corp 0 34.00 30,940.00 buy
192 Glass Monsters Inc 0 45.00 8,640.00 buy
500 Glass Braga Global 0 35.00 17,500.00 buy
677 Glass EG Corp 0 35.00 23,695.00 buy
346 Glass procova 0 42.50 14,705.00 buy
161 Glass whipper-snapper 0 44.00 7,084.00 buy
359 Glass DELIRIO 0 45.00 16,155.00 buy
400 Glass whipper-snapper 0 65.00 26,000.00 buy


Total quality 0 glass = 9,947
Total price/all glass = 327,627.7
average quality 0 price = 327,627.7 / 9,947 = 32.94

I'll use my 50% range and 20% safe zone from the first post.

32.94 * 0.50 = 16.47
32.94 * 1.50 = 49.41
49.41 * 1.20 = 59.29

So the range would be bounded by 16.47 through 49.41.
The safe zone would be 49.42 through 59.29.

With the numbers above we see that there is only one offer outside of the range and even outside of the safe zone. This is whipper-snapper's offer of 400 glass for 65.00 each. Dropping that offer changes or numbers like this:

Total quality 0 glass = 9,547
Total price/all glass = 301,627.7
average quality 0 price = 301,627.7 / 9,547 = 31.59

31.59 * 0.50 = 15.80
31.59 * 1.50 = 47.39
47.39 * 1.20 = 56.87

So the new range would be bounded by 15.80 through 47.39.
The safe zone would be 47.40 through 56.87.

Interestingly, that player has a second offer of 161 glass for 44.00 so they may have already realized their price was too high to sell. Another point is the age of their 65.00 offer. When you look at the offers for a specific market they dispaly by newest offer at the top of the first page and oldest offer at the bottom of the last page (before selecting your sorting option). 65.00 is the very last item listed. This means that it is the oldest offering on the glass market so it has been ignored by purchasers for a very long time.

Dealing with the other qualities we have:
quality 1 47.39 * 1.25 = 59.24
quality 2 47.39 * 1.50 = 71.09
quality 3 47.39 * 1.75 = 82.93

These are some big upper limits but the lower limit stays at 15.80.

So now that we have all of the numbers we will now get back to your question of a person offering glass to a friend for 600,000.00. When the person tries to enter the amount they will get the notice that the most glass can be offered for is 47.39 so no offer can be entered past that amount until huge quantities at higher amounts get offered. This would be on the magnitude of 10,000 units of glass being offered for 47.39 would make the new average 39.68 with bounds of 19.84 through 59.52. So now while any cheater has a larger amount they can offer (59.52) there are twice as many goods affecting that price so their next offer would have to contain twice as many goods to affect the price as significantly. In fact, 20,000 goods at 59.52 would make the new average 49.71 and the new upper limit 74.57. So this cheater has to care about the game enough to have produced thousands upon thousands of product to give their friend that one piece at a very high price. It can be done too. If cash money brothers, Made In Switzerland and Johnny Inc all get together they could push the price that high.

So there it is, a real data sample based on an actual in game item. It would probably be useful to use this example to discuss instead of my initial post since this is real game data.

I would ask that anyone who is interested in this suggestion open Excel or another spreadsheet program and try the caluculation with your favorite product.

Also with regards to the programmers, they have already set limits on data that can be entered. That is why if you enter a letter or a negative number (ex, -2.00) in a field the game responds with this:
But some payment data is wrong now!

Maybe you should check your own amount of products again and the price maybe, too..
But I'll let them tell you about the IF THEN statement they used in the program.

James
Supragoods Inc


Image
Last edited by Guest on 14.03.2007, 15:45, edited 2 times in total.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Hi Walthir,

No, lower prices are not meant to dissappear. If large quantities are dumped on the market at a higher price then the lower limit that can be offered is increased by my formula. If the lowest priced goods are purchased (and those are always the ones that get purchased first) then the average price automatically shifts upwards as well.

Think about steel as well. A month ago you could buy steel for 75.00 caps. You would never buy it at 80.00 caps. Then the lower priced steel was purchased so quickly that the price of 130.00 caps became the norm. If someone put 80.00 cap steel on the market now it would be purchased instantly. The players make sure that prices are not kept low by buyng all of the low priced items.

You will see that this would have worked with the lemon craze as well. As soon as the contest was announced all of the 3.00 to 4.00 caps lemons were purchased. The average price increased because of this. New lemons went on the market at a much higher price and also raised the average price. This process continued until we've settled into our nice price of 70.00 caps per lemon. I think someone offering lemons at 3.00 caps now would be banned for cheating anyway! With my suggestion the lowest lemons could be offered for would be around 50.00 caps and the highest would be around 150.00 caps. This assumes an average based on 100.00 caps but I am just quickly guessing that average and not calculating it out. I recommend doing the calculations yourself and seeing what results you get for the average and bounds of what people can offer the goods for.

As for your concern about newbies buying below production costs, you need to analyze the markets first. Most goods are offered at 5 times to 20 times their production costs. Water, power and steel fall into the 5 times category. My system would limit the lowest postable price to 'average price * 0.50' which would still be 2.5 times higher than the production cost.

James
Supragoods Inc


Image
Guest

Post by Guest »

Geraci:

you didn't consider the possibility of buying products (removing them from the data used to count the bounds)

so all glass in the market can be bought for 327k, if they buy it, they can sell glass for any price, so it's just that easy to trick this system
Guest

Post by Guest »

Where as at present no one can do that? This problem already exists. Anyone can go buy all the products of a type and resell them at absurd prices.

Okay, so what is your suggestion to fix it?

I have one in mind but it is probably better if someone else tries to help support this idea. If no one does then this is a dead idea anyway.

James
Supgragoods Inc


Image
Guest

Post by Guest »

I don't think you understand my point, and it does relate to the % allowed for each product, which i admit is yet to be decided

say for example, I wanted to put lemons on the Market at 70 at the start of the contest, under this system i would have been unable to. This assumes people havn't yet bought all the cheap ones. now i might be a player who only plays every couple of days, once a week, and can't wait for players to purchase, because of real life commitments.

Certain times of the day are more active than other times of the day, this could penalize players based on the time of the day they play. I've seen these movements in the market.

At the very start of the contest i was here for it, i got offered privately 12caps per lemon for my entire production, which at the time was 4 caps over the top fax and forum price of 8. At the time this was offered I thought it was a very generous offer. By the time my first batch of product was complete the price had risen to 44.

You are majorly slowing down the price increase in the market, during contests, because not everyone can afford to buy the cheap ones so they can place the higher price they want to.

You are also penalizing the smaller player, a big player can afford to dump huge quanties to bring the price of something down. If a big player dumps millions on the market, where does that leave the small player, other than following the big players price leads. If you go into a local shop you pay more for the same goods as you would going into a supermarket.

Your assumpation that the cheapist is always bought first may not be true, for example someone may have had bad dealings in the past, and have self imposed a ban on buying from partcualr comapines. (for example unhonoured contracts)

My concern is for the newbies, not me, i am very careful with the market, I was merely trying to explain this being accused of cheating seems kinda harsh on a true newbie, because in a capilist world, people will sell things at a loss, in order to make more money elsewhere. So if they are buying cheap things they see it as a bonus they found not a breach of the rules. May a solution is to flash the rules infront of the players more often. Say the first time they log in, in a day they have to agree to them again. How many of you would hate that? You could set to once a week, or a month. Cause if we are again 100% honest, how much sinks in from the reading of rules when you sign upto a game. The market price thing, didn't sink into my skull until reading the forums.

The other problem will be when you set the extra % allowed for quality, this would need to be figured out for different products, In fact all the %'s would have to worked out for indivual products or groups.

Because when you look at a movement of 10% on a price of 0.10 compared to 10% on the price of a 1000, you will see how little movement you are allowing at the smaller price and how much more you allowing at the higher one. So while it may not be much work code wise, it would be alot figuring out what % to use where. I know you didn't say a % was using 10% just as an example.

I also don't know where you get the idea europeans go on holiday for a month, the only people i know who get such long holidays in the UK are teachers, and having friends who are teachers the 6 week summer holiday only really works out at 2-4 weeks, because the rest of the time, they are in school doing various courses. or at home working on paperwork. I also lived in germany for a year, and don't remember anything shutting down for a month or anyone going on holiday for that length of time. Now occasionally some firms over here allow people to take unpaid leave, or to save up all the holiday and take it all at once. In the UK anunal leave works out roughly at 20 days(work days) a year plus bank holidays. Most peoples biggest holiday is two weeks.

As I said before I like the idea, it's just needs safeguards on prices being driven down to the advantage of the big player and the disadvantage of the small, and yes in steel market it's not a problem, but what about the less popular markets.

If you want to try show it in a spreadsheet, may i make the suggestion that you take a look at google docs and spreadsheets, that way it can be published rather than people all having to make there own.
Guest

Post by Guest »

1, Contests do have a crazy effect on the market. Its just part of the fun. In this game its contests that are the exogene market factors. In the real world it could be some guy saying lemons will be all gone by 2008. The contests therefore actually ad realism. We need to have these effects. It also makes speculation a lot more fun. One might invest in a ware or industry they wouldn't normally go into. Cause if there is a contest... ur gonna make a lot of money. Think of it as yourself buying stock in technology that might be 10 years ahead of its time. Could make you broke and it can make you rich.

2, You assume that all big players will dump prices just to ruin the game for others? That is NOT how they got to be big. Kapilands works pretty much with a neoclassical economic framework and one big player wouldn't have that effect on the game. If one big player started dumping prices another big player would buy it all and wait for the price to go up agian. The effect would be minimal. Maybe a few panicads by minor players but nothing crucial.

3, The argument of infringing the free market just to make the game more attractive to people not beeing able to spend every day on this game is terrible. There are people that spend many hours into this game. They should be able to do that and make a profit out of it. If someone cant spend as much time with it, they probably don't care THAT much about beeing the biggest company. With the right managing it won't make THAT much difference if you only log on every other day or so. You will loose out on time to build buildings and research but production can still be done. Think of it as the production cycle having a much lower frequency but the same output.

The bottom line is the barriers you want to set up are terrible and would ruin the game for the most dedicated players.
Guest

Post by Guest »

Thanks Walthir for the response.

I should first say that my vacation comment seems to be based on misinformation that I received as a youth. Thank you so much for letting me know what the truth is. I have cut out that sentence in my original post. I feel silly. Thanks again.

I agree, putting this into google spreadsheets is a great idea. I'll do that when I have time to run through these calculations again. As it stands I've burned through way too many hours already. If someone else does it before me that would be great otherwise I'll do it when I am on again.

I agree that it would force the market to move slower than normal. In the U.S. we have put that kind of unrealistic manipulation on a market that we have here. It is the stock market, known to many as Wall Street. After the big crash in the 1980's there was a new measure created and it was acted upon as follows:
Following a 554.26 point drop in the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) on October 27, 1997, officials at the Exchange for the first time invoked the "circuit breaker" rule to stop trading. This was a very controversial move and prompted a quick change in the rule; trading now halts for an hour, two hours, or the rest of the day when the DJIA drops 10, 20, or 30 percent, respectively. In the afternoon, the 10 and 20% drops will halt trading for a shorter period of time, but a 30% drop will always close the exchange for the day. The rationale behind the trading halt was to give investors a chance to cool off and reevaluate their positions.
taken from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_Stock_Exchange

So again I absolutely and completely agree with you. This would limit the market during things like the great lemon craze of '07 but these things tend to exist in our real world. I don't say that I agree or disagree with such flagrant manipulation but I do say that there is a certain reality to it.

The truth is there was a time in stock market history when the prices of stocks were raised by people who owned large shares of certain stocks. When the price was really high they dumped all of their shares knowing that the price was artificially inflated by them. I think this preceded the crash of the 1920's and the Great Depression in America but I'm not going to research that just now. My main point being, bad manipulaion does occur.

I'll also say right now that I don't like my own suggeston. I wish there wasn't a need to try to control the market artificially. I wish the people who do these bad deals were using their own money, selling off their own goods for 0.01 caps a piece or paying 65,000.00 to post something at 650,000.00 but the truth is this is a game, its not real money and we might want to suggest some ways to control these problems.

I also completely agree with the fact that the cheapest goods might not be bought first. I personally check out the net worth of companies selling their goods and will usually try to buy from a smaller supplier even if I have to pay a few extra caps to avoid buying from a larger player. I think that there are enough people buying from the bigger companies that those products will still go fairly quickly. It would be tough for some companies to screw over all 10,000 players in this game (I have no idea how many of us there are, but my point being a low priced good should sell quickly even if passed over by a few people like you and me).

I agree, yet again, about calling the newbies cheaters. I personally don't think that selling power, water, steel, wood or stone for 0.01 can be considered cheating when they paid 0.00 for it. Their production costs are 0.00 for even though fair market value dictates a more realistic cost and price.

Hey, I completely agree on the % for quality needing to be assessed and analyzed based on different goods. It may not be workable. I don't know what the real percentages should be. The people selling advertisements are forcing a price fixing structure on all advertisements sold. (Honest, read their thread on it!) So the percentage thing may not be workable at all. What would be your alternative to this?

I'm really concerned about your last point too, the big companies driving prices down. Bringing up another real world example, when Netscape was happily selling their Navigator 4.0 for $40.00 a box, Microsoft came along with Internet Explorer for free! That is $0.00, even worse than our worse 'cheater/newbie' here selling goods for 0.01 caps. Later Netscape got aquired by AOL so that potentially awesomme company became a footnote in Internet history. So this does happen in the real world, the question remains of how can we prevent it from happening here using the constraints of Kapilands programming team or funding for the programming team if they're outsourcing that work.

So I agree all of your points and you agree that this may not be a fully fleshed out solution. What modifications can you make to have this work?

James
Supragoods Inc
Last edited by Guest on 14.03.2007, 20:56, edited 1 time in total.
Guest

Post by Guest »

I think that anything that automatically adjusts your price is a bad idea..

#1 as owner of a company I have the right to price goods for what I feel they are worth. Granted the constant undercutting annoys the heck out of me.. but in reality its what happens and honestly nothing you can or should do to stop it.

#2 its open to market manipulation.. Whats to keep someone from dropping 10 batches of goods into 1 market each time hitting the lowest allowable price dropping the price of the market overall.

What would be better is if the market alerts you if the system thinks your price is out of line.. Like that time I sold wood for .25 instead of 25 darn decimal places..

I'm against anything that takes control away from me.
Post Reply